• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Demonstrate how art can make contrasting contributions to religious questions.

Extracts from this document...


Demonstrate how art can make contrasting contributions to religious questions. The Supper at Emmaus was one of Caravaggio later works when he had fully developed his style. Caravaggio was interested in portraying Jesus as a mortal man one reachable by everyone whether they are a priest or a sinner like Caravaggio rather than a supernatural, transcendent being that shines down upon those few good Christians. This painting shows Jesus after the resurrection revealing his identity to two disciples with whom he has spent all day, he does this by breaking the bread as he did at the last supper, it is very much about the power of the resurrection and holy communion . He doesn't paint the conventional Jesus he paint him a little podgy with no beard and a different shaped face and numerous imperfections' as a man with faults. He put Jesus in a dark and dingy room with the company of a common landlord, reaching to the common man which shows us that Caravaggio concerned about his eternal destiny. ...read more.


Firstly The Supper at Emmaus, it was commissioned by a Roman nobleman and later purchased by a Cardinal. Turner was painting to portray a particular message, a painting for himself and the world. He was much more concerned about aesthetics than Caravaggio and showing the beauty in nature, Gods gift to man. Here he contrasts natures beauty and power, it wrath, possibly showing Gods intervention into mans deeds. Caravaggio's was a church painting one that was seen through conventional ideas of religion though he was challenging the accepted boundaries of religious icons at the same time as many in the Church where involved in the Counter Reformation. But he was still portraying Jesus and religion in the flesh where as Turner shows the spiritual side God's messages through beauty in nature rather than scriptures. Caravaggio's in many ways was still restricted by the conventions of the church; Turner had to answer to no one. It is paradoxical that Caravaggio was painting in the Renaissance at one of the most spiritual ages in history, when life was dominated by spirituality and the Pope still had a significant influence over all aspects of Christian life. ...read more.


What is the ultimate being and how can it be viewed? How does this power access and communicate with man kind? Turner and Caravaggio, I think, address all these questions turner's art makes a bold statement on religion he was a great pioneer of romanticism and answers all these questions with one answer, nature. He says we see and communicate with the highest being through nature. He says nature is our salvation. And when looking at the true beauty in nature you see his point how can that stupendous beauty be an accident or random it must be in some way sculpted mustn't it. And I think his art shows this more than any other iv seen. Caravaggio's art answers these questions very differently he shows us that man is saved by Jesus and by conventional religion. He says the Christian god is the ultimate being and the closest he can be viewed is Jesus as a man and not as a spiritual being and his communication is through the bible. These are much more conservative answers but Caravaggio's puts them forward to be reachable by the every day man, and in that I think he succeeds. ?? ?? ?? ?? Joe Brann Thursday, 06 March 2008 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Miscellaneous essays

  1. Aboriginal Spirituality

    Art and symbolism is one way that the Dreaming is expressed. Aboriginal art explains how the dreaming describes the origins and the creation of the universe and its components. These are used as stories and explanations to children in regards to right and wrong.

  2. Environmental Philosophy Reflection

    However, a major flaw is that the people have to pay more for using renewable resources than using non-renewable resources. (A hydrogen car is more expensive than a petroleum car.) Hence, we can say that the market prices set for products don't include the costs that future generations will have

  1. Explain the meaning and significance of Baptism for Christians today with particular reference to ...

    This may be linked with Jesus' baptism or life as he was Jewish. The infant is welcomed at the door and this symbolises that the child is welcomed into a new community of believers. The child is held up in front of the font facing east.

  2. Concepts of Beauty in Philosophy

    Aristotle's belief is that everything exists in this world and amongst everything in this world there are some things that are truly beautiful. This provides the basis for an interest in beauty and art. I believe that Aristotle was very important in paving the way for the modern concept of

  1. Heaven and Hell - general views, traditional and liberal Christian views.

    We are going to be brand new individuals that will inherit eternal life that is imperishable. Liberal Christians believe that, we have to listen to the word of the Lord and implement them in our daily lives. By doing what God wants us to do to have a better physical

  2. Science and Religion do they have anything to offer each other?

    in the place to condemn religion because it is difficult for him to understand the true meaning of faith. McGrath disagrees with Dawkins when he says that God is ?a petty unjust, unforgiving control-freak? saying that in the New Testament Jesus shows that God was a kind and forgiving God,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work