Where should the balance of power liebetween the centre and the regions in an empire or federation?

Authors Avatar

James Crosbie E

Where should the balance of power lie between the centre and the regions in an empire or federation?

Across the pond they seem to be in a state of bother. The American government thought everything was “dandy”, the last time the constitution was amended was in 1992 and it looked like this would be the last draft; for a while at least.

As states’ rights have become hotly contested debates nowadays on topics like abortion, pornography, capital punishment or type of execution and gay marriage, the tenth amendment may resurface. In more detail I am talking about the tenth article of the Bill of Rights in which it states that “powers not delegated by the Constitution to the federal government nor prohibited by it to the states are reserved to the states or the people”. It is usually used to defend a state law that the Federal government seeks to override. There are actually no such things as “States’ Rights”; only the people, in American constitutional law, hold rights. Governments hold “powers” or “authority”. These rights are the freedom of speech, religion and press.

Join now!

I do think the running of States is like a well-oiled machine, however, in that the equilibrium of power lies toward the federal government and I think this is the right thing to do because regions with too much power can cause wars and deaths as arguments arise. If the states are not bound by laws they cannot adjust then they would not be united. The principle of states' rights was the basis on which many of the political battles preceding the American Civil War were fought. Slave states asserted that they had the power to maintain social institutions, ...

This is a preview of the whole essay