• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Votes For Women - Source related study.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Votes For Women - Coursework Assignment Two Source A depicts pictorially a list of positive roles a woman could have at the time and a list of negative things a man could have been. It shows that while a woman could be a respected member of society she was still not allowed to vote, whereas a man could be a criminal or unfit in the eyes of society yet still have the vote. The poster is a peaceful means of protest, yet quite crude in the way it is presented, for example it contains bold drawings of a "drunkard" and "proprietor of white slaves". Other pictures, such as those of a "lunatic" and one "unfit for service" were compared directly above to possible female positions of a "nurse" and "doctor or teacher" respectively. These are the closest opposites in roles that existed at the time so are effective in comparison. The main implication of the picture is that a man could vote whatever his stature, be it worthless or not, but a woman could not either way. The poster is a useful source as it shows the law of the time, 1912, that all men could vote no matter what they had been but women could not. This was unjust from the women's point of view and added to their frustration at not being allowed the vote. The designers of the poster used it to illustrate the double standards employed by the Government. Source C is a cartoon by Bernard Partridge drawn in 1906 of two female suffrage campaigners. One is a Suffragist, meaning a member of the National Union of Women's Suffrage Societies (who campaigned using peaceful methods) and the other is a Suffragette, a member of the Women's Social and Political Union, which was a more militant organisation that used violence in their protest. The caption reads, "The Shrieking Sister," and the implication of the picture is that the Suffragettes only made the campaign situation worse for both groups by being uncivilised. ...read more.

Middle

Again, over 200 women were arrested and police raided the WSPU headquarters in Bow. Christabel Pankhurst avoided arrest and fled to France. Later that year, Asquith was attacked by Suffragettes and Mary Leigh almost burned down the Theatre Royal Dublin. Public opinion was not behind the Suffragettes anymore, as a result of their often shocking violent tactics. In 1911 the Anti Suffrage League was established. It quickly gained members and was able to give a petition to Parliament with over 250 000 signatures against votes for women. In June 1912, Asquith introduced the Franchise and Registration Bill. He planned to make four amendments to get women the vote, but the Speaker of the House of Commons claimed that they would change the Bill so much it would have to be withdrawn. The bill was abolished just six months later. Asquith tried a Private Members Bill to get votes for women but this also failed. Source E is part of a speech by an MP in 1913 stating that he would vote against women's suffrage, because he believed that in giving women the vote the Government would also give women the "control of the government of this country." This was the feeling of many MP's who did not want to see these violent women in charge of the country, but chose to ignore the intelligent, respectable women and their same cause. Following the failures of the Conciliation Bill and the Franchise and Registration Bill, increased Suffragette violence hardened public support and sympathy for the campaigners and led to Sylvia Pankhurst's departure from the group. Pankhurst had been the respectable face of the movement, proving they were not all working class violent protestors. Emmeline Pethick-Lawrence and her husband also left, taking their crucial money with them. They believed the WSPU was becoming too violent and moved to East London to help the poor. Emmeline Pankhurst was by now acting like a dictator, giving all the power to Annie Kenney who was not one to make good decisions or lead well. ...read more.

Conclusion

But the source shows that opinions had changed, as does Source I, "a tremendous mood favourable to change had been created." The war had enabled women to go to work and prove they were just as capable of serving their country as men. They also achieved more freedom, being allowed shorter skirts and more interesting hairstyles. Source H notes a further point, in that women had brought up their sons well to fight, which was another service to the government in the time of war. This idea, whilst being supportive to the women, was still old fashioned and not what women were aiming for overall, this being independence and respect as people, not child bearers. At the end of the war, whilst having earned more respect from politicians and other men, all women did not have the vote. The Representation of the People Act was passed to give the vote to all men over the age of 21, as many had lost it since joining the forces. The act was a chance to give women the vote at the same time, but only women over the age of 30 could vote. 364 MP's voted for women's suffrage and only 23 against because they had to recognise what the women had done for the war and that many of the previous arguments against women's suffrage were not valid anymore. 6 million out of 13 million women were allowed the vote in 1918, which was a good start for the suffrage campaigners. After this was a success and many realised votes for women was not as bad as they had presumed, the Representation of the People Act of 1928 gave the vote to all women over the age of 21, on the same terms as men. It had taken the efforts of women before the war to alert the government of their wishes, and those during the war to persuade politicians and the public that they deserved the vote. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. Outline and assess the contributions made by the NUWSS and the WSPU to the ...

    (Pg 17). In spite of the opposition, by the end of the 19th Century the NUWSS seemed strong, that was until 1903, and the formation of the Women's Social and Political Union. Emmiline Pankhurst formed the WSPU on October 10th 1903, she wrote in her book 'In my own words'

  2. Women working in WW1. Source D is a picture of women working in ...

    It also doesn't mention that the women will no longer be required in factory work when the war ends. After looking at both Sources we can learn that it is a propaganda report. Source E, as we know, is a poster produced by the government that shows a woman happily

  1. Why did the Liberals decline between 1908-1918?

    They even lost limbs and many returned home as human corpses. This caused horrific injuries and many were blinded, could not walk or talk.

  2. Votes for Women - Historical Issue Coursework

    A limitation of Source F is that it shows only one occupation. If we had only seen that one advertisement, we would be none the wiser as to whether women were being employed in other professions. This limits the usefulness as it is very narrow in the information it gives.

  1. History Revision for year 11. The Liberal Reforms, the Beveridge Reforms and the ...

    The situation got even worse in 1909 when the Liberals tried to raise taxes to pay for all of the spending. The Conservatives tried to block the Liberals plans by using their majority in the House of Lords, but were eventually forced to give way.

  2. Women & the British Car Industry

    Question 5 - Collection D Compare the sources carefully. How do you account for the differences? Source 1 is a wages book produced by Rover Group in 1941. It was made to keep track of all the weekly wage payments.

  1. The Matchgirls' Strike, 1888

    5. Study all of the Sources. "The Matchgirls' strike was not an important event in the History of Trade Unions" Use the Sources, and your own knowledge, to explain whether you agree with this view. This statement is an oversimplistication of the truth. Not many people would agree with this, e.g.

  2. How effectively did the Liberals help children, the old and the unemployed?

    The only downside to the scheme was that the inspectors were not permitted to give treatment, so poverty stricken children were being made aware of their very ill health but there was nothing they could do to make them better, as a result of this the 1912 School Clinics were very well embraced.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work