• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9

Is the film 'Of Mice and Men' a successful presentation of the novel?

Extracts from this document...


Samantha Whittaker Is the film 'Of Mice and Men' a successful presentation of the novel? The film 'Of Mice and Men' is an adaptation of the novel by John Steinbeck, which carries the same name. The film was made, 50 years after the book was first published, in 1987. Starring roles were given to John Malkovich playing the part of Lennie Small, Sherilyn Fenn as Curley's wife and Gary Sinise who played George Milton. Not only did Sinisie star in the film, but he also directed and co-produced it. 'Of Mice and Men' was filmed on location in California as the immense detail in the book could only be justified on a true ranch. The summer days and surroundings could not have been recreated in a studio. Also, this was more practical than building sets that would have been less realistic. As Lennie Small is an interesting complex character with learning disabilities, this would make playing his part extremely difficult to play. As John Malkovich takes on this role superbly, keeping it as true as you can get to the book, it makes the character of Lennie Small my favourite in the film. As for the character of Lennie, there are no boundaries to his characteristics and the range of the features he has. Despite his learning disability he has a great sense of humour and the initiative to create a good joke. Saying this, Lennie is more dependent on George and is often mimicking him. There are many occasions were George will make a statement and Lennie will repeat the idea of what he has said, although not always using the same words. ...read more.


This is probably because by adding Crooks into the dream, it would make it harder to include it later in the film and to tie up any loose ends caused by Crook's involvement. The second point that is overlooked is Curley's wife's racial and malicious verbal attack on Crooks. In the book, Crooks gets a tad overconfident by having so many, Candy and Lennie, people around him being friendly. He totally forgets his 'place' on the ranch and answers back to Curley's wife. She lashes out at him saying she'll use her position; firstly as a woman, secondly as she is the boss's daughter in law and thirdly as he is a "nigger", to get him lynched. This scene was probably left out as, nowadays, the dialogue and racial threats are not politically correct in any way shape or form. Because this scene is cut, it differs the way Curley's wife is perceived in the film and book, we don't see how clever she is and how she uses her knowledge, power and position to be malicious. In the book, there is a quite surreal scene towards the end, when Lennie is by himself in the brush. He gets agitated with himself over what he has done and all of a sudden, a short, plump lady appears, his Aunt Clara. She starts speaking to him in Lennie's voice. Then after she is finished disappears. Then, a giant rabbit scuttles out of Lennie's head and starts shouting at him. Unfortunately, this is never visually seen as it is left out of the film. It would have been a funny scene and with it being right near the end, would have spoilt the mood; therefore, it was left out. ...read more.


The last thing that is expected, that I least expected, was that George was going to shoot Lennie. The shock of this and the fact George is alone and Lennie dead, provokes sadness. Then, to provoke this emotion even more, the little added scene of them working together at the end almost makes you choke with emotion The film, on a whole, is a very emotional film. Whether it is the happiness caused by when the dream becomes reality; as this is what they have always wanted and deserve. Sadness, when Lennie kills his puppy; as he really did have affection towards it and even though disaster was imminent it was sad. Amusement- when Lennie plays his practical joke; as for a man with learning difficulties it was a funny joke to think of on his own. Anger- when Curley lashes out at Lennie; as Lennie has done nothing to provoke him. In summing up, the film, even though it misses out some scenes, in my eyes, is a successful presentation of the book. The emotions the film provokes at certain moments are the same to those in the film. The film gets the story across well and helps to put a picture to everything in the book especially the appearance of characters and their mannerisms and facial expressions. On its on, without the knowledge of the content of the book, the film is excellent and without fault, although knowing how it has been changed, adjusted and added to, causes some minor disappointments. If the film were to be remade, the only suggestion I would have would be to cast Curley's wife and Crooks differently and also to amend Curley's Wife's wardrobe so it is truer to the book. Saying this, I did enjoy the film as much as I enjoyed reading the book. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE John Steinbeck section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE John Steinbeck essays

  1. Steinbeck's novel, "Of Mice and Men" has been described as a protest statement

    Crooks said, "Well, s'pose, jus' s'pose he don't come back. What'll you do then?" Crooks asks these questions because he does not have any friends. Crooks goes on to talk about his loneliness "A guy needs somebody-to be near him" He whined: "A guy goes nuts if he ain't got nobody.

  2. For which character do we most feel sorry for in the story of Mice ...

    Slim and mentions Weed which was the last place of work for George and Lennie, but Lennie lost them both the men the job because a woman claimed she was raped. George and Lennie were chased out of the town "An' that night we scrammed outa there".

  1. The Piano Assignment.

    It needed our understanding to realize it. Flora realized that after Ada went to teach George piano, her relationship with him was closer than to her. She was jealous. When Stewart was locking the house, Flora had called him "papa" and was helping him instead of her mother.

  2. How would you use film language to make the final scene of 'Of Mice ...

    For soundtracks/FX, we especially tried to imitate characters' moods and feelings. Finally, suitable dialogue in calculated manner and appropriate timing re-enforced our essence of Lennie's demise and George's position. The establishing shots arouse an audience's preliminary attention and directly convey a filmmaker's purposes.

  1. Of Mice and Men - The film is severely different from the novel, as ...

    this helps to identify with them, to put ourselves in their shoes. There is a close up of Lennie's face; you only see his wide innocent eyes, to make you sympathise with him. When Lennie and George leave, you hear the crickets; this shows everything is safe and back to normal.

  2. Compare Steinbeck's novel with the1992 film version of 'Of Mice and Men'. In your ...

    The Gabilan Mountains have been described using very powerful terms. The words 'strong' and 'rocky' show that the mountains are formed in a fairly solid structure. On the opposite side of the river, the riverbank is scattered with all sorts of trees.

  1. Having Read Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck the section of the book ...

    Later in the scene inside the great barn Curley's wife is sitting next to Lennie on the remaining wisps of hay and is talking to him. The camera is an over-shoulder shot - this is where we see what is happening as if we were looking over a character's shoulder.

  2. Describe and comment upon the film "Of Mice and Men" (biased on the novel ...

    the men who were chasing them and the loud breathing of them both. In the novel, we do not become aware of exactly what happens to cause Lennie and George to run away from weed until they arrive at Tyler Ranch which is about chapter three, when George is speaking with Slim, the skinner.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work