• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How Capital Punishment Affirms Life

Extracts from this document...


Gary Hammontree ENG 104 M. Williams Argument Analysis 11/15/2004 Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life Mr. Koch's essay in defense of capital punishment starts with the statements made by two death row inmates at the time of their executions. Both men made statements that killing is wrong and that in turn, the state is wrong in putting them to death. These men were convicted of murdering and or raping at least six people. Mr. Koch expresses that life is indeed precious and that if the death penalty were a perceived possibility in the minds of these men it might have acted as a deterrent. That sentiment may or not be true. In our past, there were more capital offenses on the books. Rape was at one time a capital offense. Rape a woman and die. Oddly, there was a significantly lower incidence of rape forty or fifty years ago. The random snatching, assault, rape, and or murder of a woman were an isolated event, something that we did not hear of on a daily basis. ...read more.


2. No other democracy uses the death penalty. Simply put Mayor Koch points out that no other democracy has anywhere near the incidence of violent crime and murder rates that the United States possesses. There are more murders in Los Angeles in one year that some countries experience in a single year. If other countries had the equal rate of murders, the outcry for capital punishment would be as loud as or louder than it is here. 3. An innocent person might be executed by mistake. Mayor Koch's position here is that although there is the remote possibility that such an event could occur, the likelihood is infinitely small and that we should not toss aside this form of punishment and deterrent, such as it is, because the penalty and deterrent is the only defense that we have to stem the epidemic violence. 4. Capital punishment cheapens the value of human life. Mayor Koch's answer to this argument is simply that the severity of the punishment in fact affirms the value of life in that such a severe penalty is extracted. ...read more.


As Mayor Koch says in conclusion, the death of anyone - even a convicted killer diminishes us all. However, even worse would be a nation that allows the crime of murder to go unpunished. There are consequences for everything we do in life. There should certainly be consequences for the criminal taking of a life and they should be severe, otherwise there is no consequence and certainly no deterrent. Mayor Koch uses a fallacious argument in defending capital punishment as necessary after condemning killing in general. He attempts to make the case that killing as punishment is valid while killing because of a crime, or in a fit or anger, or even as a pastime, is wrong. There is an argument to be made for capital punishment, but we should, at the same time be prepared to admit that killing is in the final analysis wrong. As a punishment, the death penalty may be needed in today's world, but we should still accept that it is at best unavoidable and is still wrong in and of itself. 1 Hammontree ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Capital Punishment section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Capital Punishment essays

  1. Capital punishment is barbaric and inhumane.

    This stops serious criminals from re-offending and harming anybody else. The destruction of human life is a violation of natural law. The great Australian jurist, Sir Owen Dixon (Syme, 1997, p.3), stated, "Many of them are mentally quite able to appreciate what they are doing and quite able to appreciate

  2. “Billy Budd” - A Critical Analysis of Symbolism

    Captain Vere as well as the crew all acknowledge that Billy acted without malice, forethought, or any murderous intent, but Billy was guilty of striking a superior officer. Captain Vere was present when Claggart was killed, witnessing everything. Melville shows the reader through this that the Captain really cares about

  1. Capital Punishment

    Also, it must be remembered that animals are real people too, who have a life and with it the capacity to feel pain, fear and the loss of their loved ones and all the other emotions that the rest of us are capable of feeling.

  2. Examine at least 2 reasons for believing in life after death

    never dies and unlike the body carries on living. The type of soul's afterlife also depends on one's belief in God and in following his rules. This too falls under the same criticism, simply because majority of religious writings are viewed as mythical and it is hard to prove in what they state to be true.

  1. Capital Punishment: An injustice or a necessity?

    despite the number of murders and other serious crimes within prison, this issue can be dealt easily by removing the dangerous inmates to solitary confinement. Also there statistics which suggest that countries which have the death penalty do not have lower rates of violent crime than those which do got, which calls into question its effectiveness as a deterrent.

  2. Capital Punishment, is it an effective or ineffective deterrent?

    Josie Russell for example would have probably died of her injuries if it had happened 30 years ago. But then there is the argument for the abolishment of the death penalty. The most frighteningly important one is the fact that genuinely innocent people have and could be executed and that

  1. Capital Punishment is no longer practised in our society. Explain what differing Christian ...

    justice can put up a strong argument for that using the bible as an example. The principle of retribution is a key point when fighting this argument. A known bible verse backs up the idea of retribution; the verse is from Matthew 5v38.

  2. Capital punishment as a deterrent of capital crimes in America

    be punished for his misdeeds, nor used as an example or a warning; he is to be killed for the protection of others, like the wolf that escaped not long ago in a Connecticut suburb" (Barzun 155). This is illustrative of Gottlieb's second possible function of punishment.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work