• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison of the presentation of women in the stories by “The withered arm” by Thomas Hardy and “Tickets please” by D. H. Lawrence.

Extracts from this document...


Dan Chorley Comparison of the presentation of women in the stories by "The withered arm" by Thomas Hardy and "Tickets please" by D. H. Lawrence. I am going to compare the story by Thomas Hardy, that was first published and set in the second half of the nineteenth century, with a story written by D. H. Lawrence which is set in the early twentieth century in the period of the first world war, to assess the different treatment of women at those times. The main characters in Thomas Hardys book "The Withered Arm" are Farmer Lodge, Gertrude his wife and Rhoda Brook, the mother of a child to the farmer called Lodge. Rhoda was once a beautiful young woman but has now, at the age of thirty, become a faded woman. Her ex-lover Farmer Lodge owns a big farm, which employs Rhoda and other women as milkmaids. Rhoda becomes jealous of farmer Lodges new wife, Gertrude, and in a dream imagines a horrible vision happening to Gertrude, which later comes true. Because of Gertrude's illness Farmer Lodge becomes a gloomy and silent man saddened by his wife's loss of beauty. To get back her beauty and her husbands love, Gertrude ignores her husband's wishes and hides her actions from him. Gertrude's secretive actions to cure her illness result in causing her death. ...read more.


At first she reacts with jealously but when she gets to know Gertrude better she begins to realise that Gertrude is an innocent women. Farmer Lodges marriage seems at first to be happy and he is pleased to show her off, and she ties to look her best by dressing in "a white bonnet and a silver coloured gown" which "whewed and whistled so loud when it rubbed against the pews" and impressed the men. Because he is older and because of the way women were looked upon at the time, he is strict and tells her what she can and cannot do, for example travelling to Casterbridge by herself was considered inappropriate for a women. In modern days married women are treated as equals and have a say in what they do as a married couple, for example women can travel freely and unaccompanied without attracting unnecessary attention. The women in "the withered arm" are dependent on men to provide for them to live a decent life. Rhoda and Gertrude are both used to men telling them what to do, neither are independent and outgoing whereas Annie and the women in "tickets please" are more carefree and have a say in what they want to do. D.H.Lawrence describes the women as "fearless young hussies" that "fear nobody-and everybody fears them" In many ways the tram girls can be said to lead very different lives to Rhoda and Gertrude because society ...read more.


Most of the men had gone away to fight for their country and this leads to a rise in women's confidence and self esteem. In her work, Annie's passengers have to respect and obey her, but John Thomas has power of choice over whom he wishes to marry. But he becomes wary of Annie and the other women's power and confidence when they gang up on him because of his flirting. In the story by Thomas Hardy I have noticed that the women's appearance has a significant impact on the prospect of a marriage to a higher-class man and the security it brings. The women in Thomas Hardys stories have to accept what comes to them because marriage gives an acceptable life style and the alternative is a low paid hard labour job, such as milkmaids. Gertrude's attitude to men is different to Annie's. She has to obey her husband to keep her security and has to show respect to his cold attitude towards her. Rhoda is independent and her attitude towards men was probably the same as Annie's, before Rhoda grew old and faded. Annie's life is of a better quality than Rhoads but if she had a child out of marriage she would find in some cases life difficult, as did Rhoda when she had to accept farmer Lodges decision to leave her to cope on her own with her son. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Thomas Hardy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Thomas Hardy essays

  1. What can we learn about Victorian society from the story 'The Withered Arm' by ...

    Hardy forms an incredibly dismal ambience around the boy. I assume that Hardy is trying to epitomize the class difference, still present in Victorian England, between the farmer, an upper-class man with scarcely any worries, and the working-class boy with the weighty bundle upon his back. The light and dark also comes up again in the depiction of their

  2. Compare and Contrast a selection of Thomas Hardy's Poetry

    The thought of whether they will ever come back, ever see them again, is always there, and cannot be taken away.Hardy's concern in this poem is not really with war, but more with the effect on the wives of the departure of their men.

  1. Discuss Hardy's Portrayal Of Women In "The Withered Arm"

    In the text women are portrayed as if they were only objects of beauty. This is made clear when Gertrude arrives in the village and Farmer Lodge tells her " you must expect to be stared at, just at first.

  2. Discuss Hardy's Portrayal of Women in The Withered Arm

    she was going to visit Conjuror Trendle because Mr.Lodge would suspect that her wife were a witch. "O Lord, hang some guilty or innocent person soon!" a desperate Gertrude says. We can tell from this quotation that, when women are in desperation, they say and do things without thinking of the consequences of their actions.

  1. 'Almost all of Hardy's heroes stand aloof from life, even play the role of ...

    Through his conversation with the girls, he reveals himself as being an indecisive, weak but well meaning character. He finds it difficult to refuse any of the women a lift, and seems beguiled by the beauty of each of them when the others were out of sight as when he

  2. Comparison of "Tony Kytes, the arch deceiver" by Thomas Hardy and "Tickets please" by ...

    opinion, although sometimes he tends to go into the thoughts of the character, e.g. John Thomas' thoughts;" a good, easy twelve mile chat", and in Annie's thoughts: "After all, he had a wonderfully warm, cosy way of holding a girl..."

  1. Show how Hardy responds to the death of his wife, the thoughts and feelings ...

    He sees the memory very clearly and includes a lot of detail to show this. He can remember her 'even to the original air-blue gown', which is a pleasant and cheerful colour, showing the mood in the memory. It is one specific memory he is thinking about and, as he

  2. With close textual references to On the Western Circuit and The Withered Arm, explore ...

    of thirty", immediately the Victorian readers would have presumed that Rhoda is of a very low class and very poor. Her given age would also indicate that she is not a young woman of sixteen already married to a wealthy man, and that her chance of doing so has passed.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work