• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison of three nineteenth century short stories.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparison of three nineteenth century short stories In the nineteenth century attitudes were very different to how they are today, as reflected in the books and short stories written in this period. The three short stories I shall be focusing on are: * 'The Yellow Wallpaper'---Charlotte Perkins Gilman * 'Tony Kytes-The Arch Deceiver--- Thomas Hardy * 'The Stolen Bacillus'---H. G. Wells I have selected these three short stories, as they appear to have similarities in some aspects and differences in others; they also reveal much about how life was in the nineteenth century. 'The Yellow Wallpaper' is about a woman who moves out to the countryside to undergo a rest cure treatment for postnatal depression. It is the story of how she is treated by her husband and those around her. Mental illness in the nineteenth century was misunderstood. It was treated in the opposite way to how it is treated now. 'The Yellow Wallpaper' is narrated by the main character entirely in diary form, so it gives a very personal view of the story and the emotions involved. It starts by the narrator going straight into the story with no introduction or background knowledge given. The narrator and her husband are renting a country house to live in for the summer. It is shown in the first paragraph that the narrator thinks there is something strange about the setting by the way in which she describes it as "A colonial mansion, a hereditary estate, I would say a haunted house...- but that would be asking too much of fate!" She is obviously suspicious of the house, and even seems slightly paranoid. Her relationship with her husband John becomes clear very soon into the story. He is the dominating partner and takes it upon himself to look after her, believing that she is not able to look after herself and must be put in the responsibility of his, more capable hand 'He assures friends and family there is really nothing the matte with me'. ...read more.

Middle

He makes their lives seem very dull and as if they only have the aim of getting married and having a family. Thomas Hardy also tells us that in this time in history women are supported by men all through their lives. Their fathers are in control of them until they find a husband, who will be able to control them. This could be seen as a different attitude compared to today when many children are from single parent families who have no male influence in their lives. A similarity between Tony Kytes-The Arch Deceiver and 'The Yellow Wallpaper' is the way women are seen. Thomas Hardy treats women as very much second-class. He often makes them seem weak and stupid. Examples of this in 'Tony Kytes- The Arch Deceiver' are when Unity, Milly and Hannah cannot control the horses; 'She can't hold that horse in, you shouldn't have left the reins in her hands'. This could be seen as humorous in the nineteenth century as it is like a pantomime. Charlotte Perkins Gilman does not make women seem as they are weak, but still shows them to be second-class and as if their views do not matter. An example of this is when nobody wants to listen to the narrator when she puts forward ideas on how to treat her postnatal depression. 'Personally, I believe that congenial work, with excitement and change would do me good' When Tony Kytes sees his dad calling him he goes straight over to him. He confesses the situation he had got himself in to with Unity, Milly and Hannah in his wagon. In the nineteenth century the father's role was very important and they were like the law. Whenever your father told you to do something you would have to do it. Society at the time would be angry with Thomas Hardy for making Tony Kytes oppose his father, when he is advised to marry the only girl who did not invite herself to ride in Tony's wagon. ...read more.

Conclusion

The language in all three short stories could be seen as being old fashioned. Words are in the style of how they were in the nineteenth century. Examples of this in the three short stories are in ''The Yellow Wallpaper'' they call a doctor a physician. In 'Tony Kytes-The Arch Deceiver' there are many old nineteenth century words used including 'o the petticoats went off, and the breaches went on'. In 'The Stolen Bacillus' there are also several nineteenth century words used including ethnology. The most successful short story for telling me about the nineteenth century was 'Tony Kytes-The Arch Deceiver' Thomas Hardy had written about lots of different occurrences that took place in the nineteenth century and has had the courage to write about the true happenings. This short story would have also caused the most outrage in the nineteenth century as it tells the truth about such issues as women flirting with men and sons and daughters disobeying their fathers. Although people in the nineteenth century knew about these happenings they did not want to have to be reminded about them and read about them. The most successful short story to people in the nineteenth century was 'The Stolen Bacillus'. I think this would have sold the most copies in shops as it was about cholera, which many people would have been interested in. It was also not as controversial as the other two short stories as it didn't tackle issues that were as delicate. 'The Yellow Wallpaper' would have been seen as a very controversial short story in the nineteenth century. It was mainly centred on postnatal depression and mental illness. This topic was not widely talked about at this period in time as it was seen to be an embarrassment if you knew someone with a mental illness. Although I have referred to the three short stories as all being written in the nineteenth century, they were actually written in the 1890s. I think a better genre for the three short stories would be early twentieth century, as they would fit in that category more than the nineteenth century. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Thomas Hardy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Thomas Hardy essays

  1. Compare and contrast Tony Kytes, the arch deceiver by Thomas Hardy and Turned by ...

    This is interesting, as two similar characters separated by time and place should share similar disregard for women. Mr Marroner and Tony are both very different people, Mr Marroner is a well-educated man, we know this as he's " travelling on business", whereas Tony is an uneducated farmer.

  2. Comparison of "Tony Kytes, the arch deceiver" by Thomas Hardy and "Tickets please" by ...

    to do but because Milly has a polite manner she obeys him. She calls him 'Mr Tony' and is eager to please as well as being fragile and delicate. The social and historical forces shape the lives of these women that are why the women in "Tickets Please" took on

  1. two short stories by thomas hardy

    For that reason 'she did nothing for months and patiently bore her disfigurement as before.' Nevertheless despite her fear she's determined to try this last attempt to save her marriage and happiness. To even consider doing this task you must have courage and this undermines her personality in the beginning

  2. Essay with reference to the following Thomas Hardy short stories "Tony Kytes: Arch Deceiver", ...

    'Tisn't true that it is all settled between her and me." Tony's way with words is shown once again as he persuades Unity to hide from Milly, but at the same time manages not to anger Unity, he does this by making an excuse that seems plausible.

  1. Thomas Hardy, 'Tony Kytes, the Arch Deceiver' and Charlotte Perkins Gilman 'Turned' In what ...

    The social and historical context in 'Turned' is shown by class distinctions, which are much more important than in 'Tony Kytes', like Mrs.

  2. This essay is aimed at discussing the differences between two short stories, called 'The ...

    Marroner), on his own without any of his previous two partners or his son. It says that Gerta was like a "tall rosy cheeked, baby" with "gold hair and blue eyes." This implies that Gerta was a young and attractive Swedish girl who Mr.

  1. Discuss the way in which the authors present women in the four short stories.

    This story fits perfectly for the time it was written in. Schreiner's short story can be considered as ahead of its time. The two women, who would normally be rivals fighting for the men's attention, have an understanding between them.

  2. Which of the women in the pre nineteen-hundreds short stories set for study are ...

    Infact the main job of a woman pre nineteen-hundred woman was to be married and have children. After this Dorothes is saying in her head 'never,never,never'. This is not how you would expect a woman to respond. Despite all of this Dorothea still cannot tell Randall that she doesn't love him.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work