• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Evacuation was a great success" Do you agree with this interpretation? Explain your answer using the sources and your own knowledge.

Extracts from this document...


"Evacuation was a great success" Do you agree with this interpretation? Explain your answer using the sources and your own knowledge. In many ways evacuation was a success but also a failure in some. In the first three days of September 1939, nearly 3,000,000 people were evacuated to the countryside; this was the biggest mass movement of people in British history. However being a voluntary scheme parents had a hard time deciding; should they send away the things that mean the most to them and possibly never get them back, or keep them with you and risk their lives. I am going to use the following sources to help build on this. Source A shows a big success of evacuation. Despite this it has its problems. First of all it is a photograph, and in being so it only shows one spilt second in history, maybe all the children were really happy at this point but who knows about every other second of their lives during the war? It is also a natural instinct that whenever you see a camera you smile, especially in 1939 when cameras were rare things. The children in the picture may not have been happy about leaving but simply excited about having their picture taken. The photograph also appears to have been taken a stage, looking down on the children, this is how official pictures are taken, and someone taking a picture in a crowd would have taken the picture at eye level. ...read more.


However these sources are very useful, to start with the extract from the book is written from the point of view of an evacuee from a large city, who stays with someone in the countryside. The foster parents make an assumption that they are "too poor to afford a pair of slippers". Although the real reason they don't have slippers, is because the amount of clothing they were able to carry. This would be the attitude that some foster parents would have had, that the children they were fostering were poor, because they were from rural areas. This was a common misconception among a lot of foster parents in the countryside, however this misunderstanding started the opening up of Britain; country folk had little or no understanding of the city children, all they knew is what they saw, and what they saw was children covered in dirt and lice. After the war many rich influential people from the country began to demand more from their MP's to help these poor deprived children, this improved communications between the countryside and the cities and also helped start the first free health service the NHS. The source also shows that the children in the novel were having a good time because they didn't get angry at them for the mistake about the slippers they simply giggled. ...read more.


Source B however, I feel, was a failure. On the one hand it was written 40 years after the event took place, and memories can fade over time or change because she has seen so many programs and such with different information that the facts and what she has seen has all blurred together in her head, on the other hand something as emotional as evacuation is something that you will surely always remember especially as she was a teacher at this time so would have known the truth about what was going on as apposed to little children she was with who thought they were on holiday? We also don't know who the interviewer was so they could have altered the answers or asked leading questions. She also says that "we hadn't the slightest idea of where we were going" I know that with the poor organization the people didn't know where they were going till they got there. This is also just one person's opinion in the war. With the help of the above sources I have concluded that although there were many problems with evacuation, which can only be seen now in hindsight, that evacuation was indeed a great success, after all it did save millions of lives and was the biggest mass movement in British history. ?? ?? ?? ?? Ellen Funston History Coursework 11W ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Developmental Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Developmental Psychology essays

  1. Using studies from the list below, answer the questions which follow: Rosenhan (sane in ...

    These notions may imply that Freud's diagnosis of Hans' phobia being linked to his Oedipus complex may be wrong, since the data provided to Freud by Hans' father may be corrupted. Thus, if the data is incorrect, then it will lead to inaccurate interpretations of Hans' behaviour.

  2. What causes crime?

    This is not the case; there is new research that indicates women have higher moral orientation than men (Hoffman 1977). This theory is also limited in the types of crimes that it can explain. Kline (1987) suggests that there are many crimes that are deliberately planned and followed through, that are motivated through rational thought, not irrational thought.

  1. This assignment describes and analyses my involvement with a 13-year-old client Joe Smith, who ...

    (Gordon. D et al, 2000 ref 93) Joe has had a history of behavioural problems, both at home and at school, which have deteriorated further since his sister Emma was diagnosed with Cancer. He refused to attend school, and stayed out late indulging in both alcohol and drug abuse.

  2. "Evacuation was a great success". Do you agree with this statement? Use your own ...

    Many country dwellers did not know how city children lived and evacuation was an opportunity for them to find out. Source C, an extract from 'Carrie's War' by Nina Bowden highlights a misconception about evacuees as the child in the novel says " she thinks we're poor children, too poor to afford slippers".

  1. Evacuation - Both sources B and C show a different view on the ...

    This lack of communication was a huge problem and many children were extremely frightened and worried. The next stage of evacuation was a humiliating experience for many children; they would be lined up in front of the protective hosts who would choose which children they would like to have.

  2. The Home Front: Evacuation

    The general public felt that the Government had been too hasty, and had perhaps over estimated the resolve of the Germans. Some people didn't' send their children away for a different reason, however, and that is that they don't trust the Government: they are sceptical of anything the Government say

  1. Evacuation was a great success." Do you Agree or disagree with this interpretation?

    Another factor was that not all parents allowed their children to go because the uncertainly sometimes bordered on to paranoia mothers worried that her child would enjoy their new family to more than an extent and not want to return posters of played on parents fear to sending them away.

  2. ''Evacuation was a great success'' - Do you agree or disagree with this interpretation?

    Where his children would be sent, in the shires, 'there is nothing for them; they were starving before the war.' He also thinks that if he does die, at least friends and family can look after his children. This is very likely to be a reliable source, as it is

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work