• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why is the battle of the somme regarded as such a great military tragedy.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Why is the Battle of the Somme regarded as such a great military tragedy? The word tragedy means an intensely sad, calamitous, fatal event of course of events; disaster. I think the most important reasons that the battle of the Somme is such a great tragedy are the scale of casualties, human suffering and individual loss, bad planning and leadership and the failure to achieve objectives. One of the reasons that the Battle of the Somme was such a great tragedy was due the bad planning and leadership by Sir Douglas Haig. The plans that were originally made by Rawlinson were changed this didn't have as much effect of breaking up the Germans defences. The troops were inexperienced, also there weren't as many experienced officers as their needed to be, to tell the soldiers what to do, but also to feed back to Haig quicker and more efficiently. The Somme was meant to relieve pressure from Verdun and because of this the French were only able to contribute half the men they said they would and this made it a mainly British attack. If there had been more help from Britain's ally France then the battle would have been more successful. Haig didn't think his plan through properly, he was hopeful that the bombardment would break through the German lines and bring the allies victory. It was a pointless exercise because the Germans hid in prepared dugouts and the defence line wasn't broken. Even after the amount of casualties on the first day Haig didn't' change his mind about the methods of warfare he employed. After a while Haig thought altering his plan to fight a war of attrition would be more successful, this also didn't work as the British casualties became even higher and not much land was gained at all. In the end the, after 3 months the decision was made by Haig to stop the battle. ...read more.

Middle

Later Haig was criticised for using tanks before their design was complete. Another main reason was the human suffering. The soldiers in the trenches lived in very poor conditions. The trenches were filthy and muddy and often flooded with water to around waist height, this meant the soldiers had to walk around in cold muddy water that got to freezing temperatures in the winter. Standing in the trench for a long time in these conditions gave some soldiers a disease called trench foot that causes the foot to swell up and go numb, eventually it would rot and in extreme cases the whole foot had to be amputated. Some men also got 'Shellshock' resulting from the stress of battle and due to the loud noises of the exploding shells and firing guns. They would scream, shudder and moan at any loud noise. These bad conditions made some feel down and depressed. Some men gave themselves a 'blighty' wound to get sent home, others tried to run away. If they were caught they were found guilty of cowardice and were shot by a firing squat. The trenches were also invaded by huge rats that feasted on the dead bodies in no mans land. They produced around 880 offspring a year and were a nuisance to the men living in the trenches. There was no clean water or soap provided for the men to wash with so they remained dirty, and caught lice. These lice lived in warm places on the soldier's bodies and their hair and clothes. They weren't given hot meals and cooking facilities were basic. They had no fresh fruit of vegetables in their diets and were given a non varied diet of bread, bully beef, tea, biscuits, cheese and potatoes. The failure to achieve objectives was another main factor to why the Somme was a great tragedy. The main objective was to achieve a breakthrough on the German lines. ...read more.

Conclusion

They soldiers were instructed by Haig to start with a 3 day long bombardment, by the that time they expected no one to be alive in the German trenches, and when the troops walked to the enemy trenches they only had to fire and the British troops were killed in hundreds. After this attack the battle moved on to the war of attrition that was meant to make German supplies run out over a slow consistent period of time. Instead the British lost an even larger percentage of men and also used up much of the equipment. Near the end of the battle the British army used tanks; these were meant t scare the opponent and were used to protect themselves and crushing the barbed wire and trench system at the German defence line, but once out there the advancing soldiers weren't given any support and in the end the tanks got stuck in the mud or broke down. The British were to slow to act, this gave the Germans time to build up their defences again and their chance was missed. The last reason about why the some was such a great tragedy was because of the large scale of casualties that the British army faced. On the first day alone the British had 60,000 casualties with 20,000 British troops dead and 35,000 wounded. By the end of the war in November 1916 the British had lost in total 420,000 and the French 200,000 and the Germans 500,000. I think the most important reason for the battle of the Somme being such a great military tragedy was the amount of casualties as this is what affected the outcome of the battle. I also think it would have helped if the leadership was better as there would have been more survivors if the plan of the battle had been changed after the first day. I think that the Battle could have been a bigger success if the plans were made quicker and the British army had responded quicker. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. The Battle of The Somme.

    We must bear in mind that these two men actually despised each other, and so would be especially eager to pass the blame onto each other. Source C: (Extract of a report sent in December 1916 by Haig to the British cabinet about the effects of the Battle of the Somme)

  2. Why is the Battle of the Somme regarded as such a great military tragedy?

    Haig's main aim was to gain territorial land from the Germans and destroy their morale. The Germans were ready for the attack commencing 1st July 1916; they had seen the preparations and were expecting a large-scale attack. Consequently they moved their divisions accordingly.

  1. Why is the battle of the Somme regarded as such a great military tragedy?

    One of the main reasons the allied attack failed, is because the inflexibility of the allied soldiers. They had to walk across the land because the grass was muddy and wet. The soldiers had to carry packs on the backs, which made it even more difficult for them to run.

  2. Why was the battle of the Somme Regarded as a Great Military Tragedy?

    This gave them plenty of time from the bombardment stopping and the British troops reaching the other side of no-mans-land. A German machine gunner claimed that 'They went down in their hundreds. You didn't have to aim; we just fired into them,'.

  1. Why is the Battle of the Somme regarded as such a great military tragedy

    Numerous factors would also appear to have been overlooked by Haig, such as the position of the defenders on high ground, with a good view of any attacking forces. The strength of German defences was also underestimated, seeing as the Germans had been in place since 1914 and had set

  2. Why the Battle of the Somme was regarded as such a great military tragedy?

    After all the deaths Haig took the responsibility of the operation and designed a new plan. They then intended to have an 8-day bombardment he believed that would completely destroy the Germans, but he was wrong. General Haig used 750.00 men against a German side who only had 16 divisions in progress.

  1. Was the Battle of the Somme a disaster or a victory for Britain?

    This was called conscription. At first only single men were called up, but then married were too. This is shown in Source A2. Some even lied about their age to actually get into the army and get conscribed to fight in the war. At this time, there was a lot of poverty about in

  2. The great war: The battle of the Somme.

    Others committed suicide as they favoured this to life in the trenches. They would either place the muzzle of their rifles against their head and push the trigger with their toe, or stand on the fire step and get shot by the enemy, as they felt they could not handle the situation any more.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work