• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the 1963 and 1990 version of 'Lord of the Flies.' Which is the most helpful for students of the text?

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the 1963 and 1990 version of 'Lord of the Flies.' Which is the most helpful for students of the text? I am writing an essay on the comparison of the two films. Which were the black and white written by Peter Brooks in 1963 and the Technicolor version written by Harry Hook in 1990. In my essay I will also examine which of the two versions were in the spirit of Golding's novel and which was more useful to students of the text. I will also explore media techniques and how the main themes and the characters are portrayed. The black and white version was most in the spirit of Golding's novel. This film was made by Peter Brooks, whom had a cast of British schoolboys taken to Vieques, a Caribbean island. After three months Peter got the boys to act out the novel, which actually had little direction from Peter Brooks. In the plot events they were meant to have missed a ship, but instead they missed a plane, when Jack let the fire go out, however most events were kept true to the novel. ...read more.


Harry Hook, who made the film in America, made the colour version. It included characters that are not in the original novel. In the plot events Jack paints his face with pig's blood instead of mud. Ralph and Piggy found instruments on the scar. They miss a helicopter instead of a ship; the bigguns bury the littluns in the sand, instead of throwing stones at them. They also included scenes of Ralph fishing and another scene were Piggy comes up with the idea of building a raft, which isn't in the novel. They don't have any initial meeting because they already know each other, and another big event in the film was when the boys rescued a grown-up off the plane. The characters are a little different, as Roger has ginger hair. There is a new character called Peter. They also left out the character with the birthmark on his face, and they are all sea cadets. The music in the colour version is used constantly to influence the scenes events and character personalities. ...read more.


Ralph is generally kept like the book in the films. However the two film versions did have many different aspects. Like in the colour version the boys already know each other and are part of the sea cadets, but in the black and white version they don't know each other, except for half do because they belong to a the choir. Everyone in Hook's version knows piggy, but in Brooks version they don't. The colour version is least like he novel. They also use a lot of swearing for the colour version. My conclusion for the comparison of the two film versions is that out of the two films Peter Brooks black and white version of the story is most useful to students of the text. This is because this version is most like the novel, where as the Technicolor had so much added information to the parts of the story, it sort of side tracked away from the original story. Which would make the novel harder to understand. However the Technicolor was quite useful because it is a modern day interpretation of the book. By Guneeta Bagga ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE William Golding section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE William Golding essays

  1. Compare and contrast the 1963 and 1990 version of 'Lord Of The Flies' - ...

    The beast is a major theme in Golding's original novel. It is the manifestation of the boys' innermost fears of the evil that resides inside themselves. The video versions treat the beast in different ways. In Hook's version the idea of a beast is introduced through Jack as he is telling stories around a campfire.

  2. Our Country's Good, Plot and Subplot

    They discuss the meaning of the play. Wisehammer gives Ralph a prologue to read and they begin to practise the play again shortly after. As they practise, they all talk about their characters and discuss opinions of them and the storyline itself. * Dabby and Wisehammer make very slight and subtle digs at Ralph about Marry such as 'marriage is nothing, but will you look after her?'

  1. Compare and Contrast the 1963 and 1990 film versions of Lord of the Flies. ...

    There are also not as many characters as in the novel. In the 1990 film Jack wasn't shown as the bossy and nasty character he was in the book, but seemed quite friendly at the beginning. Ralph was perfect and was never even tempted to do anything wrong.

  2. A media study comparing two cinematic interpretations of Golding's "Lord of the Flies" the ...

    First of all he show images of some class rooms with lecturers at the front, dictating what appears to be maths and Latin. These symbolise rules and order, maths with all the rules and Latin with a very orderly structure to the language.

  1. A comparison of the way Piggy's death is portrayed in - "Lord of the ...

    Golding also mentions fire, which reminds the reader of how Jack stole the glasses off helpless Piggy, to use for their own comfort and as a aid for a cooking fire. The first sign of conflict between Jack and Ralph is when they meet.

  2. Name and/or Title of the Text: Fight Club (Film) Composer: David Fincher.

    Jack finally comes to the conclusion that he and Tyler are the same person. Tyler is simply a figment of Jack's imagination. Tyler is everything that Jack wishes he could be. He looks how he wants to look. He acts how he wants to act.

  1. Read Lord of the Flies by William Golding (1954) and also seen the scene ...

    In the text and the black and white version the group of boys introduced at the beginning is a choir but in Harry Hooks' version this has been changed to a group of Air Cadets. This is showing that the boys are acting more grown up than in the text.

  2. Compare the death of Piggy in the following - 'Lord of the flies' the ...

    Also the twins are carrying spears and guiding Piggy who cannot see, therefore they are very susceptible to attack by the savages. The way that Brook shows the boys walking to Castle Rock instantaneously shows that something is going to happen.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work