• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Deforestation of the Amazon rainforest is a major global environmental issue, which only the Brazilian government can solve'

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Deforestation of the Amazon rainforest is a major global environmental issue, which only the Brazilian government can solve' I have been asked to write an assignment arguing the hypothesis above. In my assignment I am going to argue both sides of the hypothesis. I will then write my own opinion and conclusion of the hypothesis. Deforestation occurs when people cut down trees and replace that land with cattle ranches and farms in effect reducing the size of the forest. Problems can arise from the different ways in which people want to use their environment. "Amerindians who are native to the Amazon are being forced out of their natural habitat by loggers, miners and settlers. The Amerindian population has dropped 96% and is now just 220,000." In this scenario the problems which are caused can be very serious in that people and animals can end up dying, because of others wanting to use their environment in another way. This source may not be accurate as it is outdated 4 years and things may have changed. ...read more.

Middle

(Christian aid booklet) This source taken from a charity booklet suggests that there are ways to stop the current problems from developing. It is quite reliable because it is from a charity booklet. The date of the source is absent so judging its relevance may be hard. May be open to bias. "Timber companies from Indonesia, South Korea and Malaysia are buying p large parts f the forest west of the Amazon. Friar Hector Turrihi, an Italian missionary, talks tearfully of the destruction: 'rubber tappers and Indians are being driven out to live in shanty towns outside the cities. Today we know we can make more money from conserving the forest than by destroying it.'" (The Guardian - June 1996) This source is likely to be unbiased as it is a newspaper article. It is quite old and the things stated in it may not be true. "Brazil has the largest foreign debt of any developing country in the world - well over $100 billion." (World Development Report 1990) This source indicates that Brazil is trying to get out of debt by selling parts of the rainforest. ...read more.

Conclusion

Yet Manoel Cardaso, an economist from the University of Campinas, points out that in 1995 the government spent $12 billion on rescue operations for private companies and banks. "In Brazil the rich are very rich and very power powerful" says Salgado. "For land distribution to change those with privilege would have to give up some of their wealth and power. They don't want to. Why would they?" (Brazil resource booklet 1997) This source was written in 1997 nearly 6 years ago, degrading its reliability and accuracy. It was made by a reliable author. The facts contained might be slightly exaggerated. This source is unlikely to be biased as it is part of a resource booklet. My own opinion of this matter is that both sides can benefit if they look out for each others needs as much as they look out for their own. Both parties get what they want if the Amazon rainforest benefits from sustainable development. At the present time MNC's are taking advantage of the lack of defence of the Amazonian tribes and local people. So the only thing that can stop the MNC's from taking advantage is the Brazilian government itself. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Physical Geography section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Physical Geography essays

  1. Should people be allowed to destroy the Amazon Rainforest?

    The loss of forests has increases flooding in places such as the flood plains of the Ganges River in Bangladesh. The Ganges River's source is in the foothills of the Himalayas. From there it moves along the very fertil floodplain of Bangladesh and towards the sea.

  2. Epping Forest

    there will more bare ground in pillow mounds then in rushey plain. In rushey plain there is 0% of bare ground in rushey plain. This means more people go to pillow mounds then rushey plain. Comparing the two sites and looking at the data it seems that more people go to pillow mounds then rushey plain.

  1. Population distribution in Brazil

    The highest population in Brazil is distributed in the eastern parts of plateau around Sao Paulo and on the outer skirts of the coast. Even though the temperatures are very high and the humidity is up in the 80%'s there is a good water supply, several harbours provided, which encouraged trade and growth of industry.

  2. How Is the Amazon Rainforest Seen As a Resource - the Arguments For and ...

    I have no problem with what I do. The trees will grow back and if not, well at least it brings money and jobs to Brazil.

  1. Describe the pattern of population distribution in Brazil.

    Carajas gave Brazil the development push it needed. Otherwise it would still be a L.E.D.C. Anything that gives a country a change and development is significant and it definitely changed it for the better.

  2. rainforest tribes

    enemies it will be; as men are warriors, many of them are killed in battles with neighbouring groups; by limiting the number of women in a group, the group's ability to reproduce is naturally restricted. Although these measures may seem harsh to us, they are perfectly logical and an essential feature of life in the rain forest.

  1. Geography in the News

    Conor: Snow also forms a crisp layer if left overnight, due to low temperatures freezing it over. This is why snow is far icier and heavier if left a day than when it falls. The snow which hit Britain was called a snowstorm, which means it lasts longer, is more

  2. How and why does environmental quality change around Croydon?

    I re-joined my group so we could carry out our Croydon survey on unsuspecting members of the public. We then returned to Whitgift to import out data onto the school computers. Annotated Map of Croydon (attached) The following locations of importance have been identified on Map 2 using large numbered circles: 1.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work