“The most Important Reason Why Germany Hated The Treaty Was Because Of The Loss Of Territory”. Do You Agree?

Authors Avatar
st November 2001 Douglas Rubashow 10 S

"The most Important Reason Why Germany Hated The Treaty Was Because Of The Loss Of Territory". Do You Agree?

I quite strongly disagree with this statement, because I believe the Germans hated other parts of the treaty more. For example, if you look at the economic side of the situation, they might have lost a bit of money from the loss of land, with great industrial areas such as Alsace-Lorraine being returned to France, and also one of Germany's greatest industrial areas, the Saar (with the important coalfield) just being given to France. I think, however the reparations would have put a lot of economic, and probably more stress on the German economy than the loss of great industrial areas.

As another example, I will take the German army being cut down to 100,000 men. I would have thought that the German people would have been much more concerned about this than the loss of the land, because if they put one foot wrong, and upset one of the big powers, then all it would need was one invasion from the other country, and with no army to protect them, it would be like Manchester United, one of the best football teams in Europe taking on Tunbridge Wells football club, who are mid-tablers in the local league, there would be no contest. I think that that would worry the German people more than any loss of land, especially as after such a tragic and hard war, there wouldn't be many intelligent or reliable people lining up to run the country. The majority of people wanting to run the country would probably be insane patriots, and I don't think that would fill the Germans with confidence, especially with such a weak army. I think that this will also apply to another 4 terms of the treaty:
Join now!


. All wartime guns and weapons were to be melted down as scrap metal.

2. The German navy was to be cut to 36 ships. Germany were not allowed to have any submarines in future.

3. The Germans were not allowed to have an airforce of any kind at all.

4. Germany were forbidden ever to make an alliance with Austria ever again.

I think that this would have been harder for the Germans to cope with than the loss of land because like what I said before, they would not have felt safe, ...

This is a preview of the whole essay