• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Both "The Speckled Band" and "Lamb to the Slaughter" have ingredients for a detective story, i.e. they both have a murderer who is cold and calculating, and just that little bit mad.

Extracts from this document...


Key Stage 4 Wide Reading Coursework Mary Maloney and Dr. Grimesby Roylott are both murderers. Examine their similarities and differences as portrayed by the authors I have been reading 'The Speckled Band' by Sir Arthur Conan-Doyle and 'Lamb to the Slaughter' by Roald Dahl. Written in 1892 and 1954 respectively. Both "The Speckled Band" and "Lamb to the Slaughter" have ingredients for a detective story, i.e. they both have a murderer who is cold and calculating, and just that little bit mad. On the other hand, they are presented to us very differently, making one story very typical of its genre, and making the other very untypical of the murder mystery genre. The Speckled Band tells the story of Sherlock Holmes investigating into a case, where a girl has died under suspicious circumstances and the witness is suspected to follow the same fate. The story, though centred on Holmes, is told as seen through the eyes of his companion, Dr Watson. Unlike Dahl's story this is a classic 'whodunit', with plenty of suspense. Lamb to the Slaughter follows a woman who learns her husband is leaving her and proceeds to kill him. A police investigation follows but she is found innocent. What separates this murder mystery from others is the character it focuses on, whereas many stories concentrate on the detective or sometimes the victim, this story concentrates on the character of the murderer. ...read more.


For this reason Dahl instead used a character that was more unexpected to his audience. The detectives in both stories are portrayed differently in their attitude towards the murderers. In The Speckled Band Holmes is presented as an observant, intelligent and committed detective, which is the typical investigators role in a murder mystery. He and Watson can also be seen as mischievous at times. Evidence of this can be seen on page 165, with the line "...Holmes the Scotland Yard Jack-in-office," Holmes chuckled heartily, "Your conversation is most entertaining..." In The Speckled Band Holmes' detective skills are outstanding. He is the classic detective. He has a clear and very sharp ability to deduce even the most complex mysteries, a gift which Dr Watson admires greatly. He says 'I had no keener pleasure than in following Holmes in his professional investigations, and admiring...(the way in which)...he unravelled the problems which were submitted to him.' By contrast the detectives involved with Mary Maloney in Lamb to the Slaughter are very gentle. They view her as helpless and so they provide all the support they can. This leads to them overall being portrayed as foolish. This is because they are straight away taken in by Mary Maloney's act, and as such are blinded from the truth. The result is that the case is never solved. The detectives are as unobservant as Holmes is observant, as unintelligent as Holmes is intelligent, and as uncommitted as Holmes is committed. ...read more.


Roylott has also killed before, whereas this is a first for Mary. Another big difference is that Mary doesn't get caught, Roylott does. Overall I didn't like the character of Grimesby Roylott. This is not because he is an unpleasant character; I wouldn't base my views on the way he is portrayed. The reason for my view is the fact that his character has been done so many times before that it fails to make any lasting impression. As soon as he is introduced into the story most people recognise that he is the murderer by the way he complies with a tried and tested stereotype. So it then becomes a case of wanting to know how it is done rather than who does it. However I do like the character of Mary Maloney for the opposite of this. To begin with the way she is introduced into the story raises no suspicions, she seems to be a normal, pleasant character. But this changes with the sudden change in events and your whole perception is thrown into confusion. The aspect I particularly like about her is the way she holds the stage. She is always the focus of the story but I never got bored of her, the turn in events kept me trying to understand her throughout. She fits into no stereotype, and that's what I like. I can't stand seeing the same 'text book' characters recycled again and again, I enjoy originality and the character of Mary Maloney is perfect example of it. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Roald Dahl section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Roald Dahl essays

  1. Stone Cold.

    I acted the fool, the silly old do-gooder and it worked like a dream. I could see Link the Stink standing under the trees trying to shelter from the rain. I made a big show of calling the cat and acting concerned about it being in the rain.

  2. Both The Speckled Band and Lamb to the Slaughter share some characteristics of the ...

    However I don't think the suspense comes till much later on in the story "Holmes for a moment was a startled as I. His hand closed like a vice upon my wrist in his agitation. Then he broke into a low laugh and put his lips to my ear."

  1. Compare ‘The Adventure of The Speckled Band’ and ‘Lamb to the Slaughter’ referring to ...

    is not planned, therefore there are no weird goings on or red herrings, the police make the Red Herrings themselves by saying it was a man that committed the crime. The Maloney household is an unexpected place for a murder scene because there is nothing there to prove that a

  2. Compare and contrast the two short stories "The Speckled Band" by Sir Arthur Conan-Doyle, ...

    appearance gives a prediction of what the personality may be like, in this case evil. If you had heard what Helen Stoner had told Holmes, you would assume that this man was the same man whose 'violence of temper approaching mania' resulted in 'long term imprisonment' in India because 'in

  1. Compare and Contrast "Lamb To the Slaughter" with "The Speckled Band".

    After this Mary Maloney simply walked up behind him and with a single skull crushing blow crashed the frozen leg of lamb directly to the back of his head, "At that point Mary Maloney simply walked up behind him and without any pause she swung the big frozen leg of

  2. I am going to compare and contrast the two short stories "The Speckled Band" ...

    He has 'deep-set, bile shot eyes' and a 'high thin fleshless nose, which gave him the resemblance of a fierce bird of pray' Dr Roylott seems to be very evil from the start. Watson said that his face was 'marked with every evil passion' and this appearance gives a prediction

  1. Compare and contrast the two short stories "The Speckled Band" by Sir Arthur Conan-Doyle, ...

    With the murderers, Conan-Doyle went with the more traditional approach, making him very typical. The character of the murderer is Dr Roylott, a very violent man. You can assume that he is the murderer in this story just by the description Dr Watson gives of him.

  2. Compare both the 'The speckled band' and 'Lamb to the slaughter' to a typical ...

    Helen or Julia didn't get married, but if they did a certain amount of the money would go to them. This was a strong motive for the doctor to have committed the murder. . Sherlock Holmes got interested in the case because he saw a challenge in it.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work