• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

neither mother is without guilt

Extracts from this document...


Blood Brothers by Willy Russell "Neither mother is without guilt" By Roshni Vora Blood Brothers is all about twin brothers that were separated at birth, one is given away to the wealthy upper class lady, Mrs Lyons, while the other is kept by the working class lady, Mrs Johnstone. In this essay we are going to discuss this statement whether "Neither mother is without guilt" and how far we would agree with this statement. Also we aim to consider all the dramatic irony techniques of the play and how Willy Russell uses them to help the dramatic effectiveness of the play. In this play the characters act in two stereotypical groups, the working class lady Mrs Johnstones and their family, and the middle class lady Mrs Lyons. It seems ironic that although the Mrs Johnstone family live on the small income that comes in the house they start off cheerful, compared to Mrs Lyons who never seems to be satisfied. This makes the audience see what is wrong in the lives of both families and all the created dramatic tension. ...read more.


She wouldn't feel guilty or regret it if she gave a child away, but would still be able to see him. Mrs Johnstone is a loving person, who is without guilt because she loves all her children and cares enough about them to put them in care: "They say I should put some of them in care, but I won't. I love the bones of every one of them. I'll even love these two when they came along." Once again Mrs Lyons tries to buy Mrs Johnstone off, but she says no. Mrs Lyons says: "How much?" Mrs Johnstone says: "Nothing, nothing! You bought me off once before..." She is not going to let Mrs Lyons buy her off again, as Mrs Johnstone isn't wrong but Mrs Lyons is. Next we shall consider the case against Mrs Lyons. What evidence is there to suggest she is guilty? We think Mrs Lyons is guilty because she forced Mrs Johnstone into giving her one of the babies. For example, the author lays emphasis on words such as: "Give one of them to me" these powerful words clearly represent that she is definitely being greedy. ...read more.


Also Mrs Lyons was only trying her best to fulfil her husband's dreams: "We've been trying for such a long time now...I wanted to adopt but...Mrs Lyons is well, he says he wanted his own son, not someone else's." She was only doing what was best and helping two people at once by giving her husband a son and helping Mrs Johnstone by taking one of her children, so she has one less mouth to feed. Overall, I think that both mothers are equally guilty. Mrs Johnstone is guilty because she had lied to her children by saying one of the twins has died: "He's gone. He's gone to heaven, love." As I have shown in the paragraphs above. Also Mrs Lyons is guilty because she separated a son from a mother, as she forced Mrs Johnstone to give her the child, and lied to her by making up some silly superstition as I have shown in my paragraphs above. So in the end I don't agree with this statement "Neither mother is without guilt" because Mrs Lyons and Mrs Johnstone are both guilty in there own ways. ?? ?? ?? ?? By Roshni Vora ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. Blood Brothers by Willy Russell Neither mother is without guilt

    So Mrs Johnstone is guilty in the first place as she agrees and swears to give one of her sons away. Also she lied to Mickey by saying his brother died: "He's gone. He's gone to heaven, love." She is guilty as she lied and hides the truth to her own family, let alone others.

  2. My Mother Said I Never Should - response.

    The cast list comprises of four generations of women within the same family, all of different ages and opinions. These women are Doris Partington, Margaret Bradley, Jackie Metcalfe and Rosie Metcalfe. Doris was a woman born in the beginning of the 20th century with old-fashioned ideals and she seems altogether

  1. Neither mother is without guilt. How far would you agree with with this statement ...

    Mrs Johnstone wants Edward to remember Mickey, so she gives him a locket, "she removes a locket from around her neck." Now, this is not unusual, to give some one a locket, but there is some guilt as she tells Edward to keep it a secret, "But keep it a secret eh, Eddie?

  2. Family seperation - Hot seating and role play - I have chosen to do ...

    We wouldn't use any spot lighting because this wouldn't be so effective. By the narrator being seen only by the audience and contrasting with the other characters was interesting. By there being a spotlight on the narrator wouldn't be so effective.

  1. What is a hero? In this essay I will be discussing three short stories ...

    that it says 'festering already' gives the impression that the amputation must have happened recently. Another twist comes in this already complicated story. When the child sees what has happened, she crosses herself and alerts the neighbours. '...And cried out so loud the neighbours heard her and came rushing in.

  2. 'Street Scene' was written by Elmer Rice and exploits the values of a Catholic ...

    a diner in a Beverley Hills for a measly $3.60 an hour. Well I suppose that it's the closest I'll ever get to Hollywood. I dunno whether moving here was a good choice, I got in with this casting director I met in a bar in Brooklyn one night.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work