• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10

Martin and Malcolm: Two Voices for Justice

Extracts from this document...


Martin and Malcolm: Two Voices for Justice America in the mid-twentieth century was turbulent with civil unrest among the black community. In the face of white oppression it tested the limits of democracy to achieve the rights entitled to all under the Constitution. Rising to the forefront of this struggle for civil rights were two men, whose leadership and passion distinguished them as the two major black voices of the time. These men are Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X. Although each was fighting for the cause of freedom, their means for achieving it differed significantly. However, as the civil rights movement gained momentum each developed an appreciation for the other's work. The circumstances surrounding Martin and Malcolm's upbringings contrasted greatly. Martin was born on January 15, 1929, in Atlanta, Georgia into a middle-class family.1 As the son of a prominent Atlanta Baptist minister, Martin was instilled with the ideals of justice, love, obedience, and hope. Through the church he was taught that the integrationist values of protest, accommodation, self-help, and optimism were the best means through which to cause change.2 Along with religion, education played an important role in Martin's development. At the early age of fifteen he was accepted to Morehouse College, where he earned a degree in sociology, and went on to pursue a divinity degree at Crozer Seminary in Pennsylvania, and a Ph.D. ...read more.


He viewed integration as blacks begging whites to become part of their institutions, and said, "No one respects or appreciates a beggar." To Malcolm, there could be no unity based on equality between blacks and whites until there was first unity within the black community. 22 Dominating both Martin's dream of America and Malcolm's nightmare of America were two distinctive religious traditions in the black community. One was Christianity, which blacks reshaped in light of their struggle for dignity in American society. The other was Islam, which blacks also redefined to express their hostility towards the white oppressors of American society.23 Martin based his idea of the American dream on the assumption that America was a Christian nation, which had failed to fulfill its religious identity as the Kingdom of God, as well as its moral vision of freedom and justice. As a Black Muslim, Malcolm based part of his idea of the American nightmare on the myth of Yacob, which claimed that "an evil black scientist created the evil white race six thousand years ago because they were destined to rule the world for that period of time." He believed that America was doomed because "the God of justice" would destroy it for its sins.24 Linking the two denominations of Martin and Malcolm was faith, which had been created in the black struggle for dignity. ...read more.


In private, among close friends, Martin reportedly said, "I just saw Malcolm on television. I can't deny it. When he starts talking about all that's been done to us, I get a twinge of hate, of identification with him."36 Equally significant was Martin's adoption of such phrases as "blackness" and "domestic colonialism," words coined by Malcolm. Martin even concluded that "temporary segregation" was probably the only way to overcome powerlessness in the black community. Also, Martin began to admit, like Malcolm, that there were only a small number of whites that were genuinely committed to equality. Due to their profound respect and effect on each other, James Baldwin claimed that "by the time each met his death, there was practically no difference between them."37 Although Martin and Malcolm complemented each other, they also corrected each other. Martin still challenged Malcolm's abusive and vindictive language against whites, and believed that his philosophy of self-defense was foolish. Likewise, Malcolm remained militant and challenged Martin's idea of nonviolence.38 Realistically, a genuine coalition between the two men could never have existed because of their loyalty to self-defense and nonviolence, both of which were derived from their different religious faiths. Neither was willing to compromise on these issues.39 Together, Martin and Malcolm lifted the black community out from the pits of depravity and shame. They each symbolized a necessary component in the civil rights movement. The legacies they left behind continue to inspire those in the struggle for racial justice. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE USA 1941-80 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE USA 1941-80 essays

  1. Examine the beliefs of Martin Luther King and Malcolm X. Comment on the differences ...

    I believe his message of equality was the better one, compared to Malcolm X's view of segregation, trying to improve the situation for black people by trying to raise them higher than whites, was wrong as it would end up probably causing the black people more harm.

  2. How did Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X influence the Black people's oppression ...

    Muhammed taught that the white race was doing all in their power to prevent blacks from uniting and fighting back and achieving political, economic and social success. When Malcolm left prison, he was released a change man with the ambition to make a change using whatever force necessary.

  1. Political Philosophy of Dr. Martin Luther King and Malcolm X - a comparison.

    Kennedy reacting to the rallies and the attitude of Alabama Governor George Wallace submitted the Civil Rights Act to Congress. On August 2nd in 1963 more than 250.000 people participated in King�s March on Washington. There, on the steps of Lincoln Memorial, King gave his famous "I Have a Dream" speech.

  2. Mahatma Gandhi's effort for freedom

    If a woman works in offices, educational institutions, and factories without fear or uncertainty it is thanks to Gandhi and his followers (Potpourri). A whole generation of women leaders came up influenced by Gandhi's vision (Potpourri). Although some eastern women are very different from the western in many ways since some still have their traditional beliefs (Potpourri).

  1. "Religion's are notorious for promoting Racial Segregation". Discuss with reference to one specific historical ...

    The views of the group Stemmed from Christianity, not politics as it seemed to do with other anti-racist groups such as the 'Nation of Islam' Organisation (NOI)-see information of Malcolm X. The Importance of the SCLC was that now the Black Church, a powerful organisation in the south was to become fully Involved in the struggle for civil rights.

  2. Martin Luther King Jr.

    postgraduate student; during this transition I have made new discoveries and developed new understanding. Comparative analysis The following table was created in order to evaluate and compare some key entrepreneurial characteristics of Dr. Martin Luther King, Bill Gates and Myself.

  1. South Africa and Apartheid: Have the effects of apartheid disappeared?

    According to source J, much less Africans have household services than whites. For example, 32.7% of Africans have running tap-water compared to the 96.9% of whites. These two sources are fairly accurate because they are household surveys. Source K shows that white South Africans have a considerably higher quality of life than black south Africans.

  2. Case Study on Swazi culture

    the network of kinship allowed the political system to continue even under the British administration. Both the king and the queen mother still receive elaborate deference. Their subjects crouch when addressing them and refer to them by flattering titles. Both are regularly treated with kingship medicine to give them personality.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work