• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the position of men in 'The Withered Arm' and 'Turned'. Do these narratives present a 'feminist' view at the expense of a fair representation of men?

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the position of men in 'The Withered Arm' and 'Turned'. Do these narratives present a 'feminist' view at the expense of a fair representation of men? In this essay, I hope to come to a successful conclusion to the essay question. I will do this by analysing the two main male characters in 'The Withered Arm' and 'Turned', Mr Lodge and Mr Marroner. In the narrative 'Turned', Mr. Marroner is a high class, educated working man who owns his own household. He is married to Mrs. Marroner and together they employ a servant; Gerta who is much younger than Mrs. Marroner, uneducated but has worked for Mr. And Mrs. Marroner for many years. The couple almost treat Gerta as their own child and Mrs. Marroner being unable to have children ("How they do come when they are not wanted and don't come where they are wanted" Mrs. Marroner says when she finds out about Gerta's pregnancy) seems to mother Gerta. Mr. Marroner got called out to go away on business but he still kept in touch with his wife by letter, which often included messages and postcards for Gerta. Mrs. Marroner loved her husband dearly and I believe that she trusted him, she was "not a jealous woman", and I think that she held great faith in people. ...read more.


He is given an address and he goes to settle the problems that had existed and to put his mind at rest. When he turned up at the new residence of the two women and the child, he was shocked ("He looked from one to another dumbly.") to learn that they had coped without him and that even after the events of nearly a year ago, Mrs. Marroner had stayed true to Gerta and had supported her. The two of them had begun to raise the child in a family environment. At the end of the narrative, the male role is not forgiven and the females had almost dismissed him for he was clearly not needed in the upbringing of the child. The last line in this narrative "What have you to say to us", brings the story to a conclusion that leads the reader to believe that he is the person who needs to make amends and realise that men should answer to women. Mr.Lodge was also not necessary in the upbringing of his child, although I think that Rhoda yearned for support from him and for the farmer to be a part of their son's life, just as she wished to be a part of Mr. ...read more.


The fact that when Mr.Lodge was really needed, (at the court case) he was there for his son might have been how Hardy wanted to show that men are there at crucial times. However, I feel that when Mr.Lodge only is there at a point of life and death, shows that he is not a very responsible parent. Hardy also shows that his male character swears. " 'Damn you! What are you doing here?' He said hoarsely." The language used in this short extract presents yet another negative image of men, while Gilman's use of language towards the end of the narrative slightly improves the picture of Mr. Marroner. In Conclusion, I think that although both authors represent the two male characters in a negative way, it is only Charlotte Perkins Gillman who presents a feminist view. I think this because even though Rhoda Brooks does manage to cope with bringing up her son on her own, there is no accomplishment of women over men in this story. This may be because the author was male and that Charlotte Perkins Gillman had very strong feminist beliefs anyway. I don't think that the representation of men is necessarily fair because not all men are unfaithful or betraying, yet the two male characters in the narratives were portrayed in a negative way fairly as they had both carried out appalling acts at the expense of women. Christine Nobbs 11N 11X1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Thomas Hardy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Thomas Hardy essays

  1. Compare and contrast the two stories, "The Outsiders and "The Withered arm", and show ...

    Many factors became obvious one being was the fact that Ponyboy was distressed by his parent's absence. He has nightmares to emphasis e this point, "I had a nightmare the night of mum and dad's funeral. I'd had nightmares and wild dreams every once in a while when I was little, but nothing like this one.

  2. Compare and Contrast “Piano” and “At Castle Boterel”

    b This rhyme scheme is quite straightforward and very regular. It is quite short as well where only two lines rhyme together (rhyming couplets). The rhyme scheme is straightforward and quite short because the speaker's memory of his past is short and very straightforward.

  1. Show how Hardy responds to the death of his wife, the thoughts and feelings ...

    He does not use "we", which shows he feels they will never be together again and, although he asks the question, he knows he cannot see her again. The caesura of 'Nay.'

  2. Compare and Contrast a selection of Thomas Hardy's Poetry

    This is especially emphasized in the last stanza, where Emma is practically begging for assistance in her efforts at her interaction with Hardy, 'Tell him a faithful one is doin all that love can do...' It is as if Emma accepts that Hardy has moved on to other things, but

  1. Prose Study " The Withered Arm And Other Wessex Tales" By Thomas Hardy

    " Wherein she, with her bad grammar and her ignorance, would be an encumbrance to him." Randolph (the son) was always embarrassed and ashamed of his mother so consequently, as he got older, the divide between them widened. This is similar to what happened to the relationship between Gertrude and Farmer Lodge in " The Withered Arm".

  2. This essay is aimed at discussing the differences between two short stories, called 'The ...

    and Mrs. Marroner) decide to take on a young Swedish homehelp called Gerta. The couple become very attached to Gerta and she becomes a dear and trusted friend. However she and Mr. Marroner have an affair behind Mrs. Marroner's back and Gerta becomes pregnant.

  1. Compare and contrast the main female characters in 'The Withered Arm' and 'Turned'. You ...

    Daughters were seen as a burden to their family and this meant that the pressure to marry was intense. Women were not seen as individuals in their own right but as property that belonged to their husbands, they were in a vulnerable position where even the law failed to protect them properly.

  2. With references to the selection of short stories you have read, compare and contrast ...

    William Preston, 'was a stern, hard man' to most people, but he was very kind and loving toward his son, the narrator, and his wife, Helen. Whilst Helen was dying William Preston 'would have coined his heart's blood into gold to save her'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work