• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Two poems with a completely the opposite views of love are Valentine written by Carol Anne Duffy in the 2oth century and How Do I Love Thee written by Elizabeth Barett Browning written in the 19th.

Extracts from this document...


A Comparison of Two Poems About Love and Relationships Two poems with a completely the opposite views of love are ?Valentine? written by Carol Anne Duffy in the 2oth century and ?How Do I Love Thee? written by Elizabeth Bareth Browning written in the 19th century. ?How Do I Love Thee? is a poem written by a wife describing her love for her husband. She portrays love as a fairy tale, with red roses, hearts, gifts and happiness, passion and devotion, whereas the second poem ? ?Valentine? portrays a more realistic side of love, where love is a powerful, passionate and wonderful emotion, but it does occasionally come with drawbacks. In relationships, unrealistic expectations help no-one. In the first two lines of the poem, the poet describes the intensity of her love. She measures the size of her love to the size of the universe ? ?How do I love thee!? let me count the ways? and ?I love thee to the depth breadth and height?. The next couple of lines she explains that the love she has is like a basic need of life; such as food and shelter. She feels that she needs to love from the beginning of the day to the end; just the way she needs to possess the basic nededs of life. ...read more.


These two lines suggest that she has lost people people in her childhood, and has learned to love the way she wished she had been loved as a child. By giving us an insight in to her past and childhood, she has made it very clear that these painful events have affected the way that she loves at present. Even though there is only a small portion of her pain and grief revealed, she gives us quite a realistic picture of herself. All in all, I feel that even though the poem could be analysed negatively, there are more positive aspects to it. I feel that she is indeed in love and is portraying the emotion in a very significant way. She portrays herself to be happy and shows us that indeed even though she has suffered losses and been lonely in the past, she has overcome it all and learnt to love again. The second poem ?Valentine? is written in a much more modern form. It is an unusual poem and possibly gives a more realistic view of love. ?Valentine? begins on a much harsher tone. The title ?Valentine? makes the reader imagine that the poem is actually about love, and is related to Valentines day. This is not really the case as it is not related to romantic love, but this poem uses an onion (a symbol of representation of love) ...read more.


The poem also focus on the thoughts and emotions of the speaker, you could imagine the reactions of the person they?re talking to. The poet also never reveals the sex or identity of either person. As you can see, there are quite a lot of differences in the two poems. One creates the image of the writer being in love and expresses a passionate emotion. She is crazy about her husband and can not imagine a life without him. She portrays the good side of love, and expresses the joy as well as happiness that love brings. On the other hand the second poem portrays a completely different side of love ? a side we do not usually associate with love. She compares love to an onion and describes the pain that love gives a person. The heart breaks, and the figths. There is a strong message behind the second poem, because it tells us how much love can hurt a person. I think that both poems are useful, because they portray and tell us the truth about love. They show us the happiness and joy that love brings, and the pains and sorrow that a broken heart can bring. All in all I agree with both poets perspectives of love, because they are both quite reliable. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Pre and Post 1914 Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Pre and Post 1914 Comparison essays

  1. We have studied two poems Follower and STRONGMAN. These two poems are from two ...

    The word 'plod' is also onomatopoeia. These two quotes create a very good imagery of the father and son. In the fifth stanza the son talks about how he admires his father and how he wants to be like him, following his footsteps "I wanted to grow up and plough, to close one eye, stiffen my arm."

  2. Look at the different ways in which Shakespeare, Duffy and Clarke present relationships in ...

    Furthermore he says in the first line that there can be no obstacle to true love. Shakespeare also repeats key words in the same sentence such as "alters" and "remove" to emphasise the point he is making. In the second quatrain, Shakespeare explains how love cannot be changed "it is an ever fixed mark" meaning that it cannot be moved.

  1. Compare and Contrast Four Sonnets Essay - 'Let Me Not'; 'Death Be Not Proud'; ...

    In his sonnet, Owen uses an extended metaphor; he is comparing the normal funeral proceedings, in peacetime, with the hasty and inappropriate goodbyes said to the soldiers who died for our country and future. He begins both stanzas with rhetorical questions, like Shakespeare does in his opening line of 'Shall I compare thee'.

  2. Essay Question: Discuss both poets of murder, revenge and violence in Salome by Carol ...

    It is not the poet speaking to us, but the voice of the character he has created. In 'Salome' and 'The Laboratory' both the speakers want to take revenge however the speakers of the poem have different motives. 'The laboratory' motive is for the speaker to only kill her lover

  1. Compare how death is presented in Hitcher and one poem by Carol Ann Duffy. ...

    This simile describes the look in which the speaker demands for. As this imagery compares death to jewels, which truly highlights the importance her creation has to her. It can also be seen as her trying to make it as beautiful as possible, in order to appeal to her enemy, who will be a victim of death.

  2. William Blake and Carol Ann Duffy both utilize powerful imagery to describe ...

    This image of an uncompassionate God is reinforced when God is questioned to have ?dread hand? and ?dread feet? for creating this creature. The use of the adjective of ?dread? to describe God produces powerful images that oppose the assumed kindness of God, implying that this all-powerful figure may also harbour malicious intent.

  1. Compare how poets present the theme of love in; Havisham, Valentine, My last Duchess, ...

    Also the use of the word ?alter? provides us with the information that Shakespeare is trying to relate love to Christian worship, making love sound symbolic and pure, and the repetition of the word ?alter? strengthens his point. At the end of both of the sonnets, Shakespeare can?t help but

  2. How are male and female relationships portrayed in "Romeo and Juliet", Valentine by Carol ...

    By following the word ?fierce? by its antithesis ?love? Duffy emphasises loves unstable and aggressive nature. Imperatives such as ?here? and ?Take it? express the fact that the person (Duffy) is commanding them to take their love. The onions ?platinum loops? represent a strong circle of trust that cannot be

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work