• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

to what extent have conservatives supported one nation principles?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent have Conservatives supported 'one-nation' principles? The belief that governments should be committed to reforms that make people feel part of the nation is a defining feature of one nation conservatism. The various factions of the ideology consist of differing degrees of one nation principles; in one nation Conservatism, this is the defining principle, in traditional Conservatism it is a minor consideration, whilst the New Right holds views that are against this belief. You should also be aware that ONC includes striking a pragmatic balance between business and the needs of the people, the idea of the government taking noblesse oblige and the idea of making decisions to keep the 'ship' afloat as opposed to directing it. Perhaps most obviously, one nation principles are at the centre of one nation conservatism. The idea of Britain being viewed as a nation is of great importance to one-nation thinkers and this is why they are committed to reforms that make people feel part of the nation. This brings in ideas of social responsibility and the belief that social reform is essential in order to preserve a fragile society; in terms of strengthening existing bonds, reducing resentment and making people feel part of the nation. ...read more.

Middle

In contrast to one-nation principles of social reform and a need for Britain to be defined as a nation, traditional Conservatives interpret the organic nature of society to mean that dramatic reforms will lead to an unstable society. This faction of the ideology holds the view that any reforms should be to maintain existing structures of historic institutions and not to better the lives of the people; the government has no role in social reform. Whilst one-nation principles vindicate social reform in order to maintain stability and order, traditional conservatives see the maintenance of hierarchy and ensuring that everyone knows their place as being important for stability. The idea that a fragile and organic society must be governed by the ruling classes and that normal people must know their place is put forward by Burke in his best known work, 'Reflections on the Revolution in France', in which he likens the state to a parent and subjects to its children. Here, he illustrates his belief that people have an obligation to obey the state as long as it provides them with order. ...read more.

Conclusion

This led him to advocate a dedication to free market principles and a rejection of state management. Whereas one-nation principles reach an accommodation between social reform and minimal government intervention, liberal new right thinkers believed in individual responsibility; people must solve their problems themselves rather than waiting for the state to do so for them. Ideas of social reform are rejected because of the belief that there will always be an 'undeserving poor', an underclass of people who could look after themselves but choose not to. It could be argued, therefore that liberal new right thinkers are in direct conflict with one-nation Conservatism. The main beliefs of different factions within conservatism vary in terms of the degree to which they are comprised of one-nation principles. One-nation conservatism is defined by these principles, traditional conservatism sees maintenance of the status quo rather than social reform as being key to stability, Neo Conservatives oppose one-nation principles in their belief in minimal government intervention but share the need for unity of the nation and liberal new right Conservatives reach no accommodation with one-nation principles. In conclusion, with the obvious exception of one-nation conservatism, the ideology is not really influenced by one-nation principles. ?? ?? ?? ?? Rebecca Marlow ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

5 star(s)

Response to the question

Response to Question
This question requires candidates to consider the evidence that conservatives have supported One Nation principles (such as the British Conservative Party from Disraeli's ministry to the beginning of Thatcher's leadership), and, importantly, to use the evidence of ...

Read full review

Response to the question

Response to Question
This question requires candidates to consider the evidence that conservatives have supported One Nation principles (such as the British Conservative Party from Disraeli's ministry to the beginning of Thatcher's leadership), and, importantly, to use the evidence of conservatives opposing One Nation ideas as an argument against the idea that conservatives have supported One Nation principles. With a "To what extent..." question, candidates should make a judgement at the end based on the two sides of the debate that they have weighed up, and this candidate is an excellent example of an effective concluding paragraph.

Level of analysis

Level of Analysis
The level of analysis in this essay is excellent. The frequent references to and use of quotations by politicians and political thinkers (Disraeli, Burke, Oakeshott, Joseph) demonstrates a strong candidate and is an important skill in order to gain a good grade in A Level Politics, as it shows the examiner the candidate has a good knowledge of the topic, and that they can apply their knowledge to new situations under timed conditions. The inclusion of the two other major branches of conservatism (traditional and New Right) in order to evaluate whether the ideology has been influenced as a whole by One Nation ideas is a good technique, and is a key aspect of this essay, as it provides the counterargument to the assumption put forward in the question. The candidate has also acknowledged the tensions between some of the core ideas of conservatism and the desire for social reform as advocated by One Nation principles shows an example of this, as they contrast traditional and One Nation conservatism.

Quality of writing

Quality of Writing
Overall the candidate's quality of written communication is very good, and their writing style is fluent and reads well. There are no spelling mistakes, but political ideologies are not proper nouns and thus should not be capitalised (i.e. "conservatism" and not "Conservatism", and "conservatives" should only be capitalised when referring to the Conservative Party). This is a very minor error, but it at A Level candidates should have an excellent grasp of spelling and grammar, particularly with regards to subject-specific vocabulary.


Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by ecaudate 20/04/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Compare and contrast the pluralist, elitist and Marxist theories of the state.

    So the ultimate source of power in a Marxist society is the ownership and control of means of economic production. This leads to a central theme of Marxism; the common ownership of productive wealth. If you control the production and distribution of something that everyone needs, this becomes a source of power that can be translated into political power.

  2. Compare and Contrast Positive and Negative Conceptions of Liberty.

    Berlin states 'Once I take this view, I am in a position to ignore the actual wishes of men or societies, to bully, oppress, torture them in the name, and on behalf, of their 'real' selves'7. By manipulating the meaning of the individual 'self', dictators have been able to distort

  1. Conservatsim favours pragmatism over principle, discuss.

    It is therefore vital for a traditional conservative to allow some form of pragmatism as, like previously, helps to conserve a society. Benjamin Disraeli went further than this and believed the rich had an obligation to help the poor. He was prompted by the division of wealth within Britain; this would go on to be called 'One-nation conservatism'.

  2. Compare the views about the nature and development of Carl Rogers and George Kelly. ...

    an individual was to understand, predict and control their own behaviour (Jourard, 1974). The prototype of a mentally healthy individual was seen on similar terms by Kelly and Rogers. They both named several similar characteristics that define a healthy personality.

  1. Compare and contrast the concepts of Anomie and Alienation.

    This is paralleled by a corresponding increase in human alienation, an increase that reaches its height in a capitalist society. Defining both of these concepts has shown that anomie and alienation appear to be rather similar. Marx believes that self-estrangement is the result of alienated labour and capitalist relations of

  2. "At the heart of New Right thought, lies the paradox of libertarian and authoritarian ...

    They accept the use of some initiation of force, such as a State that violates the non-aggression principle by taxing to provide some public goods and some minimal regulation. Some writers who have been called libertarians have also been referred to as classical liberals, by others and themselves.

  1. Define hegemony and explain its significance for Global World Order. (15)

    They usually inform the hegemonic state to do as they wish to restore World Order and therefore the state has much significance for World Order. An example of such pressure was apparent after the Kosovo Crisis. ?The CNN Effect? was the phrase given to describe the constant pressure put on

  2. To what extent is the global system now multipolar?

    Even President Obama was quoted saying ?We must borrow billions from China to bail out Greece.? This is illustrates the clear power of China that they possess above the rest, including USA, because that quote essentially has Obama conceding and admitting that the one real force in our global system is China .

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work