• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Dunkirk was a Great Deliverance and a Great Disaster

Extracts from this document...


Dunkirk was a Great Deliverance and a Great Disaster Is there sufficient evidence in sources D-I to support this? A.J.P Taylor is a very respected British historian and for him to come up with such a contradictory quote there must have been some sort of evidence and a meaning to it, so to determine whether it was a deliverance or disaster we need to assess the positives and negatives of the evacuation, then decide on the sources reliability and utility to conclude if there is sufficient evidence. Source D was painted by Charles Cundall and he was given an artistic license, which means he didn't have to produce an accurate painting. The fact that he is British means he would have probably produced a painting the aim of which would have been to keep the morale of the British population high and contributed to the Dunkirk myth. This source agrees with the quote "Dunkirk was a great deliverance and a great disaster" as it shows men being rescued, the Blitzkrieg attack and boats that have capsized. ...read more.


The picture in itself however tells us very little apart from the fact we cannot see columns of men waiting to be rescued or any boats close by. Source G was part of a speech by Anthony Eden, the Minister of War. As it was made after the evacuation it is a secondary source albeit not by much and the fact that he was British and a Minister it is obviously biased. (Conversely, he was high up so will have had access to government archives and therefore has an intelligent opinion on the state of the BEF). Apart from "we have had great losses in equipment" there were no negatives and it was based heavily on improving public morale so would try to be picturing it as a deliverance; it did not mention the thousands of men lost or taken prisoner or any other bad points. The evidence in this source isn't sufficient enough to agree or disagree with the interpretation that "Dunkirk was a great deliverance and a great disaster." ...read more.


He is also the writer of the quote that the question is based on and supports it with evidence in the source such as "almost the entire BEF was saved" but also put forward the losses such as "Six destroyers had been sunk and nineteen damaged" and "The RAF had lost 474 planes" The source is a balanced view of Dunkirk. It mentions both the negative and positive aspects. Although the writer was the one who made the quote and provides evidence to support it, there is too much evidence providing different information for it to prove the quote right. In conclusion, Sources D and G both show the good and bad sides of the evacuation and corroborate with Source I which involves both in detail. Whereas, Sources E and F are unreliable as could be staged and neither point towards either deliverance or disaster and Source H agree with Source I in facts and opinion. Therefore the majority of evidence shows it was both a great deliverance and a great disaster because of the circumstances and what we know happened and will happen. ?? ?? ?? ?? By Ben Davies ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Britain 1905-1951 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Britain 1905-1951 essays

  1. Dunkirk - Defeat, Deliverance or Victory?

    Source 4 tells us that the returning army left behind most of its heavy equipment 600 tanks lost, more than 1000 filed guns, 850 anti-tank guns and a large number of lorries cars and motorbikes were left in France. I have gathered from this source that the fleeing solders did

  2. The Evacuation of Dunkirk.

    Many sources produced by the British declared that Dunkirk was a defeat for them and not a shining miracle. (SOURCE D8) This source above is from an English historian A.J.P Taylor, which was produced in 1965 about 25 years after Dunkirk evacuation.

  1. Was Dunkirk a defeat?

    They were very luckily because the smoke had saved them but not themselves. This source its not reliable because he could be traumatised by the whole event therefore this would criticize his judgement. From my knowledge I know that Luftwaffe couldn't see properly as there was a thick smoke, therefore they couldn't bomb effectively and kill.

  2. Dunkirk - Defeat, Deliverance or Victory?

    Germany did not really see Dunkirk as important so it wasn't really a victory for Germany, but it could definitely be linked to the temporary defeat of the British. The basic facts of defeat are, most importantly, the surrender or retreating of demoralized troops.

  1. Defeat, Deliverance or Victory? Which of these best describes Dunkirk?

    probably took the photographs and as the purpose is unknown it could be for German propaganda. This photograph could be of just one small area of messy and disorderly beach whilst the rest of the long beach could be nearly spotless.

  2. How successful was Dunkirk

    On the other hand the title of the book "Pillar of Fire" suggests Atkins has an agenda and wants to back up his dramatic view of Dunkirk. We must remember also that Atkins wants to make his book more dramatic in order to sell better.

  1. Was Dunkirk a Triumph?

    the information was more valid since it was changed by many people. The detail is also something that makes it more reliable since it isn?t just one sentence. The audience are GCSE students and the facts have to be correct so in conclusion i think this text is reliable.

  2. The Evacuation from Dunkirk in World War 2 was a great Disaster for Britain. ...

    It shows a soldier (possibly British) standing defiantly on the shores of Dunkirk with one arm in the air showing determination and courage. He is trying to portray to the Germans that he is not afraid; he is adamant not to give up and is showing a positive attitude.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work