• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss The Various Roles of an MP in the House of Commons.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Hina Safdar Discuss The Various Roles of an MP in the House of Commons. In this essay I am going to look at four major roles played by an MP in the House of Commons. These are Law- Making, Scrutiny and Accountability, Representation and Government role as a minister. I am going to discuss whether MP's are effective within their roles and what their main constraints and limitations are. Law- Making involves three elements, Legitimation, Scrutinizing and making your own legislation. Legitimation is where we elect officials to make laws and therefore they give consent on behalf of the people. However the government rarely has the majority. In 2001 the Labour party only received 41% of the vote, where as the Conservative party received 33% percent of the vote, which shows with the Labour government being in power not everyone is represented, in fact on 41% of the people are represented. So it can be argued that the Labour Government today lacks legitimacy, as only 1 in 4 people voted for a Labour Government. Not everyone voted for certain MPs and most of the law passed comes from the government itself and cannot be changed by individual MPs because they are controlled by the Whip system. ...read more.

Middle

The amount of written questions is unlimited. The questions are effective because supplementary questions are able to test an MPs ability of a minister. It is also a really good way to get information. However the problems include that question times are nothing but a slanging match between MPs. Supplementary questions can usually be anticipated. Ministers don't actually have to answer the questions and anyway it's the civil servants that answer the question not the MPs themselves. Debates in the House of Commons can be done through many ways including, debates on white paper, green paper, ministerial statements, committee amendments, emergency debates and may more. The effectiveness of debates is that it can uncover major issues and publicise problems. It can urge the government to reconsider policy and also helps MPs further their career. However the problem's with debates is that they rarely change anything and is done at night time when most ministers are not present. Voting is another way that an MP can scrutinize the government as all government policy must be legitimised by the House of Commons, so Mps can actually reject government legislation. ...read more.

Conclusion

Mps can ask relevant ministers questions on behalf of the constituents. An Mp can introduce Private Members Bills to change law for a specific constituent. In committee work \MPs can amend legislation inline of what their constituents want. This can happen at all levels including voting, debating, amending, legislating, making legislation and bring the government to account through Prime Ministerial and Ministerial Question Time. MPs have to consider how they help their constituents because when the next general election takes place they will only vote for the MP if last time they were able to help them. Overall I feel that Mps are not very good at their roles in the House of Commons. There is too much work for them to do, so no work can be done effectively. There is never enough resources so work cannot be done effectively. There is too much pressure from the government so constituents cannot be repented fairly. The House of Commons should share its seats out among the party depending on how many people voted for the. For example if 25% of the people voted for Liberal Democrats then the Liberal Democrats should have 25% of the seats. This would mean it is fair and everyone in the UK is represented. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. What factors do Prime Ministers take into account when choosing their cabinets?

    Also in cabinet, if you consult all the members then you are likely to have an overall view of the whole of that party and possibly some other parties as well. Another reason why people may argue that this happens in the British system, could be because they feel that

  2. How effective are M.P.'s at scrutinising the Government?

    Select committee meetings and as a result their effectiveness as a scrutiny body is undermined. Tony Blair introduced the latest mechanism of scrutinising the government. It allows Blair to be questioned twice a year by a panel of Select committee chairmen called the liaison committee.

  1. Introduction and Company Background.

    Dongguan, the mainland China's major export-processing center and third largest exporting city (after Shenzhen and Shanghai), is located between Guangzhou and Shenzhen on the east side of the Pearl River. In the recent 20 years, it makes full use of its location advantage, which changed it from an agricultural county to an economically powerful city.

  2. The House of Commons

    select committees was hampered by the fact that the government refused access to a number of top civil servants who were actively engaged in the affair. In addition the committees are made up in accordance with each parties strength in the house of commons, which means that the governing party

  1. What are the roles of political parties and how effectively do they carry this ...

    Yet since Labour has become more capitalist they must compete for those donations and their income is falling as a result. Small parties have the most problems raising money and rely upon benefactors such as the Sean Connery donating money to the SNP.

  2. For my creative piece I have written a short story set in the future, ...

    Jim took the hint and followed his strange host in silence. As he followed, he noticed some unsettling features about this man. For a start, he was wearing a smart suit but had a robe draped over the top, perhaps to disguise his head and the fact that he was dressed smartly.

  1. To what extent does executive dominance over parliament prevent M.P.'s from carrying out their ...

    If the constituent's problem is unsatisfactorily answered from a minister the M.P. can report the matter to parliamentary ombudsman who will investigate the matter further. However many M.P.'s complain that they have insufficient resources given to them from the executive, thus undermining their role as redresser of grievances, as if

  2. One of the functions of the House of Commons is to effectively scrutinize the ...

    The amount of EDM's in the current years has revealed it popularity as being one of the most common forum for debate and scrutiny of the government. Emergency and Adjournment debates are also held on account of a question being put forward of national importance such as on issues of war etc.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work