• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Do you agree with this interpretation of the problems faced by the United StatesSoldiers in Vietnam?

Extracts from this document...


Do you agree with this interpretation of the problems faced by the United States Soldiers in Vietnam? Source a was published 17 years after the War, (Vietnam; 1964-1975).In this time more information was made available, but witnesses accounts maybe inaccurate due to this lapse in time The author is an American journalist, not a solider or frontline reporter, so his experience is not first hand. Consequently the text's "slant" is different. The title displays limitations; it's likely to be biased as it refers to the My Lai massacre. When in four hours, on an early Saturday morning in March 1968, between 300-400 villagers were killed as a regular search and destroy mission went terribly wrong. Under official orders, Unit Charlie Company had details the area; My Lai, was housing Vietcong members and sympathiser the unit had also been instructed that the villagers had left for market as it was a Saturday; the unit were under the impression to kill all who were left. But in reality no Vietcong were found or killed, only villagers, as they hadn't all left for market. ...read more.


This is not true. Because, the American forces were not conscripted at the same time, soldiers did not finish the tour of duty together. Consequently the army was a range of skills, "all the time", rookie to officer. And how a maximum of 40% of recruits ever returned home The source is biased, showing narrow mindedness. There's no balance of advantages or disadvantages. E.g. "The tour of duty, in Vietnam was one year. Soldiers were likely to die in that year." There are advantages, such as; an enthusiastic, energetic and fresh army. There are no figures, to support this quote. It doesn't mention American Soldiers had to differentiate between peasants and Vietcong. Neither does it mention the pressure on recruits; like, the 1968 Tet offensive, (Vietcong launched a major attack towards America. 70,000 VC soldiers took America by surprise on Tet holiday, 1500 U.S army killed). Or of the anti war movement, which effected a soldiers motivation, "I kill to live" a U.S private quoted, A view formed from the one sided media coverage perhaps? ...read more.


This is important as the methodical use of this warfare proved a challenge to America, due to it being scenario America was not accustomed to. Through out the war America found no real answer to this tactic. Perfected by Mao tse-tung's red army It required Vietcong units to operate as individuals, eliminating the enemy by retreating and returning to battle any survivors. The main aim was to exhaust the enemy. Guerrilla fighters summarised the tactics like so; * The enemy attacks, we retreat. * The enemy camps, we raid. * The enemy tire, we attack. * The enemy retreats, we pursue. Neither does it mention the psychological effect this had on its victims; The American army. How soldiers were constantly at fear of losing their life; through ambush, surprise, and especially to the horrific use of deadly, unhygienic and the most painful booby traps and mines. 11% of America deaths were due to this and even if troops did not come in contact with such traps, the very fear drove many men to state of mental incapacity, even long after the war. Consequently I don't agree with source a's interpretation of problems faced by united statues soldiers, because it does not justify what it is implying. ?? ?? ?? ?? Glenn Bridges 10BT ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Vietnam 1954-1975 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Vietnam 1954-1975 essays

  1. This statement suggests that television was an important reason why the United States lost ...

    This shows that television had an impact on America's loss in the war because millions of people could have been turned against the war by this being shown on television so therefore contributed to the loss of the war. Source K is the results of public opinion polls asking if

  2. Explain why the United States withdrew its forces from Vietnam in 1973

    Equipment supplied included valuable Soviet Anti-aircraft guns and missiles. Later on in the war, Soviet tanks also played a major role in the Viet Cong's success. The guerrilla tactics used by the Viet Cong also meant that the US air force was essentially taken out of action, as their bombs were of no use.

  1. Free essay

    Study Source A. Do you agree with this interpretation of the problems faced ...

    There are a number of possibilities such as the GI's in Charlie company for committing the atrocities, or Lieutenant Calley who should have stopped his GI's from killing or Calley's superiors and the United States government for training them to kill and creating the situation for this type of atrocity

  2. Did the power of television force the US to leave Vietnam?

    This source is useful as it shows us how people reacted to the situation that was occurring in Vietnam and it shows the views of the public. This helps us in some ways to see why America had to leave Vietnam as we can briefly sum up from this photograph

  1. Do you agree with this interpretation of the problems faced by United States soldiers ...

    Another reason which makes the source limited is that the source is only one person's opinion.

  2. How useful are sources A to C in helping to explain why the United ...

    A major reason for why America became involved with Vietnam was the American policy bought up by President Harry Truman on the 12th of March 1947 but at this time he was referring to the US supporting Greece and Turkey.

  1. 'Explain why the United States withdrew its forces from Vietnam in 1973'

    For France the war was over. Before the US got involved with troops, they were indirectly involved pay paying for much of the weapons and supplies. The US was in Vietnam at the time of the Cold War. The main reason the US was there was the fear of communism.

  2. How useful are the sources A to G for explaining why there was an ...

    Army during a peace-time period. It then goes on to mention how the tours of duty affected each soldier, with some dying in the first month of duty as this was "highly likely". Due to the soldier rotation and their differing lengths of duty (some of the soldiers were wounded,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work