• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'To what extent did Protestant support for an independent Ireland change in the period 1798 - 1921?'

Extracts from this document...


'To what extent did Protestant support for an independent Ireland change in the period 1798 - 1921?' The Union with Britain in 1801 was one of convenience, but only to the minority of the Protestant North who relied on the power of the British empire in economics, law and as Peaple said 'civilising' Ireland and also as S. J. Connolly said 'the indigenous Catholic peasantry.' Since the protestant landlord class settled in Ireland there has been immense strains and grievances, though we cannot say that Protestant support for the Union was always there, due to varying opinions of Irish Nationalists and of the Protestants. Also, the struggle to repeal the 1800 Act of Union succeeded, however the reason for this somewhat over-delayed ending was to a certain extent not the result of Britain's determination to maintain Ireland as part of the empire. When trying to see if Protestant support for an independent Ireland changed then we have to study certain events making close reference to events and particular historical outlooks. ...read more.


To the majority of British Prime Minister's they saw Ireland as lawless and felt that intervention by force was necessary and Adelman suggests that it was this lack of understanding that caused some of the troubles. Though, Kennedy and Johnson believe that it was the fact that the Protestants "Ruling Ascendancy didn't want to be ruled by Westminster" and they liked to rule themselves. It has been argued that following the post-war recession of 1815, with falling agricultural prices and financial deficit, the Union with Britain was arguably acting as a catalyst for the subsequent state of Ireland's internal decay. It's apparent that Britain was taking everything it could out of Ireland and was giving nothing back and the Ruling elite in Ireland, the Protestants were worried that the British market was out competing the Irish one and thus revenue coming into Ireland was grinding to a halt. Kennedy and Johnson go on to say that this fact online meant that some Protestants questioned the gains of the 'Union' during this period and felt that it 'was a one sided arrangement'. ...read more.


Charles Stewart Parnell, had legitimate control over the Land League, and was also respected amongst the Fenians, and had an able control over a loose coalition of nationalist groups. This meant that he had the majority of the control over the Irish. We can see that when Edward Carson came into power over the unionists, unionism as a political force grew out of Protestant fears that 'Home Rule' would mean 'Rome Rule in reaction to implementation of 'de-Anglicisation' by the Nationalists. It possible to say that the Irish Nationalists split into two distinct sections with Protestant support for an independent Ireland with the notion of a self- governing Ulster Union and those who saw the rebirth of Irish Nationalism as strictly Catholic and therefore supported the Union more strongly for economical and social benefits of the Union. We can say the Protestant support during this time period changes dramatically due to a number of issues but coexistence was never going to be seen in a independent Ireland because of the fundamental issues of religion and lifestyles. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Northern Ireland 1965-85 essays

  1. In what ways did the Irish Question change between 1800 and 1922?

    It was clear that Home Rule would not be enough anymore and the British Government would have to think of alternative solutions. Sinn Fein, which means 'Ourselves Alone', was a militant non-violent organisation and it owed much of its support to the fact that it had been wrongly blamed for the Easter Rebellion.

  2. How realistic is a United Ireland in the context of past and present events? ...

    anything short of the exclusion of the whole of Ulster from Home Rule. In the December 1918 election, Unionists won 24 of the 39 Ulster seats, with separatist Sinn Fein securing 10 of the 15 seats won by nationalists. December 1918 to the British House of Commons from Ireland declared the independence of the Irish Republic.

  1. "In the years 1865-1868 the Fenians did not pose a serious threat to British ...

    Extract C is from the Archbishop Paul Cullen's letter to the Roman Catholic Clergy of Dublin, October 1865. The Archbishop may have a biased view because he will have approved the views of the Catholic Church. For that reason he will have tried to disgrace the Fenian movement, by using emotive language, i.e.

  2. How Effectively did Irish Catholic and Nationalist Leaders advance their Cause in the years ...

    the increased grant to Maynoch College (the main seminary for training Catholic clergy in Ireland). All these factors combined to derail the movement completely. O'Connell died in 1847. O'Connell, it seems, was an effective Catholic rather than Nationalist leader, as his aims were clear on religious terms, such a catholic emancipation, but unclear about what he wanted politically.

  1. How far do these sources support the veiw that Irish Nationalism was a 'curious ...

    Though Parnell was less concerned about the emergence of the catholics than O'Connell, he still realised that to be effective he must have the support of the Roman Catholic Church.

  2. Why were some forms of opposition more successful than others in the period 1798-1921?

    Charles Stewart Parnell had taken over from the relatively unsuccessful Isaac Butt. Butt set up the Home Rule association in 1870 in Dublin in aims for advancing the Nationalist cause of unionism. Parnell was elected as leader of the IPP in 1880.

  1. Ireland - Modern World Study

    and Direct Rule began on the 24th March 1972. Many have said that Direct Rule came three years too late. If there had been an intervention then maybe the 'troubles' may not have happened. Direct Rule did not seem to improve the situation.

  2. The History of Conflict in Ireland.

    They were emboldened by the imposition of direct rule. They could see what damage it did to their Unionist opponents. They believed that Unionists would then begin to start asking questions about the nature of the British guarantee, and that that might persuade some Unionists to move in the direction of some form of Irish unity.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work