• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the opening scene of Educating Rita to the opening scene of Pygmalion. Discuss the similarities and differences between Shaw's characterisation of Eliza and Higgins, and Willy Russell's characterisation of Frank and Rita

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare the opening scene of Educating Rita to the opening scene of Pygmalion. Discuss the similarities and differences between Shaw's characterisation of Eliza and Higgins, and Willy Russell's characterisation of Frank and Rita These plays revolve around the theme of an upper class, well-educated man transforming a lower class woman into someone like himself. One is Pygmalion; a play set in the time when there was a very distinct class system and members of different classes avoided each other as much as possible. Educating Rita is set much more recently, when the classes mingled much more frequently and when the class system was much less distinct. However, the differences between Frank and Rita are still very apparent. Both of these are situations which could prove to be quite comical because of the culture clash. I am going to compare the opening scenes and explore the characterisation of the main characters. In both plays, the teachers are reluctant to teach their pupils. Higgins is reluctant at the beginning of the scene to teach Liza, but towards the end, when he gets more excited about the challenge, he really wants to. This is different to Educating Rita, in which Frank is willing to teach Rita at the beginning of the scene, because he needs the money, but as he learns more and more about her, he becomes more and more reluctant. He realises that Rita wants to be more like him, but he doesn't like what he is. ...read more.

Middle

This tells us that Frank perhaps has a drinking problem. Russell then uses the interesting medium of a one-sided telephone conversation between Frank and someone we expect to be his girlfriend or wife. This entertains the audience, as they are wondering what the person on the other end of the line is saying. We become more accustomed to Frank's character. The telephone conversation is also humorous: "Darling, you can incinerate ratatouille and it still wouldn't burn" and "What do you mean, I'm determined to go to the pub? I don't need determination to get me into a pub." If we compare Higgins and Frank, we can see that Frank is less confident in his own position as a member of the upper-middle class. The reasons for this are a combination of his bleak outlook on life, and the fact that times have changed. There was a much less distinct class system at the time when Educating Rita is set. Ideas about equality were much more prevalent. He admires Rita very much because of her spunkiness. He doesn't want to take that away from her and turn her into someone like himself, because he believes that his upper middle-class lifestyle is very shallow, and not worth living. It is only made bearable by a steady flow of whisky. He knows that he is a clever, well-educated man, but he doesn't think that is important: "Everything I know is that I know absolutely nothing." - Act I Scene i. ...read more.

Conclusion

You can see that she is a proud person when she offers to pay for the lessons, instead of getting them free. They are both very mouthy and to different degrees, they both try to gain authority over their teachers. Rita is far more successful in doing this than Eliza; she reverses the student/teacher role completely. Eliza tries to gain a bit of respect from Henry Higgins, but fails because he is far too arrogant to be dominated by a working-class woman. However, she still gets him to agree to educate her, so it isn't a complete failure. In conclusion, there are a few similarities between the scenes: in both, a woman comes into a man's office and asks him to teach her. In both, he is reluctant to do so, and she says that she might change her mind, and in both, the lessons are eventually agreed upon. The main difference is how the teacher views himself and how the student views him. Frank is quite self-critical and sees his middle-class existence as bleak whereas Higgins is very arrogant and content with his upper-class superiority. In both plays, you get the feeling that because the student goes to the teacher, she looks up to him. She knows he can change her for the better. Although both plays revolve around the same theme - a man from a superior class educating a younger woman from a lower one - there are obvious differences between them. At least some of these are due to the different time periods in which the plays are set. 0 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Educating Rita section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Educating Rita essays

  1. In this essay I am going to show my ideas for staging a production ...

    After that, it must be more obvious the differences between Frank and Rita. At this point we don't see the similarities so the two actors must make every effort to be very different. For example, while Rita looks around and does most of the talking, Frank must sit down and listen more.

  2. How does Willy Russell explore the theme of conformity in “Terraces”?

    Did you know that? Warped, that's what you are. They're your friends." Fourthly Joey creeps inside the house to give him a final chance.

  1. Once upon a Time in the West: A Critical Response.

    Once loyal to his employer, Frank turns his back on him. Ironically, Frank's own men turn against him for the same reason--money (this time, paid them by Frank's employer to kill Frank). We then get a double dose of irony when Harmonica enables Frank to survive the murder plot.

  2. How does Russell reveal to the audience the change in Rita's character? 'Educating Rita' ...

    The audience see that she finishes achieving her goals through the dress Frank gives her. Frank: "I bought it some time ago-for erm- for an educated woman friend- of mine..." (Act 2, Scene 7) The dress is a key symbol used in the play and is significant in all these ways.

  1. Educating Rita by Willy Russell

    This show she has made a sacrifice to get her education and in life you have to make these sacrifices to get what you want in the end. Another important change was her feeling about herself because at the start of the play she is feeling unfulfilled but in Act

  2. How does Russell use the opening scene to prepare the audience for the rest ...

    Rita questions Frank to gain insight into what he thinks is acceptable and good. Rita longs to have the mind of Frank, and tries to see through his perspective throughout the play. It isn't surprising how quickly they open up to each other because Rita is obviously fascinated with Frank,

  1. How far do you think that Frank was solely responsible for this development, or ...

    see the influence of her social background, such as when she stops reading Howard's End because E.M Forster quotes in the book that, 'we are not concerned with the poor'. This shows that in my opinion she was being very subjective at the time.

  2. By referring to scenes of your choice, discuss Ritas changing character.

    The fact that the door is "open" suggests that Rita is open to new things and is not afraid to progress into an unknown territory. Also, the word "swings" suggests Rita that even though she is confident in moving towards being educated she will still swing back to her past

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work