Compare and Contrast Violence in Stealing by Carol Ann Duffy and three other poems

Authors Avatar

Exploring the Violence in the Following Poems, Compare and Contrast:

  • Hitcher by Simon Armitage
  • Salome by Carol Ann Duffy
  • The Man He Killed by Thomas Hardy
  • My Last Duchess by Robert Browning

In all the poems, the themes of violence/violent individuals are recurring. However, as well as similarities between the violent acts there are also differences which make them poem more individual and means it stands out from the rest.

In Simon Armitage's poem (Hitcher) the main character shows a lack of remorse for the innocent hitcher who has fallen victim to his violence. By using phrases such as “I let him have it” and “you can walk from there” Armitage makes it seem as if the hitcher deserves the violence he is receiving, and makes the main character sound very bitter and unsympathetic.

This is very much the same in one of Carol Ann Duffy's poems (Salome). Here the main character, Salome, is clearly portrayed as emotionless and with a lack of remorse. The vocabulary used suggests Salome's bitterness as it clearly shows she has no remorse for what she has done. “what did it matter?” In asking a rhetorical question the reader feels more involved, and in many cases would like to respond. From the question Salome's trail of thoughts moves on without a mere thought for what she has done, and continues onto what she sees as more important matters.

Join now!

However, in Salome there is a suggestion that the main character knows they are doing something wrong, but are lacking to act upon it. During stanza three Salome considers that she “need to clean up her act”. Although the main character is not seen to change her behaviour she considers what needs to be done, and admits that she is doing wrong. On the contrary in Hitcher the main character is never seen to admit that they did wrong, or that they consider changing their ways. They are also seen to remain anonymous, suggesting that they feel some guilt, ...

This is a preview of the whole essay