• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the key features of the academic fields Industrial Relations and Human Resource Management

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the key features of the academic fields "Industrial Relations" and "Human Resource Management By Kaixin Ding IHRM&CIR 08/10/2011 Contents Introduction ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 Industrial Relations---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 Human Resource Management ------------------------------------------------------------------2 Comparative and Contrast ------------------------------------------------------------------------ 2 Conclusion -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 3 References -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 4 Introduction Industrial relations became a field of academic research since the end of eighteenth century in UK. With the development of discipline differentiation in nineteen century, the definitions of each academic area become more detailed and each subject are deeper discussed. In the earlier twentieth century, a subdivision focus on labour management of the industrial relations called personal administration was centred on the goal of employee and a variety of actions aimed at maintaining, inspiring, and developing the labour force. This subprime subject tended to regard workers as means to achieve the industrialists' purposes and paid attention on the relationship between employee and employer. In 1960s, human resource management first appeared to be a separate field from industrial relations although it was not taken seriously. Nowadays industrial relations and human resource management are definitely different and both very important academic fields in human labour. Although the situation of the two subjects may be upside down compared with before that there are some critics argue that the academic industrial relations is better described as human resource management, these arguments may not be all right. ...read more.


In 1964, Myers et al changed the name of their textbook into "Management of Human Resources: Readings in Personnel Administration". Mondy and Noe (1990) consider human resource management as to achieve the organization's goal by using the organization's labour force. They point out that there are six functions in human resource management: Recruitment, Human resource development, Security and Hygiene, Compensation and welfare, employer relationship, and human resource research. In conclusion, human resource management is the management of all the activities aimed at attracting, developing, encouraging and maintaining the high performance in the organization. Compare and contrast There are many common points between human resource management and industrial relations. Based on the Kaufman's research (2001), they focus on the employment and workplace issues, care about the relationship between employer and employee and expect the organization to operate more smoothly. Government policy has a great influence on both of them, and they must adjust themselves according to the policy adjustment. These two fields' research theories are based on the essence of human beings. Scholars cannot ignore the motivation, perception and emotion when they establish the structure of these academic fields. What's more, they are both seeking positive-sum solutions to labor problems. ...read more.


The HR and IR fields are still distinguished nowadays, however, by numerous differences in their approach to research and practice. If the name "industrial relations" no longer works, scholars need to find another term and then rebuild cross-disciplinary dialogue and supporting institutions so the field once again can claim jurisdiction to be the study of "all aspects of work"(Kaufman). Reference Clarke, Linda and Donnelly, Eddy and Hyman, Richard and Kelly, John and McKay, Sonia and Moore, Sian, 2008. 'What's the point of industrial relations?' British Universities Industrial Relations Association Conference, 2008,June 26-28 Kaufman, B.E., 2001. 'Human resources and industrial relations: Commonalities and differences'. Human Resource Management Review, Volume 11, Issue 4, 2001, 339-374 Storey, J.(2007), 'HRM today: an assessment', in Storey,J.(ed), HRM: a critical text(3rd edition), Thomson, Ch.1 Ackers, P., and Wilkinson, A., 2003. Understanding Work and Employment. Oxford: Oxford University Press Colling, T., and Terry, M., 2010. 'Work, the employment relationship and the field of Industrial Relations', in Colling, T., and Terry, M.(eds), Industrial Relations: theory and practice(3rd edition), Chichester: Wiley Hyman,R., 1975. A Marxist Introduction to Industrial Relations. Basingstoke: MacMillan Bach,S.(2005), 'Personnel Management in Transition', in Bach, S., Managing Human Resources(4th edition), Blackwell Publishing ?? ?? ?? ?? 4 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. Critically compare and contrast 'hard' and 'soft' models of human resource management.

    The management's principal reason for improving HRM within the organisation is to simply increase productivity. Within the hard model the organisations needs come before those of the employee. A study carried out by Heery (1997) examining the compatibility of industrial relations and performance related pay found it to be an increasingly adopted practice.

  2. Human resource management in Carrefour

    6.Evaluation the effectiveness of the Personnel Department The evaluation of the Personnel Department is an overall quality control check on human resources activities in a division or company and on how those activities support the organisation strategy. Several benefits result from a human resource audit: Identifies the contributions of the

  1. External and Internal environment factors in Industrial Relations

    (Likert, 1961) Political "Politics", in this sense, is a concept that can be defined as "A process involving the exercise of control, constraint and coercion in society". (Michael Salamon, 2000) According to Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak, "economic downturn influence on our exports and industrial output, at the same time

  2. Expatriation and Repatriation Issues in International Human Resource Management

    Also, the HR managers from STS argue that the lacks of resources such as budgets and do not have suitable people to handle the training are the reasons why the organization cannot offer a program to meet expatriates' needs (Tran & Wong, 2006).

  1. Human Resource Management: Development, Activities, Planning and Recruitment

    Collection and analysis of data; monitoring targets for the whole organisation. Providing information to managers. Conducting exit interviews and analysing reasons for leaving. Provision of contracts- Provide written statement of particulars for new employees and issue them to these employees, having checked that the detail is correct.

  2. Personal, Academic and Career Effectiveness. Business and Human Resource Management. Personal, Academic and ...

    In the end of my reflection I will critically analyse my improvement in the three skills chosen so that I can see how effective the whole process has been in terms of preparing for my academic success as well as future career.

  1. Free essay

    Employee Relations, Trade Union Recognition

    They argue this monopoly on labour has the same negative effects as any other monopoly. 4. Trade Union recognition at Vertex Vertex was created in 1996 as a subsidiary when North West Water and North West Electricity (NORWEB)

  2. Human resource management - Microsoft problems and recommendatins

    It is a complex and specialized activity and entails both pay and benefits. The aim of compensation is to allow the organisation to establish and maintain a competent workforce at an affordable cost. Challenges to be faced: 1. Compensation system may demoralise the team which has not performed well or has not reached the target.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work