• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison Essay between "Out-Out" and "Disabled" by Wilfred Owen and Robert Frost.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparison Essay Of ?Out-Out? and ?Disabled?. Both Wilfred Owen and Robert Frost use techniques such as careful diction, imagery and sentence structure to convey their agendas. They both outline how a single even can end the childhood of a young man prematurely and what effect it has on both of their lives. The two poems stimulate a sense of pity within us and furthermore, Owen stimulates a sense of outrage that men are allowed to join the army below the set age. Both poets use graphic description and effective diction as a means to stimulate a sense of horror within the reader. Both poets use an omniscient narrator to give the reader a larger overview of all of the events. By using an omniscient narrator it enables the reader to know all of the characters? feelings and this would not have been possible by using a first or second person narrator. Interestingly Frost changes the speaker during his poem to the first person. This change in narrator is very effective as it highlights the sudden harsh realisation of the situation the young man is in. It is also a very dramatic change in direction within the poem because before this change in narrator, the poem had been neutral and non-judgmental but now, the narrator?s own opinion comes to the fore and this changes how we view the poem. For example, the narrator says: ?I wish they had said? which is an opinion of the narrator. Previously we had felt more detached and distanced from the events because of the omniscient narrator but because of this change and because of the introduction of opinions it starts to become more judgmental and feel more real. ...read more.

Middle

Frost uses very few exclamation marks and in this instance he uses it to make the reader focus on the hand and how gruesome it is, this works very well. Frost also centers his poem around the idea of it being hideously comic. For example the boy is described as crying out with a ?rueful laugh?, the boy is obviously so shocked that his whole hand has been cut off that he finds it comical. It is ridiculous that the boy finds his hand being cut off is so comical but so is a boy doing a man?s work, Frost is trying to convey how ridiculous it is that this young boy, who laughs at his hand being cut off, is doing the work of a man. Frost carries the idea of the event being hideously comic by using the phrase ?half an appeal, but half as if to keep the life from spilling? which means the boy is literally holding his hand in place so it will not fall off. this supports Frost?s idea of the event being hideously comic. In ?Disabled? the reader does not read to rhyme because the punctuation does not allow it. There is not an artificial iambic rhythm in ?Out-Out? because the poet does not want the poem to sound jolly. The poem looks coherent but it is not, it is disjointed, much like the character in the poem. Frost uses a very small sentence in the second half of the poem after the tragic event has happened which is very powerful and effective and has very many meanings, which is ?So.?. ...read more.

Conclusion

To conclude, I personally prefer ?Out-Out? because it is centered around one single event and it is told in almost real time. I feel it captures the graphic scenes better than ?Disabled? by using careful effective diction and the whole idea of it being comically gruesome. I also feel that because the poem is told in real time the reader feels less distanced to the events than in ?Disabled? because you are not constantly flicking between times and places. I feel that Robert Frost succeeds in conveying his agenda because he shows how the pure carelessness of a child means that he can be killed instantly in the wrong situation as the boy was in ?Out-Out?. However, I do feel that ?Disabled: does show the changing attitude of the general public towards servicemen and servicewomen between 1915 and the present day very well. In ?Disabled? it talks about how the boy would be put into institutions and how people were more concerned about a goal in a game of football than the safe return of a serviceman. Since Iraq and Afghanistan the general public does not have the same attitude towards our armed forces. For example before 2002, men returning from war were discouraged from coming back in uniform but now when our armed forces return we have large parades for them and it is a joyous occasion. Another example is that Wootton Basset was turned into Royal Wootton Basset just because that is where servicemen return to. Previously, returning armed forces were put into institutions and shut away but now there are huge charities with the sole purpose to raise money for injured servicemen so they can lead a normal life. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Pre and Post 1914 Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Pre and Post 1914 Comparison essays

  1. Little boy crying

    This fierce man longs to lift you, curb your sadness with piggy-back or bull-fight, anything, but dare not ruin the lessons you should learn", this means that although the father hits the little boy, he knows what the boy feels too, because it makes him cry when he see the boy crying.

  2. GCSE English Essay - I am not that woman and still I Rise comparison

    The next phrase used in this poem is "Remember me". This phrase was also used in the first paragraph. It shows that this poem is directed at someone who has caused her oppression in the past. It also shows that all of what Naheed is writing about in this poem is from past experience.

  1. Compare the viewpoint on war in Charge of the Light Brigade by Alfred ...

    This shows that Owen knows much more about how horrific it is in the war and has much more experience. Owen wrote about his experience of World War 1, whilst he was in hospital in 1917 being treated for shell shock whilst in hospital he met his all time hero

  2. Essay Question: Discuss both poets of murder, revenge and violence in Salome by Carol ...

    This reinforces the idea that Salome believes that the murder is beautiful. Salome expresses the idea that she has no recrimination. For the reader, this shows that the murder is immoral, gruesome and implicating as Salome believes the murder is pleasuring and joyful.

  1. Compare the presentation of the soldier in Disabled by Wilfried Owen and the Charge ...

    This word shows the results of what the war has done to him, losing limbs. Also it shows the mental effect on this wounded soldier. And he will always regret what he did and why he should put himself through the war.

  2. Compare and contrast the way in which Seamus Heaney and D.H Lawrence describe childhood ...

    However a sense of guilt also lingers when he says, "I saw him for the first time in six weeks" showing he is guilty he hasn't seen enough of his brother recently.

  1. Compare and contrast the different moods and themes created in Out, Out-and Disabled

    ?liked a blood smear down his leg? and ?thought he?d better join? was proved to be wrong by his experiences and the reader feels the urge to give him some small measure of comfort that he is deprived of now due to his deformities and he ?noticed how the women?s

  2. Compare the ways in which Owen and Frost present youth in disabled and Out, ...

    to swing so gay?, this was until he ?threw away his knees? and the girls now look at him as if he is ?some queer disease?. One of the reasons the boy joined the army to go to war was ?to please his Meg?, this shows the immature nature of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work