Would you classify Stevens or Miss Kenton as a better human being? Your reasons? In the novel Remains of The Day, the protagonist of the story, Stevens reflects how an individual will put aside all things just to serve

Authors Avatar

Remains of The Day (Kazuo Ishiguro)

Would you classify Stevens or Miss Kenton as a better human being? Your reasons?

        In the novel Remains of The Day, the protagonist of the story, Stevens reflects how an individual will put aside all things just to serve his master to the utmost. Stevens is a butler who believes that serving his master will show his loyalty, dignity and his professionalism. Throughout this novel, we can see that he tries so hard to follow what his master has to say about everything. His unchallenged loyalty can be seen throughout this novel. The other significant character in this novel is Miss Kenton. Miss Kenton possesses different characteristic from Stevens. Miss Kenton shares Stevens’ efficiency and intelligence, but she possesses warmth and personality, cannot be seen in Stevens’ character. The question in which one of the characters that should be classified as a better human being is very hard to decide. Taking the full consideration on the characteristics of both of these characters, I think that Miss Kenton is the one that should be deemed as a better human being – even though she does not posses all the qualities in her.

        Miss Kenton can be considered as a better human being because unlike Stevens, she does not substitute Lord Darlington's values for her own; she makes decisions based on her own thoughts and beliefs. In this sense, she displays more dignity and personal integrity than Stevens ever does. Where as for Stevens, his relentless pursuit of dignity leads him to constantly deny his own feelings throughout the novel. For Stevens, dignity involves put on a mask of professional composure at all times. Although there is merit in the ideas of modesty and loyalty, Stevens takes these concepts to an extreme. He never tells anyone what he truly feels and he gives his absolute trust to Lord Darlington. Little that he realizes that, the man that he honours is a man who himself makes some very poor choices in his life. Stevens's pursuit of dignity in his professional life completely takes over his personal life as well. By suppressing his individuality in this manner, he never achieves true intimacy with another person. The fact that his view of dignity is so misguided is sad; we can tell that Stevens has wanted great things, but that he has gone about attaining them the wrong way.

Join now!

        Miss Kenton on the other hand, never thinks that everything that her master does is right. She argues when Lord Darlington instructed Stevens to dismiss the two German girls just because Lord Darlington hates to have any Jews in his house. She thinks that their religion has nothing to do with the dismissal of the two girls. “…you are saying that Ruth and Sarah are to be dismissed on the grounds that they are Jewish?” She strongly feels that dismissing these two girls would be wrong just because they are Jewish. She is so frustrated when Stevens tells her to ...

This is a preview of the whole essay