• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Where Did Power Lie in the Third Reich?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Where Did Power Lie in the Third Reich? " The essential political decisions were taken by a single individual, in this case by Hitler." (Jackel)! It has been said that at the heart of the power system of Nazi Germany there was a confusion of private Empires. This is true to some extent but overall power lay with Hitler. Hitler had ultimate power but how he exercised it is a different issue. The traditional view that Historians used which is also known as the, 'Intentionalist' theory was that Hitler was Master of the Third Reich, which was a totalitarian state. Other historians such like Mommsen and Brozat have said of this view to be too simplistic. They say the Nazi system was feudal, chaotic and polycratic. Mommsen describes Hitler as a 'weak dictator.' This school of thought is known as the 'Structuralist' theory. They counter attack the argument of the Third Reich being a Totalitarian state because there was no set ideology and no one member had complete power. All Historians agree that Hitler dominated Germany from 1933 - 1945, however the extent of his power and how he used it has been greatly debated. The first issue to discuss is how Hitler came to power and then how he consolidated it. Hitler became chancellor in January 1933 whereby Van Papen claimed that he would be pushed into a corner, "so hard he'll be squeaking." Hitler straight way called for elections, which were to be held in March. The campaign to the election was violent to say the least. Goering used his powers as Minister of Interior in Prussia and head of the police to recruit more people in the Gestapo and break up Communist meetings. Various posters were published which appealed to the middle class and the working class after the collapse and depression the Weimar Government had left them in. He spoke to the public asking for 4 years to transform this crumbling country. ...read more.

Middle

No one could block his will and he was prepared to use his power if he felt threatened as can be seen in The Night of the Long Knives. Although other people influenced their legislation one has to see that they had to convince Hitler first because he had ultimate power and everyone was 'working towards the Fuhrer.' This is probably the most significant issue because it meant that Hitler didn't have to intervene over day to day issues as everyone was implementing the will of the Fuhrer and nothing would be done without his central ideas. Some say that he didn't intervene because he liked the discontent among his party, as this didn't directly challenge his power. He trusted the likes of Goebbels and Himmler to be loyal and was never concerned about their power. His real power can be seen when it came to decision making. Hitler provided the overall vision, which was then turned into policies by people around him. If anything was to happen it could happen on the basis of Hitler's will. Although Hitler had overall power that didn't mean that he was the only person with power. Hitler had co-ordinated nearly all threats to his position and had made the Nazi party the only legal party. A 'threat' therefore could be from within the party. The role of key individuals such as Bormann, Goebbels, Himmler is essential to the 'success' of the Nazi party and it can be argued that without these people the Nazi party wouldn't have been what it was. Hitler somewhat laid the foundations of what he wanted doing and these people in charge of their own departments went and did it. Once in power the party was seen as a career opportunity for some and they were more concerned with personal advancement. However most Nazi officials held high positions.. Martin Bormann joined the party in February 1927 and rose quickly through the ranks of the Nazi party. ...read more.

Conclusion

These people had considerable power and communicated directly with Hitler and had a lot of influence on the legislative process. By using these people Hitler could control the states and have his policy implemented. The only institution that Hitler had to worry about was the army and he couldn't afford to rush to try and co-ordinate it. He already gained their support by weakening the SA but even still Hitler was worried that they posed a threat to his regime so he left it mainly untouched until 1938. The state and the army were seen as one and the army generals mainly co-operated with Hitler as they shared his view on military actions and Anti-Bolshevism. It was in 1937 when Hitler really started to take over when he dismissed Blomberg and Fritsch Hitler then became Commander in Chief of all armed forces. Hitler now had almost complete control over all elements of Germany. Although he didn't control every element of every institution he now weakened them to such an extent that they would not threaten his position. Therefore in conclusion it can be said that no one had ultimate power in the Third Reich, the simple reason being because it wasn't a Totalitarian state. However the conclusion that can be drawn is that overall power lay with the Fuhrer. His policy of co-ordination had worked to a great extent as all external institutions that posed a threat had been Nazified. The only thing that could pose a threat was the party, but the discontent and chaos and then the idea of 'working towards the Fuhrer' made sure that no one directly challenged Hitler or his power. Although his image has been somewhat glorified and the concept of him being master is too simple, one can not argue against the fact that no one within the party challenged Hitler and no major laws passed without his permission which takes me back to the first statement: " The essential political decisions were taken by a single individual - in this case by Hitler." (Jackel) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Germany 1918-1939 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Germany 1918-1939 essays

  1. To what extent was Hitler a totalitarian dictator?

    He replaced the trade unions with the Nazi run 'Nazi Labour Front'. To please the public and justify the change. He had to tell the masses a believable story about communism, as it was a popular enemy, hence the convenient Reichstag fire plot.

  2. How significant was Nazi Propaganda in maintaining Hitler in power in the years ...

    Even under these circumstances propaganda was able to persuade the majority of the public that war was unavoidable and that it had been forced on the Government (Welch, Nazi Propaganda, 1983, p.186). When considering propaganda in terms of exploiting foreign policy successes one cannot ignore the fact that whilst propaganda

  1. The weak Weimar government was a major factor in Hitler rise to power, however ...

    The end of World War I shocked many people. Most of these people were the citizens of Germany. The German army intended to deliver the German Offensive of 1918, this final attack would guarantee German victory. The government then pushed the German citizens to hang on just a little longer so they may be the victorious country.

  2. Were the events which took place during the Night of the Long Knives (June ...

    on 29 June that "I have the impression that we - Army and SA - are being egged on against each other by a third party,"22 whereupon Reichneau replied, "That may be true, but it's too late now."23 Reichneau saying this on the 29th of June is significant, as it

  1. With whom does the responsibility of the holocaust ultimately lie?

    They always only allow one political party, the ruling party tries to force its ideas on the rest of society and tries to stop people believing in other ideas and the ruling party aims to control all aspects of people's lives - there is no area where the citizen is left to think or act as he or she pleases.

  2. How hitler rose to power

    Moreover, Hitler called the German government "November criminals" as the treaty was signed in November; this showed the public that he was truly against them. In every public meeting, parades or mass rallies Hitler was incredible at capturing the audience attention and captivating them with his words.

  1. To what extent was the backstairs intrigue responsible for Hitler being able to take ...

    We shall stage a masterpiece of propaganda. And this time, naturally, there is no lack of money." (5) Hitler's opponents had brought him to power thinking that they could control "the Austrian corporal." Papen even boasted: "Within two months we will have pushed Hitler so far in the corner that he'll squeak." But they fatally underestimated him.

  2. Nazi Germany - who supported Hitler and how did he become a dictator?

    These were given to him by President Hindenburg on the 28th. The Nazis then used these powers to arrest Communists, break up meetings and scare voters. But the election went as planned, and the Nazis won their biggest ever share of the votes, and with the support of the smaller Nationalist Party, Hitler had an overall majority in the Reichstag.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work