• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Genetic Engineering has been regarded 'as a major breakthrough in the fight against disease' and will allow 'increased food production'. However, some people believe that scientists are in danger of 'creating a monster and should not meddle with nature'.

Extracts from this document...


Jennifer James 12SM 'Genetic Engineering has been regarded 'as a major breakthrough in the fight against disease' and will allow 'increased food production'. However, some people believe that scientists are in danger of 'creating a monster and should not meddle with nature'. Genetic engineering is a new science. It has the potential to be used for good or bad, to change the planet irreversibly. The state of scientific knowledge in this area is growing day by day. This is the beginning of what must be an ongoing debate, if the public is to have confidence in the moral, ethical, scientific and commercial decisions that are taken with regard to genetic engineering. Moral values of a certain topic can vary between different people, and often leads to conflict. This has happened in the Genetically Modified (GM) foods debate. The definition of Genetically Modified foods from the EC novel foods regulation is "a food which is, or which is made from, a genetically modified organism... containing genetic material or protein resulting from the modification". "Ethical decisions involve weighing up risks against the benefits". The morals of an individual rely on their "feeling rather than facts" of a situation. ...read more.


Dr. Francis H. C. Crick, winner of the Nobel Prize in 1962 states "Humans probably will not be improved or altered by genetic manipulation in the future; education and environment are more important than genetics". Religious groups feel very strongly about GM foods. They want nature to run without human interference and also the feeling that you "shouldn't mess with what God designed, humans aren't the creator". For example, Hindus treat cows as sacred and to Jews and Muslims pigs are considered un-clean, so they would be unable to consume products from these organisms. There are two extreme views about GM crops. The positive view taken by the government and the GM companies, and the stronger negative view held by the media, the public and environmental awareness companies. The newspapers can now 'name and shame' test sites of GM crops. This could lead Greenpeace activists to destroy the sites like on 26th July 1999 when 28 people made a dawn raid on a 28-acre crop. Media can be partly to blame for the hype surrounding GM crops. This is because ethics rather than facts are emphasised as main points in many articles. ...read more.


I shall finish with a quote from Jack B. Bresler "Is the human body a sacred vessel of man's soul and spirit, or is he merely at that position in biological evolution to know that he is a part of evolution and can do something about his own future evolution?" Word Count 1, 083 words Biography * Keeping the balance; policies on genetic modification- Liberal Democrats * Tomorrow's Biodiversity- Vandana Shiva * Biopiracy: the plunder of nature and knowledge- Vandana Shiva * Genetically engineered organisms: benefits and risks- J.R.S. Fincham and J.R. Ravetz * Animal biotechnology and ethics- edited by Alan Holland and Andrew Johnson * Genetic revolution and human rights- Justine Burley * Ethics in biotechnology www.gre.ac.uk/ws02/GM_Gmfoods/ethnic.html * A Mirror newspaper headline adapted from 'Ethics in biotechnology'. www.gre.ac.uk/~ws02/GM_foods/ethnic.hmtl * Andrew Parker BBC online- GM foods, what people think, 8th October 1999. www.bbc.co.uk * 'GM food protests' Thursday September 21st 2000 - The Guardian newspaper. * 'Health implications of genetically modified foods' - Professor Liam Donaldson and Sir Robert May, May 1999 * 'A new introduction to biology' AQA - Bill Indge, Martin Rowland, Margaret Baker. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Variation and Inheritance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Variation and Inheritance essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Research in Genetic Engineering Should Be Halted. Discuss

    3 star(s)

    The information acquired through genetic screening may cause insurance companies not to offer life or health insurance coverage to people who have a chance of getting a certain disease, even though a portion of these people will never actually contract the disease.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Cloning. Should it be banned? I will explain all the different types of cloning ...

    - found at http://www.ncccusa.org/news/humancloningresolution.html. This shows that currently in some states of the USA it is legal to perform human reproductive cloning as long as it is privately funded for, however is currently illegal to perform using federal funding. Reported experiments Currently there is a shortage of reported experiments with

  1. The Ethics of Genetic Engineering

    These companies expect the farmers to ignore traditional methods of farming and to buy new seeds every year from the GM seeds suppliers at inflated prices, instead of reusing seeds from the previous years.

  2. Genetic Engineering, Friend or Foe?

    * Better texture, flavour and nutritional value. * Longer shelf life, easier shipment. * Better yield, more efficient use of land. * Less herbicides and other chemicals. * Essential if we are to feed the world. The Economic and Employment Case * Opportunities for British innovation to benefit the people of Britain.

  1. Ethics in the world of Genetic Engineering

    But despite the introduction of laws, many people are still unhappy, and are pushing for further action. For example the CIWF believe GM meat should be clearly labelled, although they also say it should not be sold in the first place.

  2. Pressure groups are important in the debate about Genetic modification. How would you define ...

    Another way in which Pressure groups promote their interests is by gathering and using high valued information as a resource for specialist knowledge thus using this to their advantage against opposing parties and decision makers .An example of this is , MIND and MENCAP , which are groups campaigning on behalf of people with mental disabilities and learning difficulties.

  1. Food Policy at a Crossroads, A World of Plenty or a World of Famine ...

    Furthermore, as we become more skillful with the technology, we will be able to produce plants that deliver more than just the above benefits. For example, plants that will produce plastics, industrial chemicals, and even vaccines to counteract many diseases throughout the world.

  2. Cloning Human Beings Is Not Ethical.

    Are we willing to agree in part to follow the road of scientific progress to the dehumanized hell of the future? This future could very well hold many genetically perfect humans, making us as real humans stand out as failures in need of refinement or replacement. What a scary thought!

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work