• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine and comment on the attitudes of Roman Catholic and Anglican churches to Homosexuality.

Extracts from this document...


"Examine and comment on the attitudes of Roman Catholic and Anglican churches to Homosexuality." The context of sexual ethics today deals within a western culture the increase of sexually based crimes, higher levels of HIV and AIDS along with a rising teenage pregnancy rate. There are many differing opinions on the reason for such an increase in negative forms of sexual related issues including the opinion held by some that a loss of respect for Christian morals and teachings is responsible for the current acceptable sexually promiscuous culture. However this view is met with the argument that certain Christian values prevent people from fully exploring their sexuality. I am approaching the issue of sexual ethics with the focus on homosexuality and the attitudes presented from the Roman Catholic and Anglican churches. Within Christianity there is a mix of opinion that threatens to divide an already split religion further apart concerning the acceptability of Homosexuality. Homosexuality is where two members of the same sex develop a deep sense of physical attraction to one another. This can lead to a relationship of love between the pair forming which may or may not include sex. However Homosexuality has always faced problems, as many people believe it to be immoral and completely unnatural. Some people class it as a crime, which has lead to restrictions being placed upon the consenting age of practising homosexuals. There have been numerous tales of persecution against homosexuals ranging from verbal and physical abuse including one of the most well known forms of persecuted attacks, which involved the nail bombing of a Gay bar in London's Soho district in 1999. So members of the Homosexual community are used to being persecuted for their sexuality especially from strongly religious members of the world who believe that homosexuals degrade society with their fake, unnecessary and unnatural sexuality. There have been many cases in which homosexual persecution has gone so far as to try and reverse a person's homosexual nature through extreme medical and physiological assessment stating that the grounds for doing this are an attempt to "cure" a person from their homosexual nature. ...read more.


So in this instance a religion that claims to be "all loving" has demonstrated that in some circumstances how ever tolerant a religion appears to be there will always be a certain amount of persecution against Homosexuals. Recently in the news their have been new issues raised following the allowance of civil partnerships concerning the law that should homosexual couples be allowed to adopt. This has been met with uproar from the Catholic church who have stated that if this law is passed they will refuse to help gay couples adopt and even go as far as to close down Catholic based adoption agencies. So despite claiming to be a fully tolerant, respectful and all loving religion the Catholic Church seems to show that their opinion towards homosexuality is in some cases excusable from this as it goes against the laws of God. Personally I comprehend the reasons for the Catholics holding the views that they do, especially as they have such a strong amount of evidence stemming both from scripture and Natural Moral Law which only strengthens there case that homosexuality has no place within the church. However I am inclined to believe that the Catholics have overlooked the teachings from Jesus that state "love one another as I have loved you" and "love thy neighbour". Although those teachings where never specifically linked by Jesus to the issue of homosexuality they where meant to be followed by all and applied to every person and in my opinion the Catholics constant deontological standpoint regarding homosexuality means that they sometimes overlook the basic teachings of Jesus, which to me are more important fundamentally than the scriptures laid down based upon a culture from 2000 years ago. However its very clear those in the 21st century western culture homosexuals are being accepted and regarded as just normal people who love one another. It is now possible for openly homosexual couples to legally engage in a relationship involving a sexual nature as well as receive a civil partnership. ...read more.


Overall I believe that both the Anglican and the Roman Catholic Church have valid arguments I find it very hard to accept aspects of both. Personally I like and respect the fact that the Catholics make their views very clear and never differ from where they stand as it makes things very easy to understand whereas the Anglican Church has no fix standpoint which therefore makes it very difficult to follow what exactly they believe concerning homosexuality. However I believe that the fact that the Anglican Church in parts approaches the issue in a way that allows for all viewpoints to be taken into account is a much more effective way of approaching it as it allows for a variety of opinions to be openly shown. Personally my view is to err on the side of compassion regarding the issue as although I recognise that certain aspects of the scripture make it clear that homosexuality has no place within Christianity I still believe more in the gospel presentation of a all loving and compassionate Jesus. Jesus was presented to us as being loving and tolerant of all, willing to accept everyone even if they did wrong. The only point where Jesus is presented to be intolerant towards others is when confronted with extremely judgemental people, which could infer that despite the Catholics maintained and respected standpoint regarding homosexuality they are possibly being too judgmental. Because Jesus made it clear that the most important thing to do is to "love one another as I have loved you" I believe that homosexual people must certainly be accepted and treated with respect. Whether that means that the Christian community regardless of denomination must accept this to remains to be seen, but it seems to me that if they wish to remain a vital part of the current society they may have to make compromises on certain issues for example the current debate on allowing homosexual couples able to adopt children. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Places of Worship section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Places of Worship essays

  1. Marriage - Explain how the rituals and vows connected with Christian marriage might influence ...

    It is seen as a sign of God's forgiveness and willingness to give people a new start. Other Churches see marriage as a contract or covenant, which should not be broken but can be and they believe provision should be made for such cases.

  2. Describe the disadvantages that black Americans faced in the early ...

    They also brought wealth. Calvin's character is a factor, which is due to his success in Geneva. His most important work involved the organization of church governance and the social organization of the church and the city. He was, in fact, the first major political thinker to model social organization entirely on biblical principles.

  1. Explore the presentation of the theme of religion in "Angela's Ashes"

    This quote is an example of blackmail because it gives the woman a choice, represented by the word "or", yet the choice to defy her husband may lead the woman to face consequences far worse than obeying him. This is an example of religion being used as a tool by which people could be controlled in society.

  2. Team Nicaragua Journal, July 7-18, 2005

    We also gave gifts to him and his family, which were denim jeans, women's magazines, and the Incredibles DVD. The rooms we stayed in were very interesting. There were separate cabin-type buildings for every two rooms, and we all went into separate rooms with two to a room.

  1. A study of the attitudes of the Roman Catholic, Methodist and Anglican churches to ...

    gave up natural relations with women' (Romans 1:27) However despite the above quotes that condemn homosexuality; it is not clear whether the sin of Sodom was homosexuality or inhospitality. The Hebrew verb 'yada' - 'to know'- may allure to sexual knowledge, but could simply mean 'to become familiar' the bibles translation from Hebrew to English can have misinterpretations.

  2. The Churches struggle against apartheid and a comment on the effectiveness of this Challenge.

    The Native affairs department of the earlier segregationist period was more passive than its successor, The Bantu Affairs Department. The Bantu Affairs Department played a far more direct role and was remembered for its authoritarian control over the daily lives of the African people6.

  1. In what ways did the Roman Catholic Church confront the threat of Protestantism?

    The teachings of 'scriptura sola' (scripture alone) was rejected and the Catholics claimed that other sources had communicated God's message. 'This truth and way of living are contained in written books and unwritten traditions, which were received by the Apostles from the mouth of Christ himself'.

  2. Why was the Catholic Church so weak by 1780?

    could not be logically and empirically explained like Catholicism and its blind faith in an illogical God. The influence of enlightenment and rationalist writers was also helped by the increase in literacy rates in this period. The churches monopoly over social life and culture was declining, demonstrated by the declining

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work