• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How useful are Sources A, B and C to an historian studying the attitudes of British soldiers to their commanders during the First World War? Use Sources A to C and knowledge form your studies in your answer

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

1. Evaluation of sources for their utility How useful are Sources A, B and C to an historian studying the attitudes of British soldiers to their commanders during the First World War? Use Sources A to C and knowledge form your studies in your answer. Source A is a cartoon from the British magazine Punch. Punch was known for its attention to detail, therefore at the very least the source is reliable, and therefore can be useful. Although I have not managed to find any information on the picture on the internet, its style and design suggest that it was done during the time of the war, or just after. The fact that it is ridiculing generals suggests the latter; however Punch is a controversial magazine, so this is not definite. Either way, the author had a good opportunity to have accurate information, straight from the soldiers who had been on the front and in the rehearsals, but weren't currently serving. Indeed, the source would most probably have these soldiers' opinions as its origin. ...read more.

Middle

However, to be fully useful, other sources would have to be used to verify these assumptions. Source B is a quote from a comedy television series. More exactly, it is from the 6th episode of Blackadder goes forth, and was first broadcast on the 2nd November 1989, and presumably written not long before. This means that the scriptwriter (Ben Elton) most probably would have not consulted actual soldiers, nor had been there himself. Indeed, Ben Elton was born in 1959, making it impossible for him to have been a soldier, and anyone he would interview would have to be at least 88, and I doubt that the scriptwriter would go to such lengths. However, what it does do is base itself on common opinions. Since, as I have previously mentioned, the common view was that of the soldier of his family, it would have been based on soldiers' views. If this was taken alone, it would make the source very useful. Also, the scriptwriter would have unconscious bias against the generals, simply from the society. ...read more.

Conclusion

He would therefore not only have conscious bias due to his feeling of loyalty to his family, but would also have unconscious bias due to his father's bringing up. Earl Haig mentions what the old soldiers thought. However, he would not have actually talked to them, but would have just heard his father saying this. In turn, Field Marshall Haig would not have had very accurate reports on his soldiers' attitudes to his plans, for the simple reason that they would have been afraid to say anything bad about them. This stops the source from being reliable for soldiers' opinions. An unreliable source is rarely useful by itself. Furthermore, Earl Haig's purpose in saying this would be to somewhat rescue his father's reputation; therefore he may have been inclined to bend the truth somewhat. In conclusion, Earl Haig's quote is an attempt to rescue his father's reputation based on unreliable information given to him by his father. It is unreliable, and since a historian can't tell whether what he says is true or not, it is in no way useful in finding out what soldiers thought about generals, especially Haig. Leszek Swirski Question 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. World war 1

    Source A, is written by Haig in June 1916; he writes this letter to the British public, 'The nation must be prepared to see heavy casualty list'. By this Haig means that the public should not be shocked when they see a big number of men dieing, they need to

  2. How useful are sources A, B and C to an historian studying the attitudes ...

    It is very hard to tell whether this source is biased or not because we do not know where the producers of the show got their information or whether they were trying to provide a biased view. However the writers were well educated and it is very probable they did lots of research.

  1. Styal Mill - Study sources A, B, C and D. Which of these sources ...

    was found in London where he made a statement to a local magistrate. This source is useful in telling us information about the mill. He talks about the sleeping arrangement and how they got clean shirts every Sunday. He then goes on to mention that none of the machinery was

  2. Haig in sources

    to their deaths, Britain suffered 420,000 casualties, and nearly 20,000 were killed on the first day alone. Enormous courage was shown by the soldiers but betrayed by the leaders. "Lions led by Donkeys". 3. Study Sources D and E What do you think Haig expected to happen on the first day of the Somme?

  1. Did the First World War liberate British women?

    Iw ould say this source is usefull because it explains in more detail what we alredy know plus it is from a womans point of view, but it may not be as reliable because we don't know who wrote it but we do know that it is from a book

  2. You have been commissioned to undertake research into attitudes toward the Good Friday Agreement ...

    If we look at the results we can see that 54.7% of the population that had the ability to vote voted yes to the GFA. 13.8% voted no and 16.2% did not vote at all. This implies that the majority of the population at the time of the referendum felt that the GFA would be of benefit to the country.

  1. How useful are sources A, B, and C to a historian studying the attitudes ...

    It was written in the 1990's so the writer would have access to much information about the feelings of men on the front. However, it is a comedy program and is meant to be funny, not teach a lesson about the views of soldiers about their commanders and as such

  2. How useful are sources A,B and C to an historian studying the attitudes of ...

    The soldiers feel that the General is never there. Source B: This source is useful in studying the attitudes of soldiers towards their commanders. This source tells me that the soldiers do not have any respect towards their commanders. This source was written after the war in a series called "Blackadder goes forth" on BBC TV.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work