• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Antacid Lab. Are name brand antacids better than generic brand antacids to neutralize stomach acids that may cause diseases? Which antacid is more effective? Are both brands equally effective?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The Effective Antacid Generic or Brand Name? SNC2DO Mr. Nestor User 3/25/2009 Question Are "name brand" antacids better than generic brand antacids to neutralize stomach acids that may cause diseases? Which antacid is more effective? Are both brands equally effective? Introduction The customary acid that is originated in a healthy stomach is also known as gastric acid. Gastric acid is one of the main emitting of the stomach, together with several enzymes and intrinsic factor. Chemically it is an acid solution with a pH of 1 to 2 in the stomach lumen, consisting mainly of hydrochloric acid (HCl), and large quantities of potassium chloride (KCl) and sodium chloride (NaCl). Stomach acidity is a frequent problem. The stomach produces acid to digest food that we consume. As we eat, the cells that border the stomach pump acid liquefy the food. However, the conflict occurs when these cells compose large amount of acid unnecessary for the stomach. The result of too much acidity is the feeling of a burning sensation or acid regurgitation. One of the most popular ways to prevent stomach acidity is by taking antacids that can be brought over-the-counter. Antacids are any material, usually base or base salt, used to neutralize stomach acids. The antacids execute a neutralization reaction. The antacids perform tasks such as, they buffer gastric acid, elevating the pH to decrease acidity in the stomach. If the base stomach acid is reduced it may result in a damaged ability to digest and absorb certain nutrients. For this reason it is very dangerous for antacids that may reduce the pH of the stomach acid lower than 2. Antacids are usually categorized into two different brands, generic and brand name. The two kinds of brands mainly contain the same compounds but the brand name is popular to the population. People usually purchase the name brands, available at pharmacies, because they are not aware of the generic brands unless prescribed by doctors. ...read more.

Middle

The ingredients in generic antacid include Calcium (as calcium carbonate), De-Glycyrrhizinated Licorice (root) 760 mg, and L-Glycine. The ingredients have selected ingredients like calcium carbonate, corn starch, talc, mineral oil and natural flavors help decrease the acidity of the stomach. The remaining ingredients are usually used for flavoring and color which are considered as bases so they may have a small part in neutralizing the stomach acid. The generic antacid contain three main ingredients which are meant to help the stomach acidic but they only play a small part in neutralizing the stomach acid. The main ingredient in both antacid that contributes to the neutralization of acid is calcium carbonate. The additional ingredients act as secondary ingredients that help stomach acidity. The brand name antacid contains more alkaline ingredients that last longer towards stomach acid. However the ingredients in the generic antacid appear to be less powerful against gastric acid although they do contribute to the neutralization process. I would want an antacid to dissolve instantly because the faster the antacid dissolves the sooner the antacid will digest and contact the excess acid. If the antacid dissolved instantaneously, less time is spend for the antacid to neutralize the gastric acidity. If the antacid dissolves over a period over time it is not as effective because it will take days even weeks before the antacid neutralizes the acid in the stomach. The fast relief antacid is more in demand by consumers because it is not preferred to wait around for stomach pain relief. Many cases involve liquid medicines to contain more concentration than solid medicines. Liquid medicines are also easier to swallow; faster absorption rate and they are more natural. The solid medicines are preferred usually due to longer shelf life, better tasting (rather no taste) and more convenient for travel purposes. One another main variable that I would consider is the cost of the antacid. ...read more.

Conclusion

I thought that generic brand would be effective because it did not include the artificial flavor and coloring which I though would reduce the strength of the antacid. Although results portray that the brand name antacids are more effective than the generic antacid, theoretically the two kinds of antacids are to be equally effective. The generic and the brand name antacids contain the same active ingredients. The only difference that the two kinds have are, the brand name antacid usually contain flavoring, coloring, and additional active ingredients. I think these extra ingredients in Tums, being mainly bases, may have contributed to gaining the name of the more effective antacid. The antacid lab raised certain questions that remain in my mind that are left unanswered. I was wondering if the additional ingredients in the brand name antacid help to make the antacid stronger, if it makes the antacid weaker or if it has no effect on the antacid. I also wanted to know if the water added to antacids had any effect on the end results. A question that raised my mind was even though theoretically the brand name and the generic antacid are hypothetically equally operative why it is that consumers prefer the name brand, even after the low prices of the generic brand? In reality, many people buy the brand name antacids because they are trusted by buyers and they are popular to consumers. I thought that the generic brand, although anonymous, they would be proven more effective and that consumers were making a mistake by buying the brand name just due to the fact that they were well-known due to advertising. I learned that brand name antacids are slightly stronger that generic and they are preferred because of the flavoring, color and even the shape. However, the lab taught me, on the long run they are both similarly effective because they have the same active ingredients. It is possible that one may be stronger than the other but they are both suitable for relieving pain for acidity in the stomach. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Physical Chemistry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Physical Chemistry essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Electrochemical Cells

    5 star(s)

    if I want to make 50ml of CuSO4 at 0.25mol dm-3, I would need to add 12.5ml of CuSO4 to 37.5ml of water. Analysis Table to show Electrode Potentials of Zinc and Copper Ions (V) Concentration of Zinc Sulphate (mol dm-3) 1.0 0.5 0.25 0.125 0.0625 Concentration of Copper (II)

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Finding out how much acid there is in a solution

    Once there is excess acid, there is a huge drop. This is due to reaching the point of equivalence. Weak Acid and Weak Base: e.g. A common example of a weak acid and weak base is ethanoic acid and ammonia.

  1. Drug: Antacid Effectiveness Analysis To determine the neutralizing ability of antacids in different ...

    CaCO3, magnesium hydroxide Mg(OH) 2 and sodium bicarbonate (commonly known as baking soda)NaHCO3. Antacid tablets neutralize the HCl in the stomach according to one of the following reactions, depending on the active ingredient. Acid + Base --> Salt + Water NaHCO3 + HCl -->NaCl + H2O + CO2 Al(OH)

  2. Investigating the Rate of the Reaction between Bromide and Bromate Ions in Acid Solution

    The units of k depend upon the orders of reaction with respect to the reactants: rate is measured in mol dm-3 s-1 and concentration is measured in mol dm-3; the units of k are found using Equation t and these units.

  1. Identification of amino acids by chromatography.

    I would make sure that I was wearing a strong pair of plastic gloves at all times and that I was only holding the top of the paper where the paperclips were inserted. This would avoid the problem of irrelevant chemicals contaminating the results.

  2. Investigating the rate of reaction between peroxydisulphate(VI) ions and iodide ions

    It is important to allow the contents of both the test tube and boiling tube to reach the desired temperature before proceeding. Measure the temperature of both the boiling tube and test tube contents with two separate thermometers. This is very important so as to prevent contamination of the experiment by the two reactants mixing beforehand.

  1. Electrochemistry - Inventing Better Batteries

    After extensive research into different forms of salt bridges, our group believes that in using the porous pot salt bridge the decrease in resistance provided by the pot will increase the voltage and current readings of the original Daniell Cell.

  2. Activity Series of Metals Lab

    24 hours was probably too short of a period time to determine if there is a chemical reaction present. To avoid this error from occurring again, the period of observation should be extended and observations should be taken more than once to see the gradual change.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work