How far do you agree that what the boys imagined was more responsible for their turning into savages than the actual conditions on the island? You should refer closely to ideas and events.

Authors Avatar

Zainab Alkaisy

How far do you agree that what the boys imagined was more responsible for their turning into savages than the actual conditions on the island? You should refer closely to ideas and events.

     The beast is the main reason responsible for the boys on the island gradually turning into savages. As the novel progresses and the boys grow more savage, their belief in the beast grows stronger. By the end of the novel, the boys are leaving it sacrifices and treating it as a god. The boys’ behaviour is what brings the beast into existence, so the more savagely the boys act, the more real the beast seems to become. However, as well as the beast, conditions on the island also assist the boys’ transformation. Problems are evident from the start of the novel in particular regarding the power struggle between Ralph and Jack and their very different attitudes to rescue.

     

In the first section of the novel, the island itself is described as a paradise. It is very beautiful and described as an exotic place where ‘the lagoon was still as a mountain lake- blue of all shades..’ This ideal and beautiful description of the island suggests it is somewhere peaceful but even at the beginning; there are implications that this Eden is not perfect. The heat ‘..always, almost visible’ is something which seems to be a flaw in this perfect scenery as well as the ‘tangled foliage’ and of course ‘the open space of the scar’ which builds on the sense of destruction. The boat shape of the island could symbolise civilization but the water current around the island is described as ‘flowing backwards’, giving a subtle impression that civilization may be going backwards for the island or its inhabitants, even early in the novel.

Rescue is an important feature in the boys’ decline into savagery. The boys’ chances of rescue are very slim. Piggy makes this clear when he tells Ralph ‘nobody don’t know we’re here’ which is a good point as there are no adult survivors and the adults are busy with a war, but Ralph ignores Piggy’s ‘ill-omened talk’. Despite rescue being unlikely because of the war, it is the boys’ rope or connection with civilization and the civilised world. As soon as they being to forget it, the decline into savagery becomes inevitable. The power struggle between Ralph and Jack is also evident from the start of the novel, when Ralph is elected chief by a democratic vote. This shows the boys have the will to do good and are following examples from the civilised world. This is quite ironic because the world they are using as an example has descended into war, death and destruction. This is an early indication of the fragility of the boys’ carefully formed society and its potential to be ruined or left behind. When Ralph is elected chief ‘the freckles on Jack’s face disappeared under a blush of mortification’ and in an attempt to make things better, Ralph offers the choir to Jack. This seemingly tactful act of kindness is actually fatal for the future of the boys. Ralph has already given over control of half the boys on the island and putting them under Jack’s command is a very bad idea.

Join now!

The first mention of the beast is followed quickly by the first death on the island. Ralph insists ‘there isn’t a beast’ but Jack does not completely dismiss the idea but instead uses the situation to assert his power by telling the boys ‘If there was a snake, we’d hunt it and kill it.’ This is an instant warning, as Ralph has no belief in the beast, whereas Jack seems to have some belief in it already, despite the fact he has not seen it. The fire on the mountain is described as ‘hell’ but it is not the ...

This is a preview of the whole essay