• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To What Extent Is New Labour Really Old Conservative?

Extracts from this document...


To What Extent Is New Labour Really Old Conservative? There is ongoing debate over whether New Labour is really a Labour party with a new direction, or simply an old style Conservative Government. The fundamentals of this argument are whether or not New Labour has evolved into a free market left wing party, or whether it is still a democratic socialist party from the Right Wing. The difficulty in this debate is that there is much evidence for both sides of the coin. For instance, we have seen the increase in Government spending on the Welfare State under Tony Blair, which has provided more benefits to more people, something which goes against the beliefs of an Old Tory who would look to slim down the Welfare state due to their beliefs in freedom for the individual, and loosening of state intervention upon the public. However, Labour's positive attitude towards Public Private Partnerships to build new hospitals and schools, appears to be a direct descendant of the Conservative policy of Private Finance Initiative, and although they have different names, they represent the same idea of working with private companies/money to build services for the public, that private companies will then lease back to the Government for their use as schools and hospitals. ...read more.


The 'New Deal' was introduced in order to balance providing for the individual and encouraging the unemployed back into work. After people had been receiving unempoloyement benefit for a length of time, the government paid for that individual to receive training to do a particular job. However, these jobs tend to be low paid; yet if the positions weren't accepted, the individual lost their claim for benefit. These 'welfare to work' schemes are negatively looked upon by traditional Labour members and voters. This is because it adds limits on to what the government will support the individual, something that wouldn't have happened in an old Labour government. These schemes have more in common with left wing voters, who believe that there should be less dependency on the state. When the Conservative governments in the 70'sand 80's used PFI (Private Finance Initiatives) it was highly controversial and it was the Labour party themselves who came out and openly criticised the government for using private money to build schools and hospitals, that should be built using government money, and that health and education should not be in the hands of private organisations, the should be under the rule of the government. Labour promised to scrap the use of these initiatives 'if and when they came to power'. ...read more.


The Third Way is where middle ground is sought on matters. The definition of Third way politics is that it 'has a core concern for social justice, and promotes social inclusion and the fostering of an active civil society where community and state act in partnership' (Courtesy of LSE). However, critics of Third Way politics, simply say that the Third Way is only what the current government thinks a good thing. Believing in Crime reduction, justice and social inclusion, are all good things, things that most parties would agree on. Some would argue that the Third Way was conservative policy, simply dressed up with the PR - friendly image of New Labour. Yet, it seems increasingly like the New Labour Party has found ground that takes a left and right wing policies. In conclusion I would say that the lines between New Labour and Conservative thinking is rather blurred. The gap between the two has grown smaller every year. The New Labour party has quite obviously come to the middle ground, and in doing so has taken a conservative point of view in many policy decisions, however, this party is increasingly coming across like a left wing party than right, because they are alienating more and more members from the traditional Labour ranks. However, there is no danger of this party turning Conservative. Paul Whalley 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Politics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Politics essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    To what extent has New Labour abandoned traditional Labour values?

    4 star(s)

    Tony Blair introduced a compromise of Labour's Socialist and Tory's Capitalist ideologies and introduced the 'Third Way' and has implemented his ideology in the party's policies. This has caused a great confusion in the public opinion on what does the Labour Party really stand for.

  2. How significant is the influence which pressure groups have on government? Is there any ...

    (Grant, 1995, p74) It could be argued that New Labour's approach to pressure groups changed long before their re-election in 1997. During the period between their comprehensive defeat in 1979 and their re-election in 1997, it was recognised that the party had to dramatically adapt if it was ever to dream of returning to power.

  1. Is New Labour a Conservative Party?

    However, it is possible to distinguish numerous systems of belief on which this attitude and Conservative policies have been based. Conservatives have traditionally believed that politics are about enabling people to become what they want to be and reaching their full potential, Conservatives also welcome balance and harmony in society.

  2. The position of the New Labour government with Tony Blair ahead of that government.

    Finally, this difference is the view of freedom. Whereas Classical Liberalism believes in self-help and is focused on the needs of the individual, accepting limited state action, Progressive Liberalism accepts more state action and is focused on what the state could do to help the individual. ii) Conservatism believes in "preserving what is thought best in traditional society and opposes radical change" (Budge, 1998, p.398).

  1. "Tony Blair has been criticised by some for being a Tory Prime Minister leading ...

    And finally, Thatcher reduced and in some cases withdrew subsidies to many industries, compelling the closure of many concerns and the more efficient operation of the rest in the face of international competition. All of these economic changes made by Margaret Thatcher were extremely right wing with very capitalist values.

  2. How successful were the Labour governments of 1924 and of 1929-31?

    MacDonald was furthermore a strong supporter of the League of Nations and he spoke at the assembly. He also sought to negotiate the Geneva Protocol in order to strengthen the pledges of collective security amongst the European powers. However on the negative side, there was the problem with the leading ministers, and these can include MacDonald.

  1. Analyse the transition from 'Old' Labour to 'New' Labour.

    upon the basis of the common ownership of the means of production the best attainment system of popular administration & control of each industry or service.' Further revolutionary ideas included the introduction of what we now know as the 'Welfare State'.

  2. What are the main policy areas that divide the Labour and Conservative Parties?

    The Labour party seemed to support the idea of giving Gibraltar to Spain, whereas the Tories were keen to keep her British. On the issue of taxation in 2001, the differences lay in the level of basic rate; Tories aiming to reduce it to at least 20%, Labour extending a 10% tax band at low income levels.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work