• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Place-Name Evidence for the Coexistence of Viking Settlers and other Groups in Derbyshire

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Place-Name Evidence for the Coexistence of Viking Settlers and other Groups in Derbyshire The analysis of place-names in Derbyshire can provide useful insight into the contact between the Viking settlers colonising the Danelaw and the native Anglo-Saxons. The Danes also encountered many other native groups on their way to the Danelaw and suggestions about the interaction between these various groups can also be made from place-name evidence. In this essay, the popular depiction of the Vikings raiding villages and forcing the natives to flee will be questioned and will instead attempt to demonstrate a state of coexistence between the various groups who inhabited the Danelaw. According to Hockett (1987: 43), when two different native groups come into contact, they are able to understand each other and communicate through the process of a 'switching-code', where speakers substitute sounds and elements with equivalent ones from their own dialect. Many place-names in Derbyshire demonstrate this Scandinavian adaptation of Anglo-Saxon place-names and provide an indication of the ability of the Scandinavians to comprehend Old English (OE) speech and names. Scandinavian cognate substitution appears to be evident in many place-names in Derbyshire. For example, the pre-Scandinavian form of Hazelbadge is Haselbech(e) (1251), while its post-Scandinavian form is Heselbache (1367) (Townend, 2002: 77). This provides evidence of the OE word h�sel, meaning 'hazel tree', being replaced by Old Norse (ON) helsi. Similar cognate replacement is seen in Milton, which was recorded as Middeltune (Domesday Book, 1086, cited in Cameron, 1958: 104). The first element appears to be from OE middel, meaning 'middle'. ...read more.

Middle

These examples of phonemic correspondences suggest that the Scandinavians avoided changing the semantic content of Anglo-Saxon place-names and instead resorted to less drastic methods of change that would enhance their understanding and pronunciation of them. This provides further evidence of the degree of intelligibility between the two groups as the Scandinavians seemed to analyse the original Anglo-Saxon names in terms of their semantics and phonology in order to come up with corresponding forms that Norse speakers could understand. This is supported by Milliken and Milliken (1988: 1), cited in Townend (2002: 45), who suggest that 'the degree of intelligibility between any two dialects correlates with the system of phonological correspondences that exists between cognate lexical items in those dialects'. However, this sensitivity to Anglo-Saxon place-names by the Scandinavians is only true to a limited extent, as illustrated by Grimston hybrids, where a Scandinavian personal name is followed by the generic OE element tun, meaning 'settlement'. These places represent early English villages, as evidenced from the fact that in Derbyshire, the majority of them are situated on high-quality agricultural land, 'north of the River Trent and to the west of the River Derwent' (Cameron, 1958: 92). The idealness of this area for settlement and cultivation suggests that it was likely to have been inhabited first. This is supported by Fellows-Jensen (1978: 368), who suggests that the 'the majority of the hybrid and scandinavianised names are borne by English vills whose names were partly altered by the invading Scandinavians.' Thus, the name of the new Scandinavian owner replaced the original Anglo-Saxon name in the initial element of a place-name. ...read more.

Conclusion

The elements in the OE form are neither cognate nor phonetically similar to the modern Scandinavianised form. This would suggest that in certain areas of Derbyshire, there was in fact little contact and intelligibility between the English and Scandinavians. However, this might have been because Derby held a major military base for the Danish army, so to assert its significance, the Danes changed its name to make it wholly Scandinavian. This OE form of Derby contradicts Fellows-Jensen (1972: 119), who suggests that 'Where a cognate OE word exists... it is reasonable to assume that it was this word the Scandinavian element replaced and not some entirely unrelated word'. Thus, although the phenomenon of changing place-names with elements unrelated to its original form is rare, it is certainly apparent, and might indeed have been more common in Derbyshire if more pre-Conquest forms of place-names were available. However, due to the scarcity of pre-Conquest documents in the North, the majority of names survive only in their Scandinavianised forms (Townend, 2002: 53). Place-name evidence has been significant in providing information about the interaction between the various native groups that settled in Derbyshire. It would seem plausible with the possible exceptions of Grimston hybrid names and Derby, that the Danes generally did not attempt to completely alter the semantics of English place-names but merely made them more congruent with their own forms of speech, using corresponding phonemes and cognates. A peaceful coexistence is generally demonstrated between the Danes and Anglo-Saxons, as well as the other groups encountered by the Danes, such as Irishmen, Norwegians and travelers from the north-west of England, who accompanied them to the Danelaw. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Medieval History section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Medieval History essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    T o what extent does the Demographic Transition Model provide a reliable and accurate ...

    4 star(s)

    They suggested that fertility trends followed real wage trends, although with a lag of roughly 40 years, throughout the period and conclude that the demographic expansion of the late eighteenth century was not a revolution, but fitted a long-standing pattern of English demographic history.

  2. To what extent did witchcraft accusations reflect socio-economic tensions in early modern British communities?

    'The phenomenon is paralleled by an increase in the involvement of female deponents in all cases before the assizes ...after the restoration the proportion had more than doubled'.11 The idea of a religious reflection on the reasoning behind witchcraft accusations is also integral to the argument against socio-economic tensions because

  1. A Critical Analysis of the Sack of Limoges (1370) according to Jean Froissart

    else"'.23 The use of the rather blasphemous 'By God' signals that it was simply unthinkable for a noble to murder or mistreat a fellow noble, despite the differences between them and the fact that they were fighting against each other.

  2. Comparing and Contrasting Anglo-Saxon, Medieval, and Renaissance periods - Analysis of Early Civilizations Through ...

    When the anonymous author tells, "...He/ And all his glorious band of Geats/ Thanked God that their leader had come back unharmed" (lines 597-599), he or she is referring to the universal devotion expressed by the public to their gold-lord, king of tribe, earl or other ruling presence.

  1. historical review of Else Roesdahl's The Vikings

    The importance of this type of source analysis is made abundantly clear in the excavation of Vorbasse. Here Roesdahl goes into great detail explaining how the village evolved over the years and how our knowledge of all of this is made possible through archaeological excavations.

  2. How did the martyr's body become an emblem of triumph for early Christian communities

    In this sense the body of the martyr became a symbol of complete and utter faith in Christ that would not wane no matter what threat was faced. When the martyrs were on trial the simple act of burning a piece of incense, pouring oil or oral dedication to the

  1. How accurate would it be to assert that by 1492 the Caribbean region was ...

    The worship of zemis or idols believed to control the forces of nature formed the basis of Arawak religion. The ?cacique? acting as high priest, presided over all religious ceremonies and belived in a heaven to which souls went after death.

  2. To what extent was the English Invasion of Irelandan accident, unforeseen and unplanned?

    Leinster and, therefore, Henry?s eventual invasion to claim Norman held territories was ?an accident unplanned, unforeseen?, as there was no warrant for an Anglo-Norman invasion as had been the case with William the Conqueror?s conquest of England. In regards to Diarmait Mac Murchada, evidence states that his motives for Anglo-Norman force were well founded with purpose, planning and foresight.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work