• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparisons in the representation of Act1, Scene One Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet" in the film adaptations by Franco Zefirelli (1968) and Baz Luhrmann (1997) have differences and similarities in many elements.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Media Coursework Comparisons in the representation of Act1, Scene One Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet" in the film adaptations by Franco Zefirelli (1968) and Baz Luhrmann (1997) have differences and similarities in many elements. Zefirelli set his story in Italy, which portrays the film as an old and traditional one. The town is busy with many villagers buying and selling goods in the market, which seems like an ordinary day for the people. In 1068, there weren't any "hi-tech" buildings compared to elderly churches, town squares and markets. The atmosphere is busy but calm because the music played is soothing especially at the beginning. This is a more appropriate setting compared to Lurhmann's version because that was the way Shakespeare wrote them; in the earlier days there were no skyscrapers or office blocks. However, Lurhmann's version was very much different because although the setting seems like Italy, it was actually America. The beginning was set on California beach, which was Verona beach in the film. Lurhmann decided to use Mexico as Capulet's house. There are skyscrapers built with "Montague" signs written above them, which portrays them as businesses, because that is the only reason I can think that there would be such exploitation of their names. That is evidence that Lurhmann decided to pay attention to detail. The atmosphere is busy but not as crowded and enclosed as the market place in Zefirelli's representation. ...read more.

Middle

The styles of the clothes are clownish just like those of a joker. The Montague's wear dark, sombre and dull colours, which can represent evil (in some sense). The Capulet's costumes in Lurhmann's film are mainly vests, dark trousers and tops, which reflect sinful and criminal impressions. Tattoos, piercing and heavy jewellery portray the image of the Mafia, especially as the movie is supposed to be set in Italy. Which is the total opposite compared to the Capulet's clothing in Zefirelli's film. The Montague's' wear the opposite again to the other movie; they have outrageous haircuts, brightly coloured hair especially fluorescent pink, tattoos but overall very bright and colourful. The Hawaiian looking lose shirts are left unbuttoned and float in the wind. They look like skaters with their baggy clothes, wild hair (and attitudes) with loud music blaring from their open top car. Even though they wear strange costumes, they reflect a reasonable amount of religious imagery. E.g., one of the Montague boys have (Montague" shaven into the back of their head, one Capulet boys have "sin" engraved into silver crowned teeth. Cinematography in both films is differently used. Zefirelli did not use many close-ups shots to emphasis their feelings/danger. The character's whole bodies fitted into a single frame most of the time; there was no sense of distance/size. The camera focused on side views of the characters. ...read more.

Conclusion

This makes it very difficult to follow if using the textbook. This is unfortunate for school students who have to study the text. The Montague boys originally started the "brawl" in the Lurhmann's version yet, again Zefirelli's kept to the story because the Capulet boys started the "brawl". Lurhmann makes Romeo hold a cigarette, but how can he if he is supposed to be religious? That is why Romeo holds a rose in Zefirelli's representation. Although, Zefirelli's film perceived as a more religious film, Lurhmann overcame this problem by screening religious imagery e.g. Montague's wearing crosses (the sign of Christianity) and sitting outside churches. I have to admit that I liked Lurhmann's representation better because it was more appealing due to the effects and cinematography; which (I feel) is better than Zefirelli's version. Obviously, we have to appreciate the time difference, and I suppose that is why I like it more. The older generations may fancy Zefirelli's film and the younger generation probably prefer Lurhmann's version. I enjoyed the music too. However, I do feel that Leonardo DiCaprio did not quite suit the role of Romeo because I perceive him as "Jack" out of Titanic, even though Romeo and Juliet was released out first. He was the main character in both films, but Romeo and Juliet had already been released before and all the "hype" and excitement had been over (1968, receiving a number of awards compared to 1997). Then again, everyone is different and both films were successful in their own ways. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Romeo & Juliet section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Romeo & Juliet essays

  1. How did Shakespeare create tension in act 1 scene 5 of Romeo and Juliet

    Tybalt wants romeo gone but lord capulet stops him and tells him off "why, how now, kinsman, wherefore storm you so?..."(act 1 scene 5) he holed this against romeo and wants retribution and calls romeo a "villain" (act 1 scene 5)

  2. Compare Baz Luhrmann's version of the Shakespeare classic 'Romeo and Juliet' with the original ...

    The music changes to western and this is indicative of a change in subject and style. Another man gets out of the car while the first moves towards the Montagues' car. The Capulets are dressed in a totally different way to the Montagues.

  1. Analysis and comparison of the presentation of the prologue in film version of 'Romeo ...

    In shot one, you can see the camera panning over the city of 'Fair Verona' and slightly out of focus. The light is blue and hazy, gradually brightening up as the camera pans, suggesting that it is dawn. The colour of the light in the sky shining over the city,

  2. Character Study On Juliet

    "If they do see thee, they will murder thee." She starts to get concerned that tonight may be his last night alive if they find him here and kill him. Juliet wants to get Romeo out of the property while he is still alive Romeo not dead Juliet wants to see Romeo again alive not dead.

  1. Romeo & Juliet Act 1 Scene 1

    He as a citizen of Verona has been exposed to the conflict of the two households from the moment he entered the city and like so many of the other people of Verona he is fed up; he tries to put an end to the violence by ruling that 'If

  2. Compare and contrast Romeo's speeches in Act 1 scene 1 when he speaks of ...

    The language is a main part of the whole play. Shakespeare communicates most of his thoughts, ideas and actions through the language he presents through the characters in the play. Shakespeare uses many oxymorons through Romeo to describe his love for Rosaline to great effect.

  1. Compare and Contrast the different ways in which Baz Luhrmann and William Shakespeare establish ...

    and have grown out of proportion to the rest of the natural order of things. Luhrmann also uses a lot of iconography to assert the power and status of the Capulets and the Montagues.

  2. To what extent is Baz Luhrmann's William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet a successful film ...

    with Romeo, a Montague, in the Capulets mansion, i.e she pushes him under water when there comes a chance that they might be seen together. It is left to the film audience to then decide whether she did this for the safety of her lover, Romeo, or for the safety of herself.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work