• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How did the Village of Deir Yassin come to be Fought Over in 1948 and Why do Sources A and B Differ on who was to Blame for the Arab Flight from the Village and Other Parts of Palestine at that time?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

How did the Village of Deir Yassin come to be Fought Over in 1948 and Why do Sources A and B Differ on who was to Blame for the Arab Flight from the Village and Other Parts of Palestine at that time? Since Biblical times, the Jews had been moved from place to place with them only holding their only 'promised' state for a very small amount of time. The only wish the Jews had was to be in their holy city of Jerusalem but, after being banned from the city by the Romans, they dispersed around the world. In the late 5th century, the Romans abandoned Jerusalem and in the 8th century the Arabs began to live in the Palestine area. By the start of the 20th century, the Jews believed that God had promised that land to them and so it should belong to them. However, the Arabs, having lived there for 1100 years, did not want to become part of a newly-created state as they enjoyed Palestine as it was. The Arabs also believed Jerusalem to be a holy city. In 1516, The Ottoman Empire invaded Palestine, and for over 400 years, the Arabs did not have control over their land either. Both the Arabs and the Jews got their chance to have a homeland during the First World War. As the Ottoman Empire was supporting the Central Powers, the British decided that they would support an independent state to try and hinder the Turks. ...read more.

Middle

Palestinians however believe that Zionist forces massacred their innocent villagers. Source A shows the Palestinian view of the Deir Yassin bloodbath and is a propaganda pamphlet distributed in 1984, making it a secondary source. The pamphlet was created by the PLO (Palestinian Liberation Organisation), who believed that the Jews had invaded their territory and wanted Palestine to be the size it was before the formation of the state of Israel. The source's purpose was to try and persuade those reading the pamphlet that the Jews were heartless killers, and therefore should not be allowed to keep control of Jerusalem and the rest of Israel. This means that the source is probably biased towards the Arab ideals. The reliability of the source may also be questioned as this bias could influence people's perspective on events. The source is useful to historians as it allows them to see what the Palestinian command wanted others to think of what happened at Deir Yassin. In the source, the PLO state that the Zionist Government attacked the village of Deir Yassin and killed "154 men, women and children" and then mutilated their bodies. The source then goes on to blame the individual parts of the Zionist forces like the Irgun (the revolutionary militant force), the Stern Gang (a Jewish guerrilla militia) and the Haganah (the official Israeli army). The pamphlet states that the plot was to scare Arabs into leaving Palestine so Jews could take their place. ...read more.

Conclusion

The Arabs therefore left in early 1948 but it is disputed what made this evacuation happen. The Arabs say that they left after seeing the brutality of Deir Yassin whilst the Jews believe that the Arabs left under orders so that the army could move in. It is hard to blame one group for the exodus as both have some responsibility in the matter. The Arabs refused to allow Jews into their society and the Jews used unnecessary force in order to achieve their goals of a homeland. The actions of groups such as the Stern Gang and others who blew up hotels and whoever organised the massacre at Deir Yassin were seen as brutal and unnecessary by the majority of the world, as there were many innocent civilian casualties. Sources A and B differ for many reasons but mainly because of a national bias. The Jews in Israel have grown up learning to believe the Arabs are criminals and vice versa. Therefore, the writers of these sources cannot be blamed for any bias or unreliability in them as they are only reporting what they believe to be true. However, another unbiased source is needed to successfully reach a conclusion. If there was a source written by someone without bias, then this could be used to check details given in sources A and B and then the real chain of events could be worked out. This could tell us who is really responsible for the refugees of Palestine. Page 1 of 4 Page 1 of 4 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE International relations 1945-1991 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE International relations 1945-1991 essays

  1. There has been a significant Palestinian refugee problem for the last fifty years. Do ...

    The sources are useful as they show what each party wanted the public to think. Emotive language is used in both sources to try and gain sympathy from the reader with source A saying that the civilians were killed in "cold blood" and source B saying that the Arab perspective

  2. Deng and the Gang of Four

    From 1984 - 89 it was at its best because of its Growth domestic product, the table shows there was a lack of consistency with the profit and output. Manufacturing was at is best at 14.5% in 1984 and best GDP growth and inflation rate.

  1. Did the PLO achieve anything using terrorism

    UN plan to try and resole the problems between Israel and Palestinians. However, although there were advantages of terrorism, it had a negative effect on the worldwide opinion of the Palestinian cause. Also, the PLO was seen as ruthless and brutal for their terrorist activities, and this reduced the sympathy for the Palestinian people.

  2. Why has there been conflict between Israel and her Arab neighbours since 1973?

    However as the wall was in Occupied Territory the Security wall was declared illegal in 2004. An additional reason for conflict is the Palestinian Economic conditions in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Over 50% of Palestinians are unemployed and face serious prejudice and discrimination if they look for other work in Israel.

  1. " Individuals do not 'shape' historical events; the best they can do is to ...

    This source is very useful to us, because it gives a contradictory view towards Che Guevara, compared to all the other books and sources I have read. It is a primary source, and one of few that I have found that did not like Che Guevara or the way he went about his actions.

  2. Cold War Short Essays - Questions and Answers.

    Explain why relations between Cuba and USA worsened in the years 1959-61 (12 marks) One reason why relations worsened was because of Fidel Castro?s revolution in Cuba. Cuba had been dictated by Batista who was very pro-capitalist and thus, pro-USA.

  1. Edexcel Cold War 1943-1991 Revision (Detailed)

    1959 Nuclear War summit with Khruschev and Eisenhower but nine days before the next conference the Soviet Union had announced it shot down an American U-2 spy plane. Eisenhower was prepared to stop the flights but not to apologise. By January 1961 20,000 were leaving East for west per month.

  2. Cold War Summary, quotes and revision notes.

    Soviet Union --> COMECON tied the economies of Eastern Europe to soviet system. * Sport race - Olympics Great interest in whether or not East German or Soviet athletes outperformed Americans.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work