• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was Napoleon I an "Unprincipled adventurer whose genius owes more to propaganda than to deeds"? [Quoted in D.G. Wright Napoleon and Europe (1984) p.93]

Extracts from this document...


Was Napoleon I an "Unprincipled adventurer whose genius owes more to propaganda than to deeds"? [Quoted in D.G. Wright Napoleon and Europe (1984) p.93] D.G. Wright's view of Napoleon is justified, he was a terrific propagandist, as many of the worlds greatest dictators have been; however if all Napoleon's works were backed up by propaganda, then his legacy would have been flawed and therefore would not have lasted as long regardless of whether it is a good or bad legacy which is left behind. To discover whether Wright's view is not only justified but correct, several things need to be looked at, like Napoleon's personality and what it is about him that attracted so much attention. How much evidence there is in historical documents to support the theory that all Napoleon's genius owes more to propaganda than anything else. Or whether Napoleon's military actions show actual skill. Records show that Napoleon's personality was domineering, and is what many people remember him for, his contemporary William Hazlitt, calls him a "tyrant by divine right"(1). Hazlitt sees Napoleon as a tyrant but claims there was a kind virtue about this quality. ...read more.


As he took control of the government as well as the army, his attention naturally became more divided, but because of his desire for military glory, he did not make the decisions about the running of France for himself. There are many things in French history, that Napoleon is given unfair credit for; for example the Napoleonic code, the civil government system and the metric system. These were all the work of other people that had began while "he was still an unknown artillery subaltern" (1), however most of the work that went in the Napoleonic code, or code Napoleon were based on his own ideas. There are however factors that show that Napoleon was a principled military leader. He fully exploited the innovations in Warfare, he used the newest forms of military skill. The French Infantry and Cavalry were among the best in Europe, and were used more effectively with the infantry fighting in squares to keep all angles covered, to have better defense (5). Napoleon was among the first Generals to be able to mobilize massive armies; he also initiated the idea of self-contained Corps D'Armee of between 15,000 and 30,000 men advancing separately. ...read more.


He sponsored a major program of intellectual and archaeological study of the country". However, Rapport comments that the British thwarted this plan. This shows that Napoleon was not purely interested in military gains. He wanted to lead to further education of the French. In conclusion, the idea of the Napoleonic legend can be flawed depending on the historical point of view taken. Napoleon like many leaders of powerful country had his successes and his failings. Napoleon was a good diplomat, and he did not spend all of France's money on building statues and commemorations to himself. However due to his temperament, he can be considered unreliable. D.G. Wright's comment that he was an "unprincipled adventurer whose genius owed more to propaganda than to deeds" is however far from the correct view that should be had of Napoleon. Most of his judgements in warfare were well calculated. He did make errors, and he could be heavy handed with the treatment of people. Nevertheless, he was a good commander, and he was generally fair unless pushed to his limits. He did use propaganda but only to back up the things that he was actually doing. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1800-1899 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1800-1899 essays

  1. To what extent can Napoleon be seen as "heir to the revolution" in his ...

    Although figures show that Napoleon's education system was beneficial for France, it still wasn't the reason why he reformed education.

  2. "Discuss the aims of the Congress of Vienna and the Consequences it had on ...

    After the congress of Vienna was established, and the countries finally restored, the European countries decided to meet up occasionally to attempt to deal with any issues that needed to be discussed. They would also discuss any conflicts and try to obtain peace, in case any revolutions occurred.

  1. Using Internet Resources for Historical Research. Looking for information on the Internet ...

    The most popular search engines are WWW.google.com and WWW.yahoo.search.com. The thesis here is Napoleon. Villain or Visionary? The man, his wars and his empire. Key words: "Napoleon Bonaparte history of war" lead to the site: http://www.historyofwar.org/articles/people_napoleo5n.html. Early life of Napoleon, his childhood, education and further life.

  2. An In-depth comparison of two major Confederate Commanders: Robert. E. Lee and Braxton Bragg, ...

    However the major event of this da y was The Confederates infantry assault on the union forces. 12,500 men assault the Union centre line on Cemetery Ridge. This bold attack was repulsed by Union rifle and artillery fire. This amounted to incredible losses for the Confederate army.

  1. The evolving identity of Scottish peoples in New Zealand during the 19th century

    Brooking argues that the association between Highlanders and the High Country, in particular, "is not accidental...They sought out country which seemed familiar to them and on which their special skills in pastoral farming could be employed to best advantage."28 Also of influence were 'Scottish networks', which, according to McAloon, were

  2. Total War is as much a myth as total victory or total defeat - ...

    concepts and that as a result they have merged making it difficult to distinguish one from the other. However it seems the concept of ?Total War? is more an ideal some wish existed as a way to really emphasise if a War has been particularly brutal or if it did have rather a large influence over a nation.

  1. The revolutions would not have occurred without the economic crises that hit Europe in ...

    The outlawing of political banquets is but one government action that led to popular discontent, it just so happened that it directly resulted in the February revolution. Similar calls for popular participation, for democracy, were heard right throughout Europe; culminating in the forced resignation of Metternich in Austria; in the

  2. Compare and contrast the European-indigenous encounter in Australia with that of New Zealand. In ...

    and New Zealand natives at the time of first contact that will establish a solid foundation from which comparison and contrast between the two encounters may be better illustrated. Any directional nuance in the subsequent relationship between the invader and the invaded may now be viewed from this platform of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work