• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically Evaluate Freud's Theory.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Critically Evaluate Freud's Theory Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) he was Jewish and educated in Vienna, where he trained in medicine. Freud was the founder of psychoanalysis. He was the first psychologist to recognise the importance of the conscious and unconscious mind. His theory was psychoanalysis. The value and validity of his theory has been greatly questioned, since its inception in the early 1900s. His critics and devotees, see the answer lying in opposite extremes. Having him all the magician or all the messiah, was he either? Was Sigmund Freud a great medical scientist who uncovered important truths about human psychology? Or was he something different? His theories offer a science, but his critics of psychoanalysis question whether or not it is indeed a science; the value of Freud's data, the methods that he used and the effectiveness of the treatments. Throughout this essay I intend to show the positive and negative criticisms of Freud's theory psychoanalysis. Freud spent many years hypothesizing about the role of dreams and their interpretation. He argued that dreams allowed a person to discharge otherwise unacceptable and unconscious wishes and urges. He defines the state of sleep to be a period of uproar and chaos during which the unconscious thoughts of the (Id) attempt to force their way into consciousness. ...read more.

Middle

If we are unaware of the forces that guide us, then it follows that we are not capable of intervening to change or go against them. (Slife&Williams 1995). Jung and Adler disagreed with Freud about the idea of such a pervasive sexual instinct, and proposed their own ideas of what motivated human behaviour. Grunbaun(1986) believes that the reasoning on which Freud based his entire psychoanalytic theory was "fundamentally flawed, even if the validity of his clinical evidence were not in question" but that "the clinical data are themselves suspect; more often than not, they may be patients responses to the suggestions and expectations of the analyst". Additional critics contend that Freud's clinical data are flawed or invalid. Greenberg (1986) believes that Freud's case studies do not place enough stress on revealing the outcome of the treatment and that Freud's aim was more to illustrate his theoretical points. In addition Freud fully presented only 12 cases, but mentioned over 100 minor cases. Greenberg asserts that many of the presented cases would not even be considered acceptable examples of psychoanalysis, and that all of Freud's cases had basic shortcomings. Finally Greenberg finds it "both skirting and curious that Freud chose to illustrate the usefulness of psychoanalysis through the display of unsuccessful cases" Other powerful critics, (Colby 1960) ...read more.

Conclusion

Finally to evaluate the critics Grunbaun (1986) asserts that "while psychoanalysis may thus be said to be scientifically alive, it is currently hardly well". The criticisms of Freud's theory can be grouped into three general categories. First, critics contend that Freud's theory was lacking in empirical evidence and relies too heavily on therapeutic achievements, whereas others assert that even Freud's clinical data are flawed, inaccurate and selective at best. Second, the actual method or technique involved in psychoanalysis, such as Freud's ideas on the interpretation of dreams and the role of free association, have been criticised. Finally, some critics assert that psychoanalysis is simply not a science and many of the principles upon which it is based are inaccurate. Eysenck and Wilson (1973) there is not one study which one could point to with confidence and say "Here is definitive support of this or that Freudian notion." In conclusion many of the critics and devotees of Sigmund Freud all have valuable opinions, to which I have shown throughout this essay. However, despite the weaknesses of psychoanalysis I believe that the many strengths of the theory are extremely significant and have withstood the test of time and are widely used today. Therefore in my own opinion psychoanalysis should not be disregarded. Although many criticisms exist, there are as many arguments, if not more, in support of the rich and diverse contributions that Freud's theory gave to psychoanalysis. His legacy lives on indisputable form. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Psychology essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    In this essay I will evaluate and explain the Social Learning Theory (SLT), which ...

    5 star(s)

    * It is important that a debriefing is held afterwards, so the researcher can discuss what the actual purpose of the study was and to help the participant if they feel uncomfortable because of the deception used. Field experiment * This is an experiment carried out in the natural environment of the participants e.g.

  2. Peer reviewed

    Freud's theory of psycho-sexual development

    5 star(s)

    She also accuses him of not studying the particular sexuality of women, and basing it on the masculine pattern. De Beauvoir objects to Freud's theory of psycho-sexual development on two counts- Freud assumes that the little girl feels that she has been castrated and is a mutilated little boy, and

  1. Critically evaluate Nancy Chodorow's theory of the origins of gender identity in childhood. In ...

    For the female, Chodorow believes the identification process is relational dependant on the quality and closeness relationship with her mother. The girl then becomes a separate individual through 'secondary identification' (Chodorow 1978). Chodorow is in agreement with Freud's belief that a girl will feel hostility at some stage towards her

  2. A Critical Examination of the Sexual Life of Man In Sigmund Freud.

    These have their sources in special organs or organs system and account for the activities that are naturally determined. This means that instinct has rendered the sexual responsiveness of man deterministic in nature and he cannot but opt for a way of gratifying this innate urge.

  1. Different Theories and theorists in Human behaviour

    Roger's see people as good or healthy. Basically, he sees the mental health as the normal progression of life, and he sees mental illness, criminality, and other human problems, as distortions of that natural tendency. Rogers' theory is quiet basic the whole theory is built on a single "force of life" he, the he calls the actualising tendency.

  2. Psychoanalytical Theory.

    E.G., infants who have unsatisfied needs for oral stimulation may be more likely to smoke as adults or toddlers who were toilet trained very early may be obsessively concerned with neatness and cleanness. Few of these predictions have in fact been supported, but the general view that the events in

  1. In what way is the technique of 'Free Association' valuable for the practice of ...

    The patient was in therapy before and his main complaint was about his panic in becoming a warewolf and going to hell. Dreams with wolves and warewolves were also experienced by him. This started when he was a child and as an adolescent just after he started masturbation he replaced

  2. Psychoanalytical Theory

    The infant, at this point is very self absorbed. The Id is uncontrolled until the child is about three years old. At that point the Ego starts to take over the Id and is attempting to shape the child's life to fit in with society (Gibbons, 1977).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work