• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Lister, a Crank?

Extracts from this document...


Coursework Assignment 2 John Rudd Leeson, who was Joseph Listers assistant wrote a book that was published in 1927 called 'Lister as I knew him'. We get a small section from the book, in it, Leeson explains Lister as less important than others may have been in the 19th Century. In the section of the book that we get, Leeson even compares Lister to a crank. Our interpretation from this would be that Leeson thinks badly of Lister for some reason and that Lister is seen to be a Crank, which is someone who is strange, weird, odd and not important. The reason we come to this as our interpretation is because Leeson says "He was no longer looked upon as the founder of a new system that was to revolutionise surgery, but he was regarded as a crank". Source A is a piece of text that explains how hard it was to convince Surgeons to change their old ways in them days. Source E is an artist's impression that was drawn; it shows an experiment that was done using anaesthetics. Source F is a piece of text called "The Carbolic Spray" and it talks about how the spray is unreliable and doesn't work. Source G is a 19th Century Print showing Carbolic Acid being used during an operation. Source H is a table that was from Listers records that he kept from treating fractures using Carbolic Acid. Source I is an extract taken from Pasteur's lecture about experiments with germs. Finally, Source J is a book that is Listers opinion about Pasteur's work. Some of these sources are for our interpretation, some are against, but some can even be used in both cases. Source D is an extract from a book called 'Speed rather than Germs' from Joseph Lister, and it was written by W.Watson.Cheyne and it was published in 1927. Listers theory was that germs caused infection and antiseptic disease. ...read more.


Source H is a Record of Lister when he was treating fractures using Carbolic Acid. It explains that from 1864 to 1866, before Carbolic Spray was introduces the fractures treated were 34, and from that 15 people died, and only 19 recovered. The table to results then explain that during 1867 and 1870, after the introduction of Carbolic Spray the number of fractures treated was 40, and from that 34 recovered and only 6 died. This shows that the death rate decreased dramatically after Carbolic Spray was introduced and therefore implies that it works well and does the job that it is intended to do. This Source argues against the interpretation that Lister was a Crank because the fact that the Death rate decreased dramatically after the introduction of the Carbolic Spray implies that Lister made something that worked well. Also, the fact that Lister kept a record of results gives the impression that he was an organised person who knew what he was doing which also went against the interpretation. The Source gives the impression that Lister was a very important person who gave a lot to medical care and surgery and that he was not a Crank, but someone who dramatically improved surgery with the Carbolic Spray. Source I is an extract of one of Pasteur's lectures given at a university of Parris in 1864 about how he discovered the germ theory. Pasteur was responsible for creating the germ theory and this source highlights one of his experiments. The Source explains that if you leave something for a small amount of time then it becomes mouldy, but if you heat it, then it removes any germs that may be present. He continues to explain that if you block off the air from coming into contact with the matter, then it will stay fresh and will not get mouldy for weeks, months, and even years! ...read more.


Because of all this I think all people rely on all other people to keep everything working, so I do not believe that Lister was any more of a crank than the others were. If aftercare was poor, then patience would also die, Florence Nightingale was a nurse who introduced many schools so that training nurses could get new training in the art of medicine, she also made it so that ward floors were cleaned, and that beds were spaced further apart to give people more room. Nightingale also made sure that all equipment and bedding was washed fully between patients to prevent the spread of infection. She made sure that wards had a lot of fresh air and that all rooms were clean at all times. She also changed the look as nurses, in the early 19th century nurses were seen as drunken prostitutes, and after Florence Nightingale that all changed! The things Florence did made the death rate from aftercare go down dramatically! The fact that Leeson came to the conclusion that Lister was a Crank could be down to many reasons, especially since he was Listers Assistant. He could have done this because they could have had an argument, just because they are colleagues doesn't mean they have to be friends. It could also be due to the fact that Leeson may have thought that he was more important that Lister and that he wasn't getting the credit that he should be getting, this could have caused him to feel professional jealousy. The other reason could also be due to the fact that Leeson actually believes that Lister was less important compared to other people; Leeson would spend a lot of time with him so he could have seen another side of him that would have been stranger making him see him as a crank. The other thing that could cause Leeson to say these things about Lister is the fact that the quote could have been written out of context. ?? ?? ?? ?? David Ashcroft 11B ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE History Projects section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE History Projects essays

  1. History of Medicine - the development of anaesthetics

    There was no infection. Lister's own figures showed that death rates due to infection for his patients went from 46% before he started using carbolic spray to only 15% after he started using it. In 1867, Lister published his ideas and results to show other surgeons the value of using carbolic spray.

  2. Why did medical care need to be improved during the early 19th century

    Chloroform was only invented in 1847 so it was unlikely that it was used in amputations at this time. The source also does not show how equipment would not have been sterilized before it was used, and it did not shot that equipment had wooden handles that would collect germs

  1. Louis Pasteur V Edwin Chadwick

    micro-organisms to disease, when the silk industry discovered many of its silkworms had been struck down with disease. As with the beer, Pasteur managed to find a link between a specific micro-organism and the disease and showed the factory owners how to solve the problem.

  2. Stoke Bruerne: Canal lives

    must have been in the higher division and status of society back then. The child describes, "It is a pretty village". This description seems to, en overgenerous description whereby the normal child would not have had this opinion. This is because many were involved in hard work so their opinion would completely differ.

  1. ww1 continues

    While the elected institutions had little power compared with the Kaiser it was feared that some form of political revolution was imminent. Russia was in midst of a large scale military build-up and reform which was to be completed in 1916-17.

  2. Battlefields Coursework

    It is emotional to see such graves as Rifleman Valentine Joe Strudwick, age 15, who was killed by a sniper in 1915. Hundreds of underage soldiers signed up, the youngest being Private John Cordon of the 2nd Royal Irish Regiment, who died 24th May 1915, aged just 14.

  1. History of Medicine Revision Notes.

    1. The Beveridge report in 1942[bq]: 1. Stated that the Government should provide Healthcare for ALL members of society not just the rich! [a]For example, cuts and bruises were covered with animal fat and bound up with bark Arun Thind [b]The medicine man would try to locate this bone and draw the bad spirit Arun Thind [c]She was a pregnant hippopotamus (the goddess of Childbirth)

  2. History of plastic surgery; how plastic surgery became a usual thing in Korea

    Moreover, in the book ?Asian-Americans Criticize Eyelid Surgery Craze,? in Women?s E-news in 2004, there was a report saying, "South Korea has the highest ratio of cosmetic surgeons to citizens worldwide.? To make it short and clear, Korea is the best in cosmetic surgery and it is now a very ordinary thing in Korea.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work