• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

deliverance and disaster

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History GCSE coursework: assignment 1 The efficiency of sources may differ as some are more restricted, thus more inadequate than others. The utility can be scrutinized by exercising various analyses's and conditions. You have to consider the writer, status, motive and accuracy. On this basis I have started with a theory that the sources could be subjective as they were all written by British men. You can also note that all three sources give a different interpretation of what occurred. For example in source a, commander Thomas Kerr deems the lingering soldiers as useless and condemns their faith in the navy. Nevertheless, according to source C, there was a valiant and courageous sergeant who heroically took on eight Heinkels (planes). First of all, source A, in my opinion is very useful as it is an account from a high ranked commander of war. It must have some authenticity in it as Thomas Kerr is being extraordinarily negative of the army whereas he is being positive of the navy. ...read more.

Middle

This source is a primary one as it was written by a soldier who was present at the time, so in all likelihood, he would tell the truth. He also gives us a very first-rate outlook of the battle. His account has a much unbiased initiative of what happens; he portrays both British and Germans in positive light, hence enhancing its usefulness and believability. He informs us that, although the Germans took them to the boundaries it only spurred them on to greater heights and they certainly did not relinquish. Meanwhile, he also enlightens us concerning how the Germans were massacring the British armed forces. Albeit it is very constructive, in some places the source seems fabricated. The writer gives the intuition that the amount of planes and weaponry that the Germans beheld were minimal. He says 'a German fighter' which implies that there was only one German combatant perceptible. The are also some limitations in this source; Bill Elmsie was a seaman manning one of the boats, so it is implausible for him to have much understanding or credibility. ...read more.

Conclusion

None of the sources give us a date, when or where it was published nor do they enlighten us on the foundations of this epic battle which leads me to believe that they are incompetent. They also only comprise of British viewpoints, hence it would have been very accommodating to have French or German adaptations to collaborate what these sources are saying. Irrespective of whether the sources were authentic or not, they were all based on personal opinion rather than fact. In my opinion source A is without doubt the most useful as it told us about more of the battle than any of the others and due to the fact that it was written by a commander, who gave us a more realistic account and must have had more knowledge of the battle than the other authors. In contrast, I believe that source C was evidently the least useful, as it seems particularly fictional, it is severely limited and gives a much fantasised version of what really took place. ?? ?? ?? ?? By Abdul Wali 10RN ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE War Poetry essays

  1. Why did Britain win the Battle of Britain?

    The morale of the Royal Air Force was high partly because the pilots knew the Luftwaffe was losing far more planes as illustrated by the previous figures. It would have been boosted further by Winston Churchill's propaganda, which vastly over exaggerated the figures of how many planes the Luftwaffe was losing.

  2. War Poetry GCSE

    He states that 'We would not die in that mans company That fears his fellowship to die with us'. This is Henry's way of saying he doesn't want to be in the company of cowards if the time of death in battle would come and states 'Let him depart; his

  1. English Tennyson Coursework

    This also shows that the British are no longer as optimistic as it described in the first stanza. This line also is asking for sympathy for the British as it shows a small chance of survival. It seems likely at this point that they will suffer at the hands of the Indians just as they had made them suffer before.

  2. Why did Britain win the battle of Britain?

    of relay stations the squadrons could not roam more than one or two sectors from their airfield. It was also restricted to a single frequency per squadron, making it impossible to communicate between squadrons. Finally, the system for tracking RAF fighters, known as HF/DF or "Huff-Duff", restricted sectors to a maximum of four squadrons in the air.

  1. The Battle of Britain.

    This is because Churchill's whole propaganda campaign was trying to spread the 'sacrifice' of the pilots, and Britain were trying to prove that they wouldn't let Hitler take their island. Human tragedy played a big part in making anybody not fighting in the war feel guilty that they weren't up their helping these young men.

  2. The popular myth of the Battle of Britain quickly emerged during the early part ...

    The clips are bound to be biased, because the newsreels co-operated very closely with the Ministry of information, which was in charge of government propaganda. The next interpretation is an extract from 'The Daily Express' newspaper on August 13th; this was at the start of the battle, when the outcome of the battle was not known yet.

  1. Battle of Britain.

    Because of this emotional content, it is very effective in reaching its audience and getting people to understand what the pilots went through. However one of its main weaknesses is the fact of personal aggrandisement and is glorifying himself, because he has been injured very badly, he wanted to say

  2. The Crimean War.

    Also the suicidal British charge after the withdrawn Russians (the charge of the Light-Brigade) and into the open artillery battery, may have given the Russians a sense of deja vous when in similar position later in the day. Although it must be said that the Russians also received heavy casualties

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work