• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9
  10. 10
    10
  11. 11
    11
  12. 12
    12
  13. 13
    13

Russia's dilemma - Is Russia going to sign the Kyoto treaty?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

RUSSIA'S DILEMMA: IS RUSSIA GOING TO SIGN THE KYOTO TREATY? Global warming is a scientifically recognized process of the Earth's ozone and atmospheric decay that was first put on the political agenda by the UN(United Nations) with the adoption of the UNFCCC(UN Framework Convention on Climate Change) in 1992 and it came into force in 1994.1 The main reason behind the global warming is the unregulated and irresponsible use of fossil energy, which results in the release of climatic gases and eventually a rise in the global temperature. Unfortunately, an increase in the global temperature leads to the rising of the sea level, changes in precipitation and wind patterns, loss of biological diversity and a decrease in the quality of life, especially in the poorer parts of the world. The challenges involved with solving climate issues is first and foremost connected to use of fossil energy, and can generally be solved by increasing production of renewable energy and efforts made towards increased energy efficiency. If we continue to use fossil energy as we do today, we will experience a quadrupling of the world's greenhouse gas emissions in the course of the next 125 years, as the result of energy consumption and increase in population.2 The Kyoto Protocol, adopted at a December 1997 conference in Kyoto, Japan, obliges all signatory countries to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions by a yearly average of 5.2 percent in order to reach a goal by 2012 where participating countries are producing fewer greenhouse gases than they were in 1990. However, only developed countries are covered by the protocol because developed nations are responsible for the lions' share of greenhouse gas emissions that lead to the global warming and risk the Earth's environmental balance. ...read more.

Middle

Also, Vladimir Putin's climate change and economic advisor, Illarinov, points out that the United States and Australia opted out of the protocol after claiming that compliance would be too costly. Illarinov argues compliance with Kyoto would be even less affordable for Russia whose economy is only a fraction of the US or Australian economies.13 Other argument that the Russian government makes is that with the United States rejecting the treaty and China and India being kept out of the protocol, there would be no significant buyers for Russia's 'hot air' other than Japan, Canada and maybe few countries in Europe.14 Russian officials argue that they wouldn't be able to make billion dollars of profit as calculated and Kyoto treaty's costs will be more than its profits for Russia. Another reason why Russian government hesitates to ratify the Kyoto treaty is the Russian government officers' fear that signing the protocol would put constraints on Russia's economic and industrial growth and damage Russia's international competitiveness. Especially, Illarionov argues that even though currently Russia's emissions are lower than the 1990 goal, they are, with economic and industrial growth and Putin's plan to double gross domestic product in 10 years, again beginning to rise, which would leave Russia with an even smaller margin to trade in Kyoto emissions credits.15 Russians even consider the likelihood of stronger Kyoto emissions curbs later, which can eventually turn Russia into a buyer rather than a seller of emissions credits. In a study released last year by Alexander Nakhutin, Russia's chief greenhouse gas emissions forecaster, it is found that Russian greenhouse gas emissions have ballooned as much as 13% annually. If Nakhutin's projects are correct- and he is one of only a very few researchers with access to the best Russian industrial data, Russian carbon emissions will be 6% greater than they were in 1990, or %30 higher than originally envisioned. ...read more.

Conclusion

Recently, also a conspiracy theory has been created in media that the US administration attempts to lobby Moscow to take a particular stand on the Kyoto Protocol and pressure Russia to delay its decision. It is more interesting that former US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger and former US President George Bush Sr. made a visit to Kremlin to discuss about the Kyoto Protocol and other energy resources. Experts point out that the Washington administration argues about the fundamental flaw of Kyoto Protocol. So if the Kyoto Protocol comes into force, this argument loses a lot of strength and it would be a foreign policy disaster for the Bush administration.26 This is why it sounds pretty logical that the US administration may want to put pressure on Russia to delay its decision. In conclusion, Russia has been going through a tough transition period from totalitarianism to democracy and it is still in the progress of building an effective environmental regime. Limited resources, personnel shortages, and perceived conflicts between environmental and economic goals are few of the several reasons that explain why this progress has a slow pace. However, even more intractable obstacles include lack of training or experience in self-government, corruption, poorly functioning legal systems, and a basic lack of trust in government.27 In this kind of an atmosphere, having consensus and alliances necessary to make environmental decisions as well as developing effective environmental laws is a big challenge. This is why Russia has been still struggling to come to a firm decision about ratifying the Kyoto protocol since 1997 and it unfortunately seems like this reluctance will continue at least for a while... . ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Environmental Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Environmental Management essays

  1. Managing change by managing risk

    The plan itself may involve parallel development programs, etc. Assumption: Simply accepting the risk and proceeding. A word of caution: There appears to be a tendency within organizations to gradually let the assumption of a risk take on the aura of a controlled risk. This mental evolution is the kind of wrongly conditioned thinking that led to the Challenger failure.

  2. The Environment: Whose Responsibility?

    Here is what BP say on their website; "At BP we are dedicated to improving the quality of our fuels and making a positive contribution to a cleaner environment. Our commitment will, over time, help reduce emissions without denying people the fundamental right of mobility.

  1. Will big business save the earth? Business sector has always ...

    of source reduction with partial unfavourable information covered; Wal-Mart had been selling furniture made from wood which had been illegally logged in protected habitats for endangered species until being discovered a few years ago... the list goes on. It is obvious that big businesses have been disguising their environmentally destructive

  2. Contemporary issue assignment

    a unique experience - more so local personality, hospitality and food than "built attractions." Tourism can be used as a tool for raising awareness. Branding of local product and achievements creates regional identity both nationally and internationally. Tourism can also raise awareness of local issues and needs.

  1. Global Climate Change and Climate Protection: Current Summary

    The second-largest source of N2O emissions is agriculture, primarily fertilizer application and a small amount released from the burning of crop residues. However, there is substantial uncertainty and debate regarding the emissions implications of use of N-based fertilizers. Models used for estimation are based on limited sources of experimental data.

  2. In this paper we'll take a look at changes which each organization may face, ...

    Responses to Change6 Innovators (about 2-3%) These are change junkies...it doesn't matter what the change is, they will always sign up first. They like to tinker, they like to work with concepts and build prototypes. Early Adopters (10-15%) Much like the Innovators, they want to work with an early version (complete with bugs)

  1. Evaluate proposals for reducing environmental air pollution by energy taxation and emissions trading

    Governments may also argue that tax should be used as a way of controlling pollution levels as revenue from this could pay for cuts in income tax and potentially help increase employment as well as helping the environment. For example, in the US, if carbon emissions were taxed at a

  2. Political & Economic & Environmental Aspects of the Kyoto Protocol - The issue of ...

    Central to US obstinance was the lack of participation from China and India. Although major polluters themselves, because they are developing countries, the Kyoto Protocol accord does not require them to reduce their emissions at all. The Americans created an "all in" policy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work