• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast Tony Harrisons poems Bookends and Long Distance 2

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Zoe Nunn Compare and contrast Tony Harrison's poem's "Bookends" and "Long Distance 2" In both Tony Harrison's poem's "Bookends" and "Long Distance 2" the main idea of the poems follow the relationship between the three people in his family: him, his father and his dead mother. The poems concern the loss of his mother, and how both he and his father grieve over her, and how they try to accept and deal with her death in very different ways. Harrison also conveys the strained relationship he has with his father, which was held together by his mother before she died. This comes across very strongly in "Bookends" where he uses the title as imagery in the form a simile to depict the differences between his father and himself. They are "like book ends", they "sit, sleep, stare", facing away from each other, and never seeing eye to eye. When Harrison refers to the "books" which separate them, the books represent Harrison's education, which his father always resented. This was due to his belief that his son the "scholar" would be led into the illusion that he was in a higher class or rank than his father who was "worn out on poor pay". His father believed you were born into a certain class, and that you should seek a profession and education within that class. ...read more.

Middle

But "Long Distance 2" concentrates much more on the effects of her death on the father two years later. He is still "raw" over the loss of his wife, and two years has done nothing to ease the pain. The structure and rhythm of "Bookends" and "Long Distance 2" is irregular and awkward at times. I think Harrison intended this so as to emphasis the sense of her sudden death and the irregularity and instability of their lives afterwards. "Bookends" has 8 verses and 16 lines, with a continuation of rhyming couplets until verse 7. It has a simple structure, which is interrupted at the end very abruptly. Line seven summarises the whole poem without any explanation. It's rhythm and rhyme are completely different to the rest of the poem. It is very powerful, and is directed by Harrison at his father as a statement, showing exactly how much this loss has affected him. "Your life's all shattered into smithereens", it has long sounds and syllables, which drag on, unlike the short abrupt and explosive monosyllables in the first 6 verses. Harrison uses vowel sounds to create a long and continuous movement along with many long "Ss" and "Ls" to make this line stand out. It continues the sense that life is never going to be the same again, that his father has no hope at patching it all together, because it's "shattered" like shards of glass that have been smashed into tiny pieces. ...read more.

Conclusion

Many of the other words in "Long Distance 2", "bed", "dad", "drop" and "popped", all share the ending of a deep "D". The sound is blunt and short, which connects with monosyllabic sounds, and the irreversible definiteness of death. There is a very strong connection between this sound and the meaning of the poem. "Disconnected" sums up both poems, but it is used in the last verse of "Long Distance 2", to explain that Harrison's father is disconnected with reality; he may as well be "disconnected" or "dead" himself. He is disconnected from his wife; from real life; and from the fact that his wife is not coming back. And what is mostly presented in both poems is that father and son are also disconnected. The phone at Harrison's parents is disconnected, and Harrison admits he is somewhat disconnected. This word has the same effect as "dead" with the double "D" at the beginning and end of the word. It has a long "N" sound in the middle, giving the word a negative quality, similar to the word "sullen" with the long "N' sound at the end rather than in the middle of the word. You can separate the syllables in 'dis | con | nec | ted', giving the word a rhythm of its own. It connects with many of the other letters and sounds in the poem (consonance), and is in some ways the most powerfully expressive word in the poem. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Other Poets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Other Poets essays

  1. Night Over Birkenau Powerful Impression

    Light, which is almost always a light of hope and peace in the world, can only be found where death resides. This conveys the idea that death is a better option than life in the camp. These ideas give us the impression that some survivors in the camp envy the dead.

  2. Explore the theme of protest in the poems limbo, Nothings changed and Not my ...

    This poignant message optimises the idea of the whole poem that if there is not a will to protest, evil will go on and ultimately succeed. Finally, in the last stanza the indented few lines of "what business is it of mine?", which seem to have been catching up with

  1. Poetry Comparision - Coming Home (by Curtis Bennet) & The Man He Killed (by ...

    dignity in death which would change the meaning of the poem completely. However the use of rhyming makes war sound like a game, so I think that Thomas Hardy intended the tone to be the former. There are similarities in the tone of the poems: they have a reference to children and their emotions.

  2. In the poems Jac Codi Baw and East Moors Gillian Clarke is able to ...

    town" this might have been used to show the emotions of the residence. The tone of the poem varies from every verse, there is a sense of sadness due to the steelworks being demolished and a sense of happiness of the clean fresh air.

  1. Analysis of "End of shift" by Desmond Sim.

    The poet employs metaphor in the poem to further emphasise the persona's discontentment with his workplace as well as the exhaustion he feels. The bus which the persona rides home becomes a 'metal monster' that 'jerks' to life and throws the persona 'scowling into [its] dead innards'.

  2. Analysis of "The Mother" by Gwendolyn Brooks

    You can see this in each and every line of the poem, she is still clearly disturbed by her past life and what she did and her children. She writes ?I have heard voices of the wind the voices of the Dim? (children).

  1. Drawing parallels with other poems in the Book of Matches explore the ways in ...

    ?Hitcher? presents us with two extremes in society: two men of the same age, one of whom has succeeded in escaping all ties and worries, the other caught up in it, but unable to face up to its demands and threatened with losing his job.

  2. In many of her poems such as Aunt Jennifers Tigers and From a Survivor, ...

    cataracts on her eyes The cracked and suppurating skin of her finger-ends Till she could no longer hold a test tube or pencil? This is unbelievably visceral language and imagery. I feel it shows that Marie Curie proved women were (are)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work