• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Asymmetric information in the healthcare insurance market.

Extracts from this document...


If you think your health insurance expenses are high now, just wait. A couple of weeks ago I did my grocery shopping at a local Vons that is conveniently within walking distance of my apartment. I was getting used to seeing a barren parking lot; chased away by the union thugs. Just when I was about to enter the store, a picketer stepped into my path and gruffly gave me an unlimatum to shop at Stater Brothers. I politely smiled and told the picketer "I came to shop here." These low skilled workers are fighting for their healthcare packages. Having worked on the actuaraial side of healthcare for the past few years, I empathize with the management. Vons employees aren't aware of what an amazing healthcare package they are blessed with. Grocery store union workers, before the strike, paid nothing for their copay and only $5 for a doctor visit/prescription medication. This truly is unheard of today. To begin with, the majority of Americans do not have privatized healthcare insurance and rely on state assisted programs. However, greater part of employees with privatized healthcare pay a share of their healthcare costs - now grocery store employees are being asked to do the same. It is apparent that the members of the UFCW (united food and commercial workers) union remain determined to keep their premium health care coverage at any cost, even if it is a benefit few workers emjoy. Costs for many workers are set to soar as employers remove the last key feature that helped hold down expenses for many consumers in the past two decades: lower out-of-pocket charges for such things as office visits, hospital care and prescription drugs. Members of the United Food and Commercial Workers union who work in the Southern California grocery stores say they remain determined to keep their premium health care coverage, even if it's a benefit few other workers enjoy. ...read more.


In the graph above, it can be seen that both types of consumers are presented with a just and non-discriminatory contract. Both demanders are able to maximize their utilities given their individual budget constraints, since by definitions - indifference curves are tangent to their budget lines. In this diagram, a stable separating equilibrium is possible because of the genetic testing. However, high risk consumers desire the same contrat as low risk buyers because of the lower premiums. If genetic testing was not mandatory, then high risk buyers would lie and purchase the low risk contract, subsequently accessing a higher indifference curve. Asymmetric information: We have established that with asymmetric information the high riskers would be able to access the low risk health insurance due to the fact that insurers are unable to calculate and predict inherent risk. The probability of getting sick or suffering from an injury escalates while premiums and coverage stay constant. As a result of asymmetric information, halth insurance companies incur dramatic losses. This problem is called adverse selection. If genetic testing were not required, then in order to circumvent adverse selection, the pooled insurance method or the option of providing limited coverage for the low risk demanders are the two methods that insurers currently implement to reduce loss. Pooled insurance: The above graph shows that pooling the risks of both the high and low demanders is possiblity, but it is also inefficient and unstable. Since there are separating plans with lower premiums available to low risk individuals, low risk buyers will most likelyl not enroll in a plan where premiums are calculated using pooling. Consequently, low risk individuals opt-out of insurance coverage and will therefore not be covered in the even that the unexpected does actually happens. Additionally, the effect of low risk individuals exiting the risk pool will produce a higher claims mean and thus instigate higher premium for those remaining buyers. ...read more.


