• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What is the role of the nurse in different versions of the Hippolytus myth?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

What is the role of the nurse in different versions of the Hippolytus myth? The role of the nurse within the Hippolytus myth varies between sources. This essay shall use examples of literature and art to explore how the nurse's role changes over time according to the views of the audience and the artist. Euripides' play is an example of Greek literature where the nurse has been given a clear pivotal role in the Hippolytus myth. The key themes in the Euripides version of the myth are around secrets and silence. If the nurse were removed from the play, then no tragedy would occur, Phaedra would go through with her threat to kill herself, Hippolytus would be ignorant of her feelings and Thesus would not have had his son destroyed by Poseidon. Euripides first presents the nurse as trying to help Phaedra. She is exasperated and determined to find out what is the matter with her mistress and although it is done out of love; "I brought you up; I'm fond of you" (Hippolytus, 698 in Euripides 1996) it is her meddling that ultimately brings about the death of Hippolytus. ...read more.

Middle

The nurse is an older woman, which would usually suggest someone wise. Phaedra does not appear to be paying attention to her nurse, she is facing away from her, ignoring the advice that she gives Phaedra at the start of the play. Being seated clasping her knees shows us a Phaedra is struggling to resist the desire she feels (Taplin 2007). Aphrodite takes centre stage of the scene representing the influence that the goddesses have over the tragedy. Comparing Euripides' Hippolytus to Seneca's Phaedra we can see both differences and similarities in how the nurse is used. Seneca was written in the Roman period where attitudes were different. Roman society approved of modesty and fidelity, especially in women. When myths were portrayed, women were used to give a clear message of what destruction was caused to households when social barriers were broken down, especially amongst the upper or ruling classes (Budelmann & Huskinson 2011 p.52). Seneca has his nurse emphasize this theme; "people who overindulge themselves amidst too much prosperity and live extravagantly are always looking for something new and unusual" (Phaedra p.112 in Seneca 2011) ...read more.

Conclusion

Both of these versions are referring to the consequences of human actions. Although there are certainly differences between Greek and Roman interpretations of the role of the nurse, the two plays by Euripides and Seneca have, to some degree, used the role of the nurse similarly. They both use her as the catalyst within the story; if she was absent there would be no real tragedy. They differ in their identification of the rationale behind the tragedy; Euripides' nurse points the blame at Aphrodite, whilst Seneca's nurse uses the actions of human's decisions to bring about the tragedy. Both nurses act out of love for their mistress but both become the target of the audiences' blame for the resulting deaths. Euripides also may certainly have used his nurse as a voice for his 'corrections' of his former version of the play. His nurse was also used to shock Greek society by getting Hippolytus, her master, to keep a secret that he dare not reveal. Other cultural materials depicting the myth support the societies' views of their time. They either illustrate the nurse, along with the goddesses and their influences on the characters within the myth or, they show the nurse and Phaedra, indicating a society's view on conspiratorial nature of women and the consequences of their actions. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Classical Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Classical Studies essays

  1. Alcestis. In Euripides play, Alcestis, the chorus serves as a way to observe and ...

    After much anticipation of the queen's death, the Chorus finally informs the audience she has passed. This helps to push to the play along towards the climax. Not only does the Chorus help to forward the play, they also help to emphasize the foreshadowing elements of the play.

  2. Free essay

    Could a female be as heroic as a male character in Greek tragedy?

    (Poetics 13) Certainly, we can allow ourselves to feel significant sympathy for Clytemnestra in her situation, yet Aeschylus presents us with a character with no evidently 'good' qualities. Her attempts to be a good wife are minimal and false, and any sympathy we might feel for her is undermined in

  1. How does Ovid weave together the different myths in Book 6 of Metamorphoses into ...

    The second story involving competition involves Apollo's punishment of Marsyas. It is a very different outcome for Marsyas, who is flayed alive for daring to challenge Apollo to a piping competition. Ovid gives a very graphic depiction of Marsyas being stripped of his skin until his organs lay bare (6.384-391),

  2. Shakespeare one word play in King Lear

    Nature, art my goddess" in I, ii, 1), and whereas "nature" usually refers to the human nature and hence it is not personified nor apostrophized, both "Nature" and "nature" can in fact focus on either the physical or the spiritual aspect of them.

  1. Does Classical Mythology reflect a disposition to explore the realities of the world or ...

    But if a Greek went through the motions of piety, he risked little. A parallel can be drawn today; how many people attend church for special occasions like weddings, christenings, Easter and Christmas? They are seen to be performing the rituals that are expected but do not necessarily believe.

  2. Republic of Plato Essay - Ignorance, and Philosophical Conflict

    The lucky philosopher-to-be is dragged up by benevolent individuals on the mountain from whatever level they are at, because dragging ignorant persons to the light does not cause a philosopher to degrade, that is, to slide down the mountain. Without the restriction of the Noble Lie, there is no inherent

  1. JUVENIL'S SATIRES - attacking the Patron-Client Relationship in Roman Politics.

    of 6.25 sesterces, it is hard to feel sorry for the patrons who were already incredibly wealthy and could easily support themselves after this payment to their client. For example, Pliny the Younger left 1120 sesterces to each of 100 freedmen - annually 4(Friedlander, RLM I, 79).

  2. In Book 9 of Homers The Iliad, Aias seemingly plays a very minor role ...

    Mortality is a recurring motif throughout this epic. After Agamemnon threatens to take away Briseis, Achilleus?s most treasured prize of war, Achilleus proclaims: ?I for my part did not come here for the sake of the Trojan spearmen to fight against them, since to me they have done nothing ?And

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work