• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A rhetorical look at "Television The Plug In Drug" by Marie Winn

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Depner, J 1 Jerome Depner Instructor Dougherty English 090-56I 20 May 2011 Television: The Plug-In Drug The essay "Television: The Plug-In Drug" by Marie Winn describes how the first generation of television viewers imagined this new invention would revolutionize the home front. Winn moves on to emphasize how important the television has actually come to families, however not necessarily for the best. Winn continues with excerpts from mothers, teachers, professional therapists, and a host of different types of people describing how a television has become too controlling in modern families. After describing each excerpt Winn summarizes stating that television is destroying families by taking opportunities from families to interact normally. The essay uses many different devices of writing to emphasize the author's point of view, and lead the readers to believe her analysis is correct. Winn establishes ethos in the beginning of the essay by discussing the early days of television. She starts the essay by introducing facts on television and quoting well known sources like The New York Times as well as not so well known sources to ensure her readers that she in knowledgeable in the given subject. ...read more.

Middle

Winn plays on the parental concerns of readers to give her argument a skeletal structure while filling in the fatty tissues with her own reflections. Winn uses Irony in the paper when she used multiple quotes describing the benefits of televisions in homes from early analysis of the device, although giving the exact opposite opinion of her own. She continues by stating that the people she quoted could never have seen the hazardous change in life style due to the television and twists these quotes to her own advantage. She frames these quotes in such an ironic manner that they become the platform for her jumping off point to begin talking about her own sentiments on the subject. Winn continues the Irony to the end of the essay when quoting the book Television and the Quality of Life by stating that the more time families spend together watching television left those families feeling unchallenged and passively engaged as a whole, and all together less satisfied. (Winn 465) Winn appeals to the pathos of her readers with the argument that television destroys family interactions. ...read more.

Conclusion

It seems that Winn is constantly accusing the parents for how their children have become addicted to television, and in some cases have addicted the parents as well. Winn states that "...the medium's dominant role in the family serves to anesthetize parents into accepting their family's diminished state and prevents them from struggling to regain some of the richness the family once possessed." (465) In most cases the parents are to blame for letting their children be raised by a television, or watching a cumulative of hundreds of thousands of hours of programing just because a child wanted to, however what about the parents who couldn't tell their children to turn off the television because they were at work? Shouldn't the child be held responsible for part of their actions in choosing to watch so much programing? Winn used many Different writing techniques to emphasize her points in the essay, some well-placed others with a bit more routine use. I found the essay a bit too pushy in regards to making the authors point of view stick, however setting aside the author's point of view the article was quite informative and well structured. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Television & Radio Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Television & Radio Studies essays

  1. Nepal television Evening News Bulletin

    These sources are, as acccording to Breed , W (1955: 186): "mainly individuals and organizations high up in the social hierarchy and mostly state officials and departments." The NTV has always been the primary receptor of such authority signals and messages in order to give out a situation that was to the interest of those in power.

  2. textual analysis of SATC

    The show often depicts frank discussions about romance and sexuality, particularly in the context of being a single woman in her mid-thirties. To begin with I first watched 'What's Sex Got to Do with It?' with a pen and paper and simply wrote down any clear ideas which were presented without an in depth analysis.

  1. Conversation Analysis

    (ibid p.10). James McDonnell (1991) argues that one member of the committee's opinion was found favourable by the majority- John Reith. Reith believed that broadcasting should not remain in the private sector and that a company with "...such potential power over public opinion and the life of the nation ought to remain with the State..."

  2. 'In attempting to understand the making of meanings in contemporary media cultures, should our ...

    other types of production as different is the notion that "the 'object' of production practices and structures in television is the production of a message". Achieved by specific organisation and adherence to particular codes "within the syntagmatic chains of a discourse", messages are produced within mediated texts and circulated to audiences (ibid., 1973:1).

  1. 'The Golden Age of British Television'Discuss and account for this view of television in ...

    As I already mentioned above there was that economic factor, which also influenced the way how people treat the television. The very important fact is that there were not such a wide spread central heating as we have nowadays, so people have usually the television in the room where they have some source of warmth.

  2. ''Children are dedicated consumers of television. A substantial part of their waking hours is ...

    David Buckingham also mentioned this time of 'media panic'5 in Britain. For some, it is television's fault that society is at the state it is in today, inciting aggressiveness and disruptive behaviour in the youth. It is rare that a day goes by where a newspaper does not include some

  1. Can there be a sociology of popular television?

    into the 1950s and 60s, and it is with a historical source paradigm that we study such seminal 'effects' works as Packard's 'The hidden persuaders' (1957). As the title suggests, this charismatic book likens the trend in merchandise advertisement as akin to an overall hidden 'effect' that permeates his contemporary society in politics and industry: 'All this probing and manipulation...

  2. What goes on behind the scenes at a television studio is just as important ...

    Such people had the discretionary income and some fascination with what later came to be known as "new technologies." But their decision to buy sets frequently carried an additional cost. Relatives, friends, and neighbors groped for an excuse to drop by to watch TV.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work