• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Analyse Orientalism as a tool for deconstruction images of the Third World.

Extracts from this document...


Analyse Orientalism as a tool for deconstruction images of the Third World Orientalism can be seen as a useful tool in deconstructing images of the 'Third World'. This paper will demonstrate how Orientalism as an analytical tool aids the interrogation of images of women in the 'Third World'. Secondly, the limitations of Orientalism will be shown in that the ability to deconstruct an image cannot be confused with a moral rebuttal. In conclusion, this paper will demonstrate Orientalism to be a useful tool in deconstructing image of the 'Third World', even though we best understand this usefulness to be limited to an extent. For Hoogvelt the idea that writings or concepts can be considered Orientalist in character rests upon the understanding that the images they infer are the "outcome of profound historical pressures and struggles" (Hoogvelt, 1997, p. 29). From a Gramscian perspective the "historical process to date deposits [in an idea] an infinity of traces without leaving an inventory, therefore it is imperative to compile such an inventory (Said, p.2)." Orientalism is a tool with which we can compile such 'an inventory' with reference to those conceptions and images of the world generated by discursive practices that bind Western knowledges of the East to its domination over it. ...read more.


Liddle and Rai contend that the workings of orientalist power are "invoked discursively when male oppression and female resistance are characterized in such a way as to reinforce a 'hierarchy of civilization'" (Chu, 2001, p2). When in the early twentieth century Europeans complained brazenly "the Japanese worker is hardly willing to submit himself to the military discipline which according to our standards must rule the modern factory" (Iwabuchi, 2003, p.1) Orientalism was clear. It is similarly present in frustrated NGOs who complain of the "negative role that traditional culture played in 'blocking' development" (Hoogvelt, 1997, p.30). It is much more subtle in these feminist discourses but the image of women in the 'Third World' can be deconstructed using Orientalism to reveal traces of imperialist conceptions of the world nonetheless. For Jack Donnelly, however, to do so in such instances is tantamount to a dangerous kind of moral relativism (Donnelly, 1999). He attacks statements made by writers such as Lee Manwoo who argues that, "different civilizations or societies have different conceptions of human well-being. Hence, they have a different attitude toward human rights." (Manwoo, 1997, p.131) For Donnelly writers such as Barry and Feldt are articulating views that ought not to be seen as signs of "disrespect but of disagreement" (Donnelly, 1999, p60). ...read more.


then the limitations of it are profound. It can more profitably be seen to show the difficulties inherent in talking about another part of the world. This difficulty is amplified by the particular historical circumstances that will necessarily impact upon our view of the world as Orientalism, understood properly, reveals. Horner argues that China's encounters "with the Islamic parts of the post-colonial world" display "another Orientalism" (Horner, 2001, p1). "Secular radicalism informed both Chinese strategic ambitions in Southeast Asia and," he argues, "Indonesia's own internal political vocabulary" (2002, p2). In this Horner takes Orientalism to mean a particular historically developed set of traces on the 'inventory' of an idea. For Horner Orientalism enables him to better understand China and its relations to the Islamic world. Rightly, however, these observations are not argued in a moralistic manner. Orientalism is a useful tool in deconstructing images of the 'Third World'. Orientalism as an analytical tool aids the interrogation of images of women in the 'Third World'. We best understand this usefulness to be limited. Orientalism is a good means of interrogating an idea. To do so may at times undermine viewpoints articulated against a perceived 'moral' wrong (as was seen in Barry's writing). Of itself, however, Orientalism is not a useful tool in building ethical frameworks or new approaches to development issues. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Anthropology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Anthropology essays

  1. This Research paper will present an overview of traditional Chinese marriage system and customs ...

    This meeting involved the bride bowing to her parents-in-law and other family member and present gifts she had bought from her family. In return, the groom's family would give her some gifts or money. Thus, the position of the bride in the groom's family would be confirmed.

  2. Children and warfare, are their rights being violated?

    Children are also usually used in suicide missions or what some call human wave attacks. This is where they overpower a well guarded opposition stronghold. This accomplished, because of their great number of soldiers. The rates for child soldiers that are killed have been much higher than those for same adult groups.

  1. Why has the concept of exchange proven such a useful tool in anthropology?

    social bonds, to receive in order to maintain the existing social relations, and to then return the equivalent or greater value and by doing so demonstrate one's prosperity (Mauss 1954, p. 10-11, 37-41). Such rules regulate this unusual battle in which the winner is the one who demonstrates a greater

  2. Discuss the purposes of genetic testing during pregnancy and the ethical issues raised by ...

    Though it is possible to predict whether a child is likely to have phenylketonuria if it is present in the family, tests for it cannot be carried out during pregnancy. The concentrations of phenylalanine are normal even in foetuses that are homozygous for the disease (Ibid), because proteins pass across

  1. The Color Purple has been described by critics as a feminist novel, do ...

    She defines 'womanism' with the statement "womanist is to feminist as purple is to lavender". Walker's purpose is to show the ill treatment black women have endured, especially in the early 20th century, in the southern US and also in Africa, and to show how they have struggled to free themselves.

  2. The West: Unique, not universal

    major non-Western societies to sustain democratic governments for any length of time). Individually, almost none of these factors is unique to the West. But the combination of them is, and has given the West its distinctive quality. These concepts, practices, and institutions have been far more prevalent in the West than in other civilizations.

  1. Is it possible to forge a post-colonial geography?

    This is a problematic term in its own right since it implies the initiatives for decolonisation were taken by the metropolitan, ruling powers, rather than by the colonised peoples themselves. Chamberlain (1985) notes that decolonisation varied over time and space.

  2. How much power did women possess in Early Modern Europe

    These ideas lead Jurists in many parts of Europe to recommend, and sometimes execute, the re-introduction of gender-based guardianship. This meant that; unmarried women and widows were again given male guardians, and prohibited from making any financial decisions without their approval.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work