Most people are already willing to perform medicals and truthfully report their health status. Some genetic diseases are more prominent in certain races. Thus, the issue of racial discrimination is another factor that stands against genetic testing. Although informed family planning is advantageous genetic testing could result in eugenics. This occurs when people refuse to have children with a certain partner due to them carrying mutated genes. This is already practiced in Greece, Turketyvand Cyprus10. Those of very high risk could become non-insured due to extortionately high premiums. When faced with illness they will struggle to live off their wealth and pay treatment bills. Mandatory testing would solve the economic problems of asymmetric information - but it could instigate just as many social problems for society. Refrences 1. New Controls on Gentic Tests, Wednesday 5th February 2003 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/2723579.stm 2. Rees, Ray. Uncertainty, information and insurance, in Current Issues in Microeconomics. 3. Harris, Rodney. The Health of the Nation. The British medical Journal,1991 4. Donaldson & Gerard. Economics of Health Care Financing, 1993. Chapter 3 & 4 5. Wagstaff, 1986, The Demand for Health, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 6. Altman, Daniel.. "Genetics and Insurance." The Economist. (April 2001) 1-6 7. Anonymous. "Leaders: Insurance in the Genetic Age." The Economist. 3:57 (21 October 2000) 1-2 8. Bolger, Andrew & Clive Cookson. "The Risks of Gene Testing: Advances Could Deny Medical Insurance to Many." Financial Times. (7 April 2001) 1-2 9. Doherty, Neel. & Leesa. L. Posey. "On the Value of A Checkup: Adverse Selection, Moral Hazard, and the Value of Information." The Journal of Risk and Insurance. 65:2 (June 1998) 189-211 10. McPake, Barbra, Kumaranayake, Lilani, & Charles Normand. Health Economics: An International Perspective, London: Routeledge, 2002. . 1 Source: New controls on genetic tests, Wednesday 5th February 2003. http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/2723579.stm 2 Source: Ray Rees, Uncertainty, information and insurance, in Current Issues in Microeconomics. Macmillan, edited by J.D. Hey, 1989. 3 Source: Ray Rees page 69. 4 Harris, p. 172. 5 Bolger & Cockson, p. 1 6 Ibid., p. 2 7 Anonymous, p.2 8 Anonymous, p.2 9 Wagstaff 10 Altman ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Healthcare section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Healthcare essays

  1. Today's healthcare environment dictates that management decisions are clinically sound, operationally efficient, financially responsible ...

    The researcher will seek to obtain a sample size of around 150 respondents. The researcher will write to the selected respondents via the respective HR departments in order to seek their co-operation and participation in the study. Once the confirmation that they wish to participate in the study has been

  2. Euthanasia - an analysis of the theories and principles which guide healthcare practice and ...

    There is the very real risk, in short, that vulnerable people would be forced by unscrupulous relatives into making premature decisions they did not really want. It is sometimes suggested that euthanasia is discriminatory because it implies that some lives are of less value than others and so are not worth prolonging.

  1. What are the main challenges faced by mature students studying Healthcare courses in Higher ...

    that changing identities creates tensions between these roles which can be stressful and incapacitating. This stress was compounded further when trying to balance academic life with work and family responsibilities (Steele et al 2005). Many of the students, in their study, also suffered anxiety with regards to education re-entry, in

  2. Patient Screening

    Astrand -Rhyming Test The Astrand-rhyming test is also a sub maximal test requiring the client to wear a heart rate monitor. The seat of the Monark cycle is to be adapted to suit the client and their weight is recorded.

  1. Rise in Healthcare spending

    Thus, a reliance solely on the consumer-driven model is not likely to solve the problem, since it would do little to address the key factors that underlie the rise in health care spending. Indeed, missing from the list of solutions for slowing health spending growth are public health and preventive

  2. Health Profile

    weather conditions, with the coast keeping hot conditions bearable with sea breezes and the sea salt in the air providing a basic deterrent from icy conditions during the cold winter months. The resident population of Castle Ward, as measured in the 2001 Census, was 7,895, of which 46% were male and 54% were female (appendix 4).

  1. Review of Factors Influencing Successful Patient Education in a Rehab Unit for Spinal Cord ...

    The study suggested need for improvement in the overall health behaviours *** Author, Year, Reference Journal and Country Study Design and Type of method Risk of bias Inclusions and Exclusions Result Comments Usefulness of Study 12 Gelis, A., Stefan, A., Colin, D., Albert, T., Gault, D., Goossens, D., Fattal, C., Pelissier, J., Coudeyre, F.

  2. Texas State Insurance Exchange. The American Health Benefits Exchange and the Small Business Health ...

    the poverty level and 9.5% of income for those between 300-400% of the poverty level. (The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation) 5. For those individuals with incomes ranging from 100-250% of the poverty levels, cost-sharing subsidies will be available. (The Henry J.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work