• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Internal Assessment: Camp David and Oslo Accords

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Which peace process was more effective in attempting to resolve the Palestinian-Israeli conflict: the 1993 Oslo Accords or the Middle East Peace Summit at Camp David in 2000? Libby Liang Kiana Yau Word Count: 1999 History Internal Assessment International Baccalaureate Programme Sir Winston Churchill Secondary School Mr. R. Picard May 2011 Table of Contents Section A: Plan of Investigation .............................................................. Page 1 Section B: Summary of Evidence ............................................................ Page 2 Section C: Evaluation of Sources ............................................................. Page 6 Section D: Analysis .............................................................................. Page 8 Section E: Conclusion ...........................................................................Page 11 Bibliography ...................................................................................... Page 12 Section A: Plan of Investigation This investigation seeks to determine which peace talk was more effective in attempting to resolve the Palestinian-Israel conflict: the 1993 Oslo Accords or the Middle East Peace Summit at Camp David in 2000. To complete this investigation, related primary sources, secondary historian accounts, and biographies from a variety of perspectives will be analyzed and their different views regarding the issue will be focused upon. While a variety of sources will be analyzed, two of the primary sources will be evaluated in depth for their origin, purpose, value, and limitation: The Oslo Declaration of Principles and The Trilateral Statement issued by the United States, Israel, and the Palestinians at the Camp David Summit. ...read more.

Middle

The purpose of this declaration is for Israel and the Palestinians to recognize their legitimacy and mutual rights of existence and to commit themselves to negotiating a permanent settlement to improve relations between the two parties. The value is that it provides candid insights into some of the important issues that were discussed, such as troop withdrawal, in the meeting between the two sides, and it also reflects the perspectives of the people, such as Rabin and Arafat, involved in the negotiation. The limitations of this primary source include its vagueness in its proposal for negotiation. Instead of providing a definitive solution over some of key issues, such as the status of Jerusalem and the problem of Palestinian refugees, this document only serves as a framework for future peace talks due to its lack of details. Also, the document may not reflect the real discussion during the Oslo process, since it is a declaration released to the public. Source 2: The Trilateral Statement issued by the United States, Israel, and the Palestinians on the Camp David Summit, July 25, 2000 The Trilateral statement is a primary document issued cooperatively by the United States, the Israelis, and the Palestinians on July 25th, 2000, the last day of the Camp David Summit. ...read more.

Conclusion

His argument was strong in focusing on the overall influence of the Oslo Accord while considering other historical views as well. Overall what was realized is that the Oslo Accord was a negotiation primarily between the two parties with little external pressure (such as the US), and it was a breakthrough in trying to resolve the conflict on both diplomatic and economic levels. There was the consideration of dealing with the political opposition between the two sides and the social and economic stability of both peoples. Ben-Dor's argument was strong and reliable in helping to answer our investigation. Section E: Conclusion While both the Oslo Accords and Camp David had the same objective of promoting peace and reaching a non-temporary agreement, they produced different outcomes that had huge impacts on the Palestinian-Israeli relations. The Oslo Accord was significant in trying to reach an agreement between the Palestinians and Israel from both political and economic aspects. It had the aim of promoting peace between the two authorities and achieving stability for the civilians. Conversely, the urgency and desperation in Camp David contributed to its fatal flaw of struggling to reach a final agreement between the Palestinians and the Israelis, leaving many key issues, such as Jerusalem, to be unresolved. While the Oslo Accord provided an opportunity to thaw the tension between the two sides, Camp David lead to nowhere but escalation of violence. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our International Baccalaureate History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related International Baccalaureate History essays

  1. History internal Assessment (The subsidiary role of women in Nazi society)

    success of Nazi policy by its supporters.15 > The effects Although rate of birth increased, it is not clear if it was due to German policy, not to the end of German Depression or correction of living standards. In 1938 the number of employed women leveled off and then revived again in war.

  2. Schlieffen Plan - analysis of the sources

    The website is established by John Simkin and was created in 1997; however the date of the publication of the Schlieffen Plan article is not stated.

  1. Internal Assessment - How effective were the policies implemented by the U.S. during the ...

    * MacArthur implemented un-democratic means from any political charge being imposed on Emperor Hirohito, such as threatening of General Tojo to change his testimonial. (Coates) * The U.S. introduced a universal suffrage to Japan, guaranteeing human rights. (Hanneman) * "A Tokyo stage show in which one of the cast sang 'how can we have democracy with two emperors?'

  2. Israeli- Palestinian Conflict. I chose this topic due to my personal connection with ...

    Israel has built nearly 250 illegal settlements on the Palestinian territory, which has caused a huge refugee crisis in the Middle East. Currently, there are 7 million Palestinian refugees and 1.5 million Palestinian Israelis live under race-based Apartheid law4. Over 25,000 Palestinian homes have been demolished since 1967, mostly due to the illegal settlements Israel has built.

  1. Favorable external and internal circumstances, not Bismarcks diplomatic genius, explain the unification of Germany ...

    The Growth of Nationalism The growth of German nationalism throughout the beginning of the 19th century also played a crucial role in the formation of a unified Germany. The Zollverein may have laid the foundations for a possible unification, but the widespread feeling of nationalism among the middleclass liberals made it a realistic event.

  2. Extended Essay - The Role of a UN-Secretary General to Achieve World Peace: The ...

    Furthermore, a U-2 American pilot had been reported to be missing after being attacked over Cuba.[29] In fact, Castro even appeared to be forcing the Russians to commence a nuclear invasion against the US.[30] Due to the rising tension, U Thant decided to make an immediate trip to Havana to consult with Castro himself.

  1. Executive Dysfunction: Franklin Delano Roosevelts Health and Effectiveness in His Final Term of Presidency

    Upon reviewing the medical observations and reports from Drs. McIntire and Bruenn, who oversaw his medical illnesses, it is apparent that Roosevelt was not interested in knowing the nature of his conditions (Bruenn, 1970; McIntire, 1946). Contrastingly, FDR faced his polio and paralysis with tireless inquiry, questioning the experts treating him regarding the nature of his illness, the prognosis, and many minute details of his treatment (Ferrell, 1992).

  2. British role in the establishment of The State of Israel

    More Arab violence managed to harvest a second White Paper of 1939 which prepared concessions to the Arabs on a varied range of concerns. The British not only announced serious restrictions on Jewish immigration (a total of 75,000 to be allowed over the next five years)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work