• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically assess the view that the two Patrick theory solves the puzzle of Patrick

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Critically assess the view that the two Patrick theory solves the puzzle of Patrick The Two Patrick's theory was first delivered by Thomas O'Rahilly on the 20th of March, 1942. In it he summarises the studies he undertook in the years 1934-35. Originally, his interest was contained to the fifth and sixth century annals. It was while he studied these however, that he noticed the discrepancies surrounding the dating of Patrick's mission. Although he notes that "the history of Christianity in the fifth century bristles with difficulties, many of them in chronological order", he remains hopeful that "the most serious of our difficulties [regarding Saint Patrick] will resolve themselves quite readily once we get our chronology right." Bury's suggests the date 432-461 for Patrick. From 1905, this date was held as the "official" dating of Patrick's mission. O'Rahilly believes that Bury limited his work, because he was not an Irish language scholar, and he failed to look at sixth century annals while compiling his chronology. O'Rahilly firmly believes that if he had have studied the sixth century annals, and taken them into account then he would have a completely different view to the dating of his mission. ...read more.

Middle

Another idea that was mentioned was that the significant dates in some saints lives was moved, so that they correspond with other important figures, however baring in mind the amount of dates that are wrong, by up to seventy years, this is hugely unlikely. It is clear that the 492/3 date would "fit" other contemporaries, however in accepting this, we must question the date cited for the arrival of Patrick. Bury is convinced that this date is "certain, and rested upon clear and unvarying tradition." Bury rejects the 492/3 date, and is of the opinion that it was changed in an attempt to equate the lifetime of Patrick to that of Moses. O'Rahilly however argues that the 492/3 date is just as likely as the 461 death date, and he believes that rather the arrival date should come into question. Since the seventh century, and coming in to the ninth century, there has been a tradition of two missionaries called Patricius, who both worked in Ireland in the fifth century. O'Rahilly points out that there are notes in the appendix of T�rech�n's "Brief Account", in the "Book of Armagh", which speaks of: "Palladius also called Patricius." ...read more.

Conclusion

For example, Carney, who believes that Palladius laboured in Scotland, rather than Ireland, disputes O'Rahilly's identification of Palladius with the "elder Patrick". It has also been criticised because it is very much based on assumptions. O'Rahilly assumed that Palladius had worked in Ireland for thirty years, with little to no evidence. This is criticised because if Palladius did minister for thirty years, perhaps Patrick would have mentioned him in his writings? Murphy points out however, that Patrick failed to mention those who assisted him in his own mission with the Irish, never mind those who predecessed him. Ryan also puts forward a very credible argument. Palladius is widely associated with Auxilius and Iserninus. So if he had been a minister for thirty years, should they not have been the ones to become his success him, rather than an unknown Briton. Hanson is very critical of O'Rahilly's chronology, saying that its major weakness is that "it discounts internal evidence about him in favour of later tradition...it is not supported by any evidence in Patrick's writings...and rests on hypothesis." It is impossible to say that the Two Patrick theory solves the puzzle of Patrick, when there is so much conflict an debate regarding it, and so little scholars agree. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Christianity section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Christianity essays

  1. Examine and Consider critically the view of Scholars concerning the content and purpose of ...

    language is very similar, excluding when it changes in verse 14, to the rest of the Gospel. Also, why would the Evangelist feel it was necessary to write a summery and an explanation? The Gospel itself, without the Prologue, could exist without explanations and summaries at the beginning.

  2. Give an account of the missionary outreach of the Celtic Church in Britain? ...

    However, the invaders were to receive the faith from two different sources, the mission of Saint Augustine in 597 (the year that Colmcille died); and his successors, and the missionary outreach of the Celtic monks in Iona.

  1. Outline and explain the issues included in uncovering the historical Patrick (30 Marks)

    The big problem is that there is a two-hundred year gap between the time Patrick actually lived, and when he was first written about, so this leaves plenty of room for false information or inaccuracy. In Patrick's Confessio, Patrick tells us of his birth place, Bannaven Taburniae, but he does not tell us where it is actually located.

  2. ABOUT SAINT FRANCIS

    By the time he returned to Assisi, he was seriously ill. His mother's loving care and time itself brought him back to health, but the carefree life he had led before and which had started again by now, seemed empty to him.

  1. Explain the contribution of Thomas Merton to mysticism

    Merton has written in The Asian Journal of several mystical experiences he had during the trip. In India, he visited a Buddhist shrine and there had what seems to be a mystical experience, when he wrote of being visited by a presence that took him out of the body.

  2. Critically assess the view that sin always has serious consequences

    However, in more recent times I believe that sin is coming with less serious consequences in some cases. Sticking to the theme of homosexuality I will talk about Gene Robinson. In the past 20-30 years Robinson has had a huge impact on the way Christians view homosexuals in the Church.

  1. The Impact of Missionaries on the Joti Tribe of Venezuela

    authority and has even made disciplining their children a struggle for JotÑ parents. Before the missionaries arrived, the JotÑ also believed in many crazy things and also a few logical ones. For instance, every JotÑ was afraid of the water, believing that it was the gate to the underworld.

  2. Christianization throughout History. I wanted to find out the true origins of the ...

    The Act of fasting in preparation for a great occasion can be found in many lands. The Babylonians and their neighbors fasted for 40 days in preparation for the annual celebration of Tammuz?s resurrection. This is probably the direct source of the Christian Lent, but a pennence period like this can be found in many other societies as well.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work