• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How might Marshall McLuhan's theory of hot and cold media be used to explain the surge of interest in mobile technology, especially text and picture messaging?

Extracts from this document...


How might Marshall McLuhan's theory of hot and cold media be used to explain the surge of interest in mobile technology, especially text and picture messaging? 'Any invention or technology is an extension or self-amputation of our physical bodies, and such extension also demands new ratios or new equilibriums among the other organs and extensions of the body', Marshall McLuhan in 'Understanding Media' (1964, p43). A comment which has possibly never been truer than when understood with regard to a mobile phone. McLuhan's theories have recently been given new life with the onset of the Internet; however, they can also be usefully applied to the massive explosion of mobile technology. Given it is a medium which some may consider to be cool; its impact on society has been immeasurable. In today's society it is difficult to meet a person between the ages of fifteen and fifty who do not own a mobile phone. Like televisions, it is the electronic accessory of the moment and it is advancing fast. Only five years ago text messaging was in its infancy and not all phones offered it; picture messaging was unheard of. Nowadays picture messaging is very much here and already the technology has moved towards video messaging. Some 'mobile phones' would be more accurately described as hand held computers as the telephony is only a fraction of its capabilities and often not even its main function. As with most mobile phones the main function consumer's use is text messaging. According to McLuhan in 'Understanding Media' (1964) ...read more.


Barthes also wrote about Text itself and its semiotics, arguing that words are strong and can be used as political weapons, as they have been in post World War II politics. He charts the beginning of the 'moment of the text' as 1968 (Hartley 2002). This seems to have affected the whole of society as people now talk to each other less, preferring to e-mail or send text or picture messages. McLuhan has commented on discourse and text. According to a website called 'Marshall McLuhan: spinning the web of the future', <accessed 13/12/03> 'specifically, McLuhan feels that the best way to convey information between two people is to maximize the use of the senses...[therefore] ancient oral civilizations appeared to have the greatest and most clear form of communication.' That is not the written word, but the spoken. This has, however, been criticised by Miller (1971) who 'disagrees with this assumption because he feels that humanity has evolved with technology and that this is not necessarily a bad thing. The reality is that further technological advances have given humanity the ability to communicate using mediums that are essentially extensions of the spoken word.' McLuhan expressed concern over the effects of technology and its result in the loss of human identity, although he did not see it as a bad thing, it was something to be maintained and supervised. His concerns could be justified, however, in that nowadays people talk to each other less, preferring to communicate by the written, or typed, word. ...read more.


'Texting' has become a common, everyday form of communication; one that did not exist during the lifetimes of Marshall McLuhan or Roland Barthes and it can be assumed that neither would have anticipated this surge in technology. Both would express concern at its immense popularity as it risks people becoming less sociable and having less actual conversation. Another side to that argument, however, could be that it increases human interaction, it just takes place in a different way. People can now contact their family, friends and acquaintances much easier and faster. To send a text message to say 'hello' is far quicker and easier than making a phone call which could result in lengthy conversation. Whereas once a person may have decided against the phone call for that reason they will now send a text message. It is probably safe to say that, given that human beings are an innately social species, and indulge in conversation for pleasurable as well as functional purposes that if what they desire is a conversation then that will be sought above a text message. It is hard to predict where society and culture will go with this ever increasing technological development. In the next year or so we can assume that videophone will become much more popular and that mobile phones will continue to develop into small computers than 'phones'. Living in a century where convenience is emphasised and encouraged and our lives are busier it is likely that less face to face interaction will take place however with the help of the mobile phone we can avoid losing contact altogether. 1,910 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Narrative section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Narrative essays

  1. &amp;quot;Argue either for or against. Teenagers owning mobile telephones are they a blessing or ...

    Mobile phones, computers and other such gadgets in the bedroom are seriously disrupting the sleeping patterns of a growing number of children, a study has found. Reading a book under the bedclothes with a torch has now been replaced by insidious distractions such as video games and mobile phones used for late-night text messages.

  2. Free essay

    On the year of Leah Bettss death, her mum and dad joined up with ...

    He now says that alcohol kills more people than drugs and yet alcohol is legal and drugs are not.

  1. Media Video Evaluation

    The dark room is included in the mise-en-scene meaning that it's visible within the frame. We used a dark room because it symbolises death, danger, and damage. This is related to the narration of the scene as the gangster is giving out a message of death, danger, and damage.

  2. Language investigation on two magazines, 'Top gear' and 'classic cars'

    The proper noun 'Clarkson' to the left of the page, in very simplistic writing gives makes it very formal and gives him a sense of authority, and a voice of authority make him much more powerful, this way setting him apart from the reader and can be quite intimidating.

  1. ICT AQA 2006-2008 Problem 1, Theme Park

    And titles are usually important as is this. The map did not need relocating as it was centred like I planned it to be. This also showed that the picture representing Land of Mysteries and Monsters Page did not also need adapting or editing.

  2. My use of ICT - Social (mobile phone)

    This is because I don't really like it that much. The avantages of it is that it writes texts quicker with less movement of fingers. However it doesn't have text talk words in the program, like "2moro" so therefore the text is longer and you can't fit so much in the text.

  1. The mass media has played a major role in structuring public perceptions of crime ...

    first question, I found that out of the people that read papers or watch news most of them are aware that the paper cant always be seen as a truthful source., but this doesn't stop them believing what they read and acting with this information in mind which can be seen in my later objectives.

  2. Evolution of 'new' media.

    There is also a noticeable difference between 'traditional' and 'new' media in that rather then flipping through pages of undesirable texts and articles, the reader of on-line news sites actively selects the articles that they wish to read by effortlessly clicking a mouse.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